Jump to content

Mischlings


BlueBolts

Recommended Posts

There's been numerous queries/discussions on mischling's so I thought I'd start a thread for all members to discuss, and share their experiences...etc

Mischlings are a "shrimp" category describing a TB (Taiwan Bee - King Kong, Blue Bolt & Wine Red) x with a CRS/CBS/GB (Golden Bee)/SW (Snow White). Breeders will often cross their TB with a CRS/CBS/GB/SW to introduce the TB gene's into their stock, just in case disaster hits, plus it multiplies their probability of TB shrimplets etc.....Minchlings are then used to x back to a TB, which will result in a % of TB off it's shrimplets.

Mischling x Mischling won't neccesarily produce any TB....my personal experience extends to F3 generation, and to date, this has not resulted in any TB's. I've been told that a F5/F6 mischling still does not produce any TB's.

Hobbyist keen to take the next step to TB's should really purchase a TB 1st, x with their existing stock to create mischling's, then once they are confident, can either purchase more TB's to x back to their mischlings, or if budget and tank permits, purchase more then 1 x TB, and get their TB colony happening sooner.

Purchasing mischling's should always be done with a reputable breeder, or one that can show and proof that the mischling did come from a TB cross.

Pics of some CBS/CRS minchlings ....they tend to look like lower grade or washed out CRS/CBS, although I have some minchlings that actually look quite good, so it's difficult to ascertain whether you're actually buying a low grade CRS/CBS or a minchling .... unfortunately, there will be people out there that will take advantage of this....

post-480-13990985764_thumb.jpgpost-480-139909857643_thumb.jpgpost-480-139909857645_thumb.jpgpost-480-139909857648_thumb.jpg

Any other experiences, thoughts, queries appreciated, as it seems to be frequently queried ....

post-24-139909857576_thumb.jpg

post-24-13990985758_thumb.jpg

post-24-139909857582_thumb.jpg

post-24-139909857584_thumb.jpg

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the great info BB!

So to start any TB gene, it's best to get one TB M/F to breed with any of your CBS/CRS? Any other differences to keeping CRS/CBS?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great write up Marcus, I'm looking to get some when I am back from holidays.

Is it minchling or mischling? Mischlingis german for crossbreed so I assumed it was that, I have seen 3 different ways to say it though so I am confused.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the write up.

I'm wondering why you would cross the TB with a CRS to produce mischlings rather than simply breeding breeding TB to TB?

I.e. Could you maybe explain why you would want to produce mischlings if your aim is to produce TBs?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great info there Marcus.

I think i might try out some mishlings next winter:encouragement:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sprae - TB's a more sensitive and difficult in comparison to CRS's....so definite progression would be cherries, CRS's, TB's ......Like many, lots of $$$ spend with no success, but with failure comes wisdom/experience, and eventually hopefully success.

fishmosy - $$$ is unfortunatley one of the main motivators of decisions. So a person venturing into TB's may not want to spend the $ on an immediate colony, and purchase just 1 TB, to prove and gain confidence of their shrimp breeding skill.

If a hobbyist just want to purchase 1 TB, I tend to recommend getting a male...this way, he can berry as many female CRS/CBS, and get the TB genetics into your breeding stock. There are more potential issues with berried females, so to be on the safe and productive side of the breeding equation, having one berried TB female vs several berried CRS female off a TB gives you more numbers and favourable odds.

TB x Mischling will give you a good potential of TB's within it's off springs, whereas mischling x mischling = potentially 0.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks for the write up bluey!!! guys minchlings are very very helpful in the taiwan bee breeding missions! it will always strengthen the genes of your future taiwans bees with the introduction of crs and cbs genes :) as proof of their usefulness here is an old thread of mine which showed the results of crossing cbs minchlin females with my blue bolt male.

http://www.shrimpkeepersforum.com/forum/showthread.php/594-BB-x-CBS-Minchling-results!!!

anyone else with success please add a link here to make this thread more informative :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for clearing that up Bluebolts.

Its seems to me that there seems to be less hesitation/ more acceptance to create hybrid shrimp compared to creating hybrid fish, unless I'm mistaken in thinking TB and CRS are different species.

Can someone really justify saying that they have TBs when they have been produced from CRS x TB parents (particularly if selling them as TB)? Should we be concerned with maintaining "pure" strains of shrimp or because most of our shrimp have been bred to be so different from the original species collected from the wild that it doesn't matter?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very interesting thread. Thanks for the writeup and I look forward to more

threads on this topic

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They're all just mutations of the same species, Caridina cantonensis. So by crossinf them, you're not making hybrids, just crossing line bred versions of the same species.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's no real way to confirm a mischling vs CRS/CBS. Mischling tends to appear washed out, void of through colour/depth, BUT so are low grade CRS/CBS......as mentioned previously reputable breeder is strongly recommended.

Perhaps the reason that not many mischling appear FS in international forums are due to these issues, and reputable breeders do not want to be accused of selling non-mischling etc.....

+1 on Gbang & Matt_95 .....

In Oz, TB's @ it's infancy stage, so lots for all of us to learn and share. Perhaps some of our international members can add and comment on this thread .... & Dean ..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They're all just mutations of the same species' date=' Caridina cantonensis. So by crossinf them, you're not making hybrids, just crossing line bred versions of the same species.[/quote']

Thanks Matt, I was under the illusion they were derived from different species.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the great explanation. And $$$ saving tip by crossing a TB male with existing female stock. Does it matter what grades the CRS /CBS are?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Simont,

Generally not....BUT, I'm trying to selective breed TB's to have a mosura pattern, so theoretically and genetically I'm pairing up mischling mosura's with my TB's.

Mischlings are generally seen to just be a carrier of TB gene's, so it's grades does not matter ...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

yeh thought so, was just wondering cuz all the charts in the other thread was always showing with CBS. But thanks! cant wait to get into TB's!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Thanks Matt_95 and Bluebolts on Mischlings...Can anyone tell me about PINTO? Not sure about them like Mischlings ? Cheers CJ

They're all just mutations of the same species, Caridina cantonensis. So by crossinf them, you're not making hybrids, just crossing line bred versions of the same species.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pinto's are still a guarded secret international breeder keep. We've just got to figure it out with x's etc....lots of speculations and theories out there...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So the TB genes carried by the CBS/CRS Mischling are recessive? Meaning probably less than a 25% chance of (what could be considered a TB) return in F1 of a Mischling/TB cross? With improving rates of TB characteristics in F2 onwards through selection right?

The Gene Genie Out

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 7 months later...

This thread answered my question about what a mischling is, but since this was all written, has there been any changes or advances with the info?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Info remains, with the exception of many hobbyist experiencing TB's off Mishling x Mishling. The resulting juvies of these are referred to TBMM, whereas TB x Mishlings are referred to TBM. These do not have pure TB genes, and their price are reflected by this...as TBM x TBMM for example, can produce a % of mishlings...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      I have just done the planned weekly maintenance and 10% water change and everything 'seems' to be going very well, I saw 12 blue and 9 panda shrimps so am very happy about that as there are always some hiding (and they are small) so there must be more than that at this point. Early days yet (especially with the off parameters) with the blues only been in the tank for a week and the pandas for 2 weeks. Not seen any dead ones yet and the shrimp seem happy enough and beautiful colour and pattern, all small so must be young! Parameters were TDS 159, GH 7-8, KH 1-2, PH 7 yesterday so still a bit off the usual ideal! Hopefully these figures come down slowly in time, I used pure RO water for the water change so Tds should drop 10. I will get a different PH test kit with a narrower range/increments as the one I have measures in .5 increments over a wide range which is probably a bit much. I bought these shrimp because the sellers parameters (PH 6.8) were the closest to mine so hopefully it will work out long term. I changed my zerowater filter as well, as the old one was measuring TDS 6 so passed its best. I will definitely overnight drip acclimate shrimp in the future, not that I plan any more in the forseeable future. I will add/edit photo when available, hopefully later today.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      All done now, I drip acclimated 11 blue bolts and 6 blue steel overnight and they are now in the tank so now is just wait and see if this works. 28 shrimps have now been put in and I have yet to SEE a dead one so fingers crossed! A couple of pictures of some below; I don't plan on buying any more shrimp so plan this to be a blue shrimp tank, though if it doesn't work out I have seen some female bettas I would like, but hopefully the shrimps will work out. The water parameters are still the same as before, so a bit off! I need to sort out what foods and shrimp stuff I have in the drawers and cupboard tomorrow as it's been a while, hopefully I find a shrimp lolly so I can give them one/part of those tomorrow, and it may bring as many of the shrimps out as possible.  Fingers crossed everyone...........  
    • NoGi
    • jayc
      LoL. Just look back at old posts on the forum.  
    • NoGi
      New, when i left i shut down everything. This is my first tank back. I've forgotten so much lol
×
×
  • Create New...