Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Neo-shrimp

2014 Shrimp Price Guide

Recommended Posts

BristledOne

Seeing mention of genetics and phenotypes etc reminds me of something I read once, "Cubing"

-edit- Spent so long typing this and I realize it's in a way off topic so I'm going to make a thread to flesh out my thoughts. I'd really appreciate peoples opinions on it though once the topics up

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
viridisornatus

Not to derail the conversation but have people actually had mischlings from TBMxTBM or is this a hypothetical example? That would be very interesting genetically.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
CNgo2006
Not to derail the conversation but have people actually had mischlings from TBMxTBM or is this a hypothetical example? That would be very interesting genetically.

TBM meaning TBMischling x TBMischling, I assume then most definitely. TB x TB is the rarity

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
clipper

Price reflects demand, nothing more. No 'good' breeder sells his best stock so it can't exactly be surprising that everyone wants a piece of the apple by offering cheaper alternatives to people who want to have a good. I only have cherry shrimp and the ride from reds to yellows to browns, then blacks and now blue and green has been exciting. One only has to stop and wonder though, that these colours have only recently been available, so how these colours were created nobody can really confirm or deny inbreeding or colour crossing. You can only buy what you see in a photo, nothing more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
michael

I have to disagree with you there. We are not saying, that people are being ripped of due to lack of quality. We are saying they are being deceived buy the seller to what they are getting. When u buy a shrimp where the. Seller Claim it to be a Pb bb and you pay for a bb then realise in 12 months when it finally breeds that there are mostly mishling babies then you will feel jipped. There is a market for tbm however it needs to be clearly stated that's what they are not hidden. If this means there are 2 different prices in our price list all the better then it's all transparent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
neosin

I've noticed a lot of deceptive conduct recently with taiwan bees

Generally if you see an ad for sale without any mention of "PURE" in the description, it's pretty safe to assume the seller is selling TBMs

Most sellers have adopted the "If you don't ask then i'm not lying" approach to justify their actions!

We should change the SKF rules so that all sellers claiming PURE should be required to state whos PURE line they are from and when they started breeding them :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

One of the primary reason's why the TBM & TBMM was discussed & created was to ensure new hobbyist to the shrimp world are aware of the difference genetically, with the $ reflecting their purity. I would assume & hope that hobbyist selling TB's, would mention their purity *i.e. TB, TBM or TBMM, so that newbies enquire the difference, and the knowledge spreads etc..

When I see a "TB" FS, I would assume it's a pure TB, ie. TBxTB of at least 2+ generations of breeding true, and not just F2, as this would still throw out mishlings etc….

So..

TB x Mish = TBM

TB x TBM = say 50% TB(1), 50% Mishling

TB x TB(1) = 75% TB(2), 25% Mishling

TB x TB (2) = 100% TB(3) …….This is F1

TB x TB (3) = 100% TB(4) …….This is F2

TB x TB (4) = 100% TB(5) …….This is F3

…the equation gets more complicated if a TBM, TBMM or even a mishling is introduced between the above sequence.

As most of the comments have mentioned, it's back to trusting the breeder, as the above "family tree" can be manipulated.

Thoughts ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ace027

If a breeder sells Mischlings and pure TB at the same time, beware... :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Neo-shrimp

Could we please can get an update on prices for the different varieties of shrimps ( like in the for sales sticky )...This thread somehow got side tracked :Scratch-Head:

Thanks guys

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
KiwiBigD

Agreed, I would say though there are not many pure TBs being sold.

And for those that ask, yes I have had TBMs from mischlings x mischlings, they go into my daughters tank and the girl goes into one of two grow out tanks for projects or the office tank for display.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bozzy

slightly OT but can someone please point me to the idiots guide to what your all talking about (tb,tbm etc). im only new to the hobby with red/rellow cherries at the moment but would like to move to others later on but getting caught up on whats what seems to be confusing me a little.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts
slightly OT but can someone please point me to the idiots guide to what your all talking about (tb' date='tbm etc). im only new to the hobby with red/rellow cherries at the moment but would like to move to others later on but getting caught up on whats what seems to be confusing me a little.[/quote']

Try this thread, I'm sure there's other thread discussing this on SKF too...

http://www.shrimpkeepersforum.com/forum/showthread.php/783-Minchlings/page2?highlight=TBMM

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
zuuutoootuuu

I've bought TBMs advertised as pure TBs in the past, I was able to isolate the true pure TB shrimp from the TBM shrimp, it was a slow process and a learning curve. However it was an excuse to have multiple tanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke
slightly OT but can someone please point me to the idiots guide to what your all talking about (tb' date='tbm etc). im only new to the hobby with red/rellow cherries at the moment but would like to move to others later on but getting caught up on whats what seems to be confusing me a little.[/quote']

Bluebolts has shown a page to explain what they are but do you mean you would like an explanation of the abbreviations we use as in TB is Taiwan Bee , TBM is Taiwan Bee Mischling meaning it doesn't come from 2 Taiwan Bees? If you want the meaning of abbreviations just let us know and it can be written out clearly for you to understand -we all started out not knowing so don't be afraid to ask. The water parameter abbreviations can be confusing too but I think they are covered in another thread:encouragement:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bozzy
Bluebolts has shown a page to explain what they are but do you mean you would like an explanation of the abbreviations we use as in TB is Taiwan Bee ' date=' TBM is Taiwan Bee Mischling meaning it doesn't come from 2 Taiwan Bees? If you want the meaning of abbreviations just let us know and it can be written out clearly for you to understand -we all started out not knowing so don't be afraid to ask. The water parameter abbreviations can be confusing too but I think they are covered in another thread:encouragement:[/quote']

is there a page of abbreviations/definitions somewhere already? (only just paid for (since my question) premium access and havent read everything in there yet)

im reasonibly familiar with the water parameter stuff with the exception of TDS (i know what it is but havent had a need to measure it before)

thanks guys

edit: just saw the thread Bluebolt posted so ill go read that now

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke

These are a few and the link to the glossary is at the bottom

CRS= crystal red shrimp

CBS= crystal black shrimp

Crystal grades= C,B,A,S,SS,SSS (lowest to highest)

PRL= pure red line

PBL= pure black line

GB= golden bee

SW= snow white

RW= red wine

KK= king kong

BB= blue bolt

TB= taibee

RCS= red cherry shrimp

YCS= yellow cherry shrimp

BCS= blue cherry shrimp

CCS= chocolate cherry shrimp

RO= reverse osmosis

DIY= do it your self

SKF= shrimp keepers forum

http://www.shrimpkeepersforum.com/forum/content.php/166-SKF-Glossary

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

Just to add to Ineke's list of abbreviations. :encouragement:

RR = Ruby Red

TB = Taiwan Bee - Genotype(pure TB genetics)

Tibee = Tiger x Bee shrimp(CRS/CBS)

Mischling = Taiwan Bee x CRS/CBS

TBM = Phenotype Taiwan Bee from Taiwan Bee x Mischling (Looks like a Taiwan Bee but impure genes)

TBMM = Phenotype Taiwan Bee from Mischling x Mischling (Looks like a Taiwan Bee but impure genes)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Posts

    • Steensj2004
      Tank doing great! Have a few Neos in the tank now from a friend who culled them. I’m counting 8-10 females berried, with several ready to drop any day based on when I first saw them berried!
    • wtusa1783
      Thanks. I bought the female berried. I want to start up a new tank for each I guess. Thanks for the help 
    • sdlTBfanUK
      If they are orange neocaridina (most likely) they will cross breed and with time will lose the red or orange as they revert to wild type. If the orange was berried when you got her she should have orange offspring (assuming she mated with another orange). Having said that even having only one colour will revert to wild if you don't remove poorly coloured offspring regularly, I have that problem with my red cherrys as I didn't cull for years and they are probably 80% wild now (5 years), and that makes life difficult because they are hard to see when  they are brown or clear? If your orange mated with one of your reds then you may get good colour offspring but you are on that downward spiral as the genes get mixed/diluted. If you bought the orange already berried you can put that in a separate new tank for just the orange, if you are prepared to get a separate tank for each colour, but if the berried orange mated with your red shrimps those shrimplets could be any colour (they may still be red or orange) but it is going to be more complicated. The main thing to decide at this stage is do you want to keep them in separate tanks or all mixed, but if you go the route of separate tanks for each colour you will still need to keep removing poor quality shrimps to maintain the colour long term! Hope this makes sense? Simon
    • wtusa1783
      O ok. They are the Sakura then? From my own research the Sunkist are neos. They are orange neos that’s what I know. Yes the female is berried. So what would happen with the orange Sakura and cherry?
    • jayc
      Was the Sunkist already berried when you got it? If that was the case, then the offspring would still be sunkist shrimp (ie. if you were successful raising the Sunkist offspring). Sunkist larvae apparently need brackish water conditions. Note: Sunkist are generally of the Caridina genus (Caridina cf. Propinqua). There is a Neocaridina genus called Orange Sakura.  So assuming the LFS has labelled the shrimp correctly then there is a lower chance of interbreeding. But people make a very common mistake of using the Sunkist and Orange Sakura name interchangeably and messing things up. But if that "Sunkist" shrimp somehow mated with the Red Cherry shrimp, then you would get diluted genetics, and some offspring would carry genetics of both Sunkist and Cherry. That means the offspring will be of poor quality eventually leading back to the wild type look.    Maybe a picture or two of what you have would help. Close up side shot of the shrimp please.    I'm going to borrow a pic from the interwebs (credits to whoever the original photographer is). The Sunkist (caridina) has a slight hump in it's back with distinctive white or red stripes. The hump is similar to Ghost shrimps. Notice the colour is a lot more transparent.   The Orange Sakura is more uniform in colour. Good quality varieties are less transparent than the Caridina Sunkist.   Of the two, the Sunkist is the rarer find.   Hope that helps.
×
×
  • Create New...