Jump to content
Gbang

Neocaridina davidi - Colour Variations

Recommended Posts

Gbang

read this article guys!!! very important read!

http://www.crustahunter.com/neocaridina-davidi-heteropoda-blue-velvet-bouvier-1904/

ok so we all know that blue rilli originate from red rilli shrimp

this article states that blue velvets originate from carbon rilli.

Therefore in conclusion. everyone in australia has BLUE RILLI.

the shrimp i have been line breeding is not a new shrimp and is in fact a blue velvet.

so how do you tell if you have blue rilli or velvet? simple.

if your shrimp have red rilli throw offs..they are blue rilli

if they have carbon rilli throwoffs...they are blue velvets

the question is would we consider this the absolute truth and a reliable source? i would say so considering this is from the author of breeders and keepers? i am still not sure

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

Definitely a very interesting developement Gman, thanks for sharing! :encouragement:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dostalgia
read this article guys!!! very important read!

http://www.crustahunter.com/neocaridina-davidi-heteropoda-blue-velvet-bouvier-1904/

ok so we all know that blue rilli originate from red rilli shrimp

this article states that blue velvets originate from carbon rilli.

Therefore in conclusion. everyone in australia has BLUE RILLI.

the shrimp i have been line breeding is not a new shrimp and is in fact a blue velvet.

so how do you tell if you have blue rilli or velvet? simple.

if your shrimp have red rilli throw offs..they are blue rilli

if they have carbon rilli throwoffs...they are blue velvets

the question is would we consider this the absolute truth and a reliable source? i would say so considering this is from the author of breeders and keepers? i am still not sure

i tried my best to read the article... but it is all in german? :(

:victorious:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

I'd still stand that the associated use of "rilli", is the distinctive pattern of coloured head & tail with clear body.

67a0f0dc408f394d8513ae21f7a47caf.jpg

Theres been several claims, and confusion with shrimps over the past few years, and I must admit that I haven't read/research on cherries that much.

There's also a taiwan breeder claim these these are super blue blue rillis. Although the blue is amazing, they're still culls from a rilli perspective.

5a3fd7cd053a94853487531a20c6a33d.jpg

Then there's the blue jelly :cower:

IMHO, I've noticed that a lot of commercial breeders are also "re-branding/naming" their shrimps for the sake of sales, and "creating, a"New" line, when in fact they're cull's or not quite there in terms of the selective breeding project, i.e. the above.

Just my opinion, but personally, a rilli has a distinctive pattern.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

I have to agree with you there dude, I'm getting frustrated with people creating their own names for shrimp that aren't up to the standard of the higher grade of that particular shrimp, just so they don't have to call them "culls", which is all they are. :encouragement:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

UK commercial breeder....

Name: Blue Velvet Jelly Shrimp "Neocaridina Davidi" or Blue Dream

Grade: Darker Blue Jelly Shrimp (Mid Grade) Other names: Blue Dream, Blue Fairy

What the hell ? LOL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

I know right, I bet that everyone here could add another name to that list for the very same shrimp, I mean come on! I don't care if it's a colour variation of one shrimp that someone "line bred" to keep that washed out colour going, that's their fault for deciding to go with it, it's still that particular shrimp. An example would be if someone used low grade red cherries to make a spotted red cherry, it's still a red cherry, not a fire engine cherry or a tomato juice cherry or a cricket ball cherry(see what I did there, lol) :victorious:

I can't imagine how hard it is for newbies to get their heads around all these names for the one shrimp! :dejection:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke

I came across another name that I queried yesterday called Blue Angel Shrimp. KiwibigD has named some as that from a line he has been breeding - they are cherry shrimp too. I didn't see a picture but hopefully if you read this BigD can you put up a picture? Also now the Blue shrimp from Chocolate where do they fit in??? Never mind a newbie getting confused , so are they all just Blue shrimp????.?.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
michael

This was on one of the fb overseas shrimp groups recently comparing a sukara red cherry with a new name/grade bloody mary red cherry......post-404-139909865876_thumb.jpg

post-1567-139909854932_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts
This was on one of the fb overseas shrimp groups recently comparing a sukara red cherry with a new name/grade bloody mary red cherry......post-404-139909865876_thumb.jpg

The "bloody mary red cherry"' date= just looks like a red from choc ? (see pic below)

null-14.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

You're right BB, they are painted reds from chocs & most of the sites I've seen them on have identified that fact so at least you know what they are & where they are derived from. :encouragement:

I'm all for exploring different colours & trying to get the best out of them but it's the FIFO sellers that give something a pretty name just to sell it as something different that worry me. This happens a lot in the betta trade & some breeders will throw two random fish together & give it a name like "Purple Sunset Dream" when really it's just a purple & orange bicolour halfmoon that's got a slightly darker purple or lighter orange because of the cross the did. Can get very confusing for a lot of people. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
John.

Time for a family tree starting from the Wild Type Cherry, and expanding on all the throw offs?

If someone wants to do the research/Tree I'm happy to make it look all pretty lol...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

Sounds like a good idea dude. :encouragement:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gbang

This is gonna take me a very long time to post lol. I agree with John!!! And we should definitely make a sticky about cherry types and names. Personally with the blue rilli name I am in complete agreement with bb. It should just be called a light blue cherry or whoever created it first. i just call it blue rilli cause everyone does....following people jump off the bridge so to speak lol but hey! we should change that right?

With the term rilli however I believe the definition is just a shrimp with translucent body areas? While I too think the best rilli is head and tail. I don't see others as a cull but that's in the eye of the beholder. Why not make it simple? Such as adding a specific trait of the rilli you are selling?

E.g red rilli shrimp with only red on tail

A cull is only perceived as a cull if it does not meet the breeders requirements. For instance, I would one day love to breed a rilli with only tiger patterns. To me it's not a cull... To some yes. Arrrgggghhhhh so many discussions to follow!

But I say male everything black and white. As for the Bloody Mary...... Looking from the photoI actually see it as another grade. Translucent red. But it doesn't mean I think it should be its own name. It should just be a translucent red grading cherry. Some peole like the translucent quality, some like it painted! but I sure as hell don't want to buy a cherry that is translucent when I'm looking for painted fire qualities so yes I would at least like to know that it's a translucent red. Hence a grading but not a name. Get it?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gbang

On another note, carbon rilli? Why not just call it a navy blue rilli?!? And with the carribean blue..... Why not just call it light blue body carbon rilli? It's no fancy name but you at least know what is goin on?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke

Gbang in essence you are right but if we start making up names to use on our forum are we any better than the person naming their shrimp a fancy name. It would be good for our community (SKF) to have a more concise name and description but how do we then expand it to the greater community of the hobby.Perhaps if we have a few members of multiple forums it can be put to the shrimp community that these are what we would like. It's a bit like we say TBM for Taiwan Bees from Mischling but say that away from our community and people ask what is that. Just my opinion but we should look into that eventually so everyone knows what that name means and the standard for that name. Otherwise not only will the newbies be confused the whole community will be confused:) and if it is going to be done it needs to be done well. We don't really want to be known as that crazy bunch at SKF (although there are some crazy people here:anonymous:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

Who you calling a crazy person? Ya crazy person! angry-old-man-smiley-emoticon_zps792fa4ec.gif

Teehee!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke

What Who me I didn't call anyone crazy. What you talking about. That was an anonymous person who infiltrated my post.:rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

Hahaha, nice save...........maybe! Whistle-smiley22_zps17fd03f2.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wayne6442

Just some of my Rilli types What would you name them?? They are all rilli's breeding true to their various major body colour eg: velvet blue !

post-404-139909865881_thumb.jpgpost-404-139909865884_thumb.jpgpost-1433-139909856385_thumb.jpgpost-3754-139909856386_thumb.jpgpost-34-139909865888_thumb.jpgpost-404-139909865891_thumb.jpg

post-12-139909854934_thumb.jpg

post-12-139909854937_thumb.jpg

post-12-13990985494_thumb.jpg

post-12-139909854942_thumb.jpg

post-12-139909854945_thumb.jpg

post-12-139909854947_thumb.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

The "carribean blue" is a name given by a commercial breeder in Taiwan (?) and not a recognised variant internationally. If we accepted and used any term and description of a variant popping up in our programs, there'll be 100's of names from tomato red cherry to electric blue spotted head half coloured tail rilli with a spec of blue and clear body.....LOL, just making a point. :-)

A new variant/name should/can be assigned to a proven colony, showing them breeding true for 2-3 generations (?)... And not just 1-2 shrimps..... Breeders that have created the spotted head pinto for example, have spent years of careful selective breeding, and produce absolutely HIGH quality shrimps, so to say we've created a new variant based on 1-2 shrimps etc.... Is showing very little regard to the breeders who are dedicated to creating absolute quality shrimps.

For example, this amazing blue body red rilli popped up from my breeding colony...

E844C567-E431-48C2-B434-DE70F997D85B.jpg

Is it a cull ? Yes, as it doesn't show a dark deep red rilli pattern like this...

null_zpse1e6b4f9.jpg

but is it a cull to be disposed out of my program ? No (sorry, no 1st dibs ..LOL), as I would love to extract the blue to my existing colony.

If I do happen to achieve it, and my colony has the perfect rilli pattern with this intensity of blue, and breeding true, will I then call it a new variant .... I wouldn't, as it's still a red rilli blue body, but one with an insane blue...similar to Benibachi PRL....etc they're all still PRL, BUT line bred to produce the quality the breeder aims for..

IMO of course....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

Oops, I hope I didn't kill this thread / conversation...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

Not at all BB, we are all just sitting back & taking in the wisdom of the master. hahaha gigglehand_zpsae3155d1.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
newbreed
Oops' date=' I hope I didn't kill this thread / conversation...[/quote']

Murderer!! :)

I think it is important for all who are selling "Blue Cherries" to acknowledge and state the parental genetics. i.e. (from red rilli), (from carbon rilli), (from chocolate cherry), (from black cherry).etc That way the buyer knows what they are getting.

Most of the blues advertised on this forum have had this kind of identification.

It's buyer beware unfortunately but the buyer has the right to ask lots of questions prior to purchase. This is important and something I have sometimes neglected to do in the past but urge all newcomers to investigate if they are planning breeding programs.

Hope this helps revive the thread! :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wayne6442

with the aid of a small amount of research I have discovered that the term Rili is used to describe a shrimp of the species Neocaridina Davidi ( Heteropoda) that exhibits a COMPLETE LOSS of colour on its body with various intensified coloured areas on the rest.

The strain was developed In Taiwan by a breeder in 2010 and the major aim was to develop a shrimp with CRYSTAL CLEAR parts without spots or COLOUR and intensify the other colour (eg the red on red rili's).

That kind of leaves us between a rock and a hard place as the various coloured Neocaridina davidi that some of us have been working on cannot be called a Rili as they don't show Crystal Clear body parts and carry a colour instead( that's the hard place!) A lot of us refer to them as Rili types (right or wrong?) prefaced by the major colour hue. So a blue Velvet with a little red could be called a blue velvet Rili TYPE and not a blue Velvet Rili as there is no crystal clear body parts, "Now it's confusing"

I have seen mentioned on some o/s forums people selling blue velvet coloured shrimp with some (usually red)colours on them as Blue Velvet Rili's and I have also seen some carbon blue's with light and dark blue markings sold as Carbon Blue Rili's . This looks to be an acceptable practice overseas.

Personally I think that these beautiful colour variations of the humble Neocardina Davidi deserve a name and a place in the cherry shrimp history just like yellows, blacks & reds after all they have all stemmed from the one wild shrimp, just like all of the other types like crystals etc.

To me a shrimp cull is only perceived to be just that by a breeder who is after a certain trait and may not be considered as a cull by a person who is willing to put in the hard yards to develop another strain from the same shrimp. Their work should be acknowledged by being allowed to name a shrimp variation whatever is fitting.

As BB said if a shrimp variation breeds true after three or four generations then it should be able to be described as such.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • Blue Ridge
      If it makes you feel any better, what you've done happens all the time! Acid-buffering substrate with a CACO3 stone that "fight" one another, and conflicting information between the two genera of shrimp can cause a lot of confusion. But where you are right now should be a perfect environment for crystals, bees, and such. Aqua soil, remineralized RO water (GH+ only, not the KH and GH product) and you should be all set for most Caridina. If buying shrimp online, just be sure that they are "home bred" and not imports. Survival rate is typically much higher this way. I prefer to buy from other hobbyists whenever possible. If you really want cherries (Neocaridina) they will live on Aqua Soil but the water will always be softer and more acidic than ideal. But cherries are tough creatures and people keep them in tanks set up for Caridina all the time with success. As for how long the substrate buffers, that is determined by how much "work" it has to do. If using soft water and no lime based stones in the aquarium, it is said go for many years. You don't want to speed that up in my opinion, kind of defeats the purpose of buying buffering soil.
    • Steensj2004
      How low does this substrate buffer, inknownit isn’t an exact science, but has anyone had experience? The PH has parked at 6.4-6.5. 
    • jayc
      Hah! LOL, how did I know. If I was going to put a bet on one or the other, it would be the rocks from Phillip Island ... from the beach. How to test? do the vinegar test. Take out a bit of gravel, and a small stone. drop some vinegar on them to see if you get a reaction. Alternate test is to put them in a cup of water. Test the water GH and KH before adding, then test again after a few hours to see if KH and GH have increased.
    • Crabclaw
      ahh shoot. gravel was washed about 20 times thru, and rocks were boiled. gravel was sold as aquarium safe gravel, but the rocks were from phillip island, along the beach... how could i just test 1 or 2 to see if that's why? (they're all the same type, but i have a few big ones that r heavy and a bunch of small ones that i can test with)
    • jayc
      That means you have something else in the tank that is leeching carbonates - like a rock, or gravel or shell grit.
×