Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
salvanost

misterious shrimp death after using powder product

Recommended Posts

salvanost

i use lot of products and there always 1-4 shrimps death after using the powder product

i don't understand the reason, even when using only 1/5 dosage still not helping at all

 

exception only borneo wild stout and mineral salty shrimp

 

here all product i use

- mosura rich water

- mosura bioplus

- mosura old sea mud

- mosura tonic pro

- mosura denitro

- borneo wild shield
- borneo wild vigor

- lowkey all in one

- ada bacter 100

 

note:

old sea mud would cause casuality if i'm using it too much/often

 

any suggestion welcome

Edited by salvanost

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GotCrabs

Well don't use those products, if you are having a number of deaths after using those foods then switch to something else.

Contact forum member Squiggles, he'll point you in the right direction, also look at the foods on Boss Aquaria, especially Shrimp Booster, Crack, Snow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2OFUS

Check your tds

You are adding alot of minerals

If you use to much salty shrimp mineral your tds will sky rocket and also it will raise your GH

If your gh is to high this will/could cause molting issues which will cause death

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

Whoa, that's a lot of additives, I would only use one or two, & as 2OFUS said, check your TDS & other WP to see if they are affecting them too much, this will definitely cause issues.

 

Do you add these all on the same day or on a rotation?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
salvanost

rotation

i will add 1 week between non food product, but still following the dossage,

for example mosura rich water only use once a month, denitro once a month too, so i use this schedule

and if some product got same result like borneo wild shield and mosura tonic pro, i will use one of them only
 

each week. mosura bioplus twice a week (because this is baby shrimp food) and
week 1. old sea mud (when wc)

week 2. mosura shield/tonic pro (when wc)

week 3. mosura rich water (when wc)

week 4. mosura denitro (if nitrate above 15ppm) (when wc)

 

nothing wrong with the tds and gh

tds max 130 (if above 130, i will drop it using dripping to 120-125)
gh 4,5-5

 

next product i will try

- glasgarten bacter ae (to replace mosura bioplus and other bactery dosing)

- glasgarten baby food (to replace the mosura bioplus too)

Edited by salvanost

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fishmosy

(if nitrate above 15ppm)

 

I think this may be a clue.

Many additives contain organic material. This may be adding to the overall nitrogen load of your tank and causing deaths.

I've found less = more when it comes to additives.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
matblack

They don't like sudden change  What type of shrimp are you talking about and how large is

 your tank and water changes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
salvanost

They don't like sudden change What type of shrimp are you talking about and how large is

your tank and water changes

Mostly all neo and some caridina got same issue

It's really hard to reduce nitrate below 10

Anyone know the trick?

big wc is no no for me, could result shrimp death too

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OzShrimp

Check your tds

You are adding alot of minerals

If you use to much salty shrimp mineral your tds will sky rocket and also it will raise your GH

If your gh is to high this will/could cause molting issues which will cause death

I think this hits the nail on the head. Ultimately if you need to do a big WC to spare deaths in the future it could save you deaths. Doing a big WC doesnt mean you have an extreme risk either it depends how different the paremeters are and how quick you actually add your new water. When i do my water changes i will just pour 30 litres or so into my tank and no deaths you just have to do things the safest way

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

Where are you located salvanost?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Shrimpy Daddy

i use lot of products and there always 1-4 shrimps death after using the powder product

i don't understand the reason, even when using only 1/5 dosage still not helping at all

 

exception only borneo wild stout and mineral salty shrimp

 

here all product i use

- mosura rich water

- mosura bioplus

- mosura old sea mud

- mosura tonic pro

- mosura denitro

- borneo wild shield

- borneo wild vigor

- lowkey all in one

- ada bacter 100

 

note:

old sea mud would cause casuality if i'm using it too much/often

 

any suggestion welcome

 

Not all products of the different brands are able to work together, they will interact and have residue that you will never be able to remove. In addition, some brands (I shall not say which) do have have proper R&D and their own product may not even work well with their own.

 

How long have you been performing this dosing regime? What shrimps are you keeping and water are the water parameters?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

rotation

i will add 1 week between non food product, but still following the dossage,

for example mosura rich water only use once a month, denitro once a month too, so i use this schedule

and if some product got same result like borneo wild shield and mosura tonic pro, i will use one of them only

 

each week. mosura bioplus twice a week (because this is baby shrimp food) and

week 1. old sea mud (when wc)

week 2. mosura shield/tonic pro (when wc)

week 3. mosura rich water (when wc)

week 4. mosura denitro (if nitrate above 15ppm) (when wc)

 

nothing wrong with the tds and gh

tds max 130 (if above 130, i will drop it using dripping to 120-125)

gh 4,5-5

 

next product i will try

- glasgarten bacter ae (to replace mosura bioplus and other bactery dosing)

- glasgarten baby food (to replace the mosura bioplus too)

 

 

I agree with what people are saying here.

A lot of the products you are using are doing the same thing and doubling up on it's functionality.

Mosura denitro isn't doing anything more than what a healthy filter is doing, assuming you have sufficient filtration for the size of tank you have. If this truely works you wouldn't be seeing nitrates. I'm sceptical a powdered product is capable of turning nitrite and nitrates into "a harmless gaseous state of nitrogen". 

 

Mosura rich water is just adding fulvic acid, nothing a cheaper bottle of blackwater won't do, or a few Indian Almond leaves in the tank won't do. 

 

I'm convinced Old Sea mud is just Montmorillonite Powder with some other additives. You don't really think they dredge up old sea mud from the ocean for use in a freshwater tank do you?

 

All the other products have no description of what it contains. Which means we have no idea what it is doing to the water in the tank.

And that's the problem with using these big name products. Their ingredients are a closely guarded secret. But once you realise what it is, you will understand that there are cheaper alternatives. 

You only have what the manufacturer's description of what it does, but have you questioned the description about what it REALLY does?

It seems like I'm picking on Mosura, I'm not. I like using some of their products. 

 

Take Borneo Wild Vigor for example. It's description says - "You can observe that shrimps stop dying during unsuccessful moulting. Vigor also helps in boosting plant growth in a planted tank." 

Really?? Yet you have shrimp dying, most likely from moulting issues if I was to take a guess. And how does it boost plant growth??

 

I'm not picking on Borneo Wild either. Again I use some of their products.

 

But not all at once.

 

You have a lot of food products. So with the exception of the food products, I would cut down of all the other additives to just one.

You mentioned using Salty Shrimp mineral. Does this mean you use RO water?

If you do, then that is all I would use. Salty Shrimp with RO water matched to the parameters in your tank and added slowly. This assumes your filter is well established and sufficient in terms of size to cater for your bioload.

Water changes at 10%, no more, to maintain water parameter consistency.

 

You can continue feeding using the foods you have.

 

The key is to keep the water parameters as stable as possible with as little fluctuation as possible.

The weekly addition of tonics in the regime above, whether you need it or not, is creating constant changes to the tank's parameters. 

 

Adopt the K.I.S.S. principle. Keep It Shrimply Simple.

Good filtration and stable/constant water parameters suited to the shrimp you are keeping.

Use the processed foods, they are good for a staple (that means you feed it regularly when you are too lazy to make fresh foods).

But give your shrimp fresh foods occasionally ... leaves, flowers, fruits (we have a list in the Food & Nutrition section).

Give your shrimp protein ... frozen blood worms. They will get more nutrients out of blood worms than you can find in any processed foods. 

 

Not only will KISS save you money, your shrimp will probably be better off for it.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fishmosy

Well said jayc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
salvanost

Hello, sorry for late replay

Right now keeping taiwan bee, misc, tiger bee, taiwan tiger bee, inside 1 tank with 2 breeding sponge, no pregnant shrimp from shrimp with tiger gen so far, the tank is 2 month old

And old tank is 8 month, using this additive regime for 4 months now

I'm located at Indonesia

And using ro water start with 008 tds then adding salty shrimp +

No molting issue from failed molting,

Just sometime when i turn on the light, i scare some shrimp while the shrimp still molting process

Ussually result the shrimp won't eat at all, dying after 1 week

I will change my wc

- big wc to reduce the nitrate, with same water tds

- small wc, to adjust the parameter from using product and tds raise because water evaporation

And stop using all powdered product i know causing trouble in the past

I will try glassgarten product later

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
salvanost

Thanks everyone for the inputs

Hope everyone would help me again later when i'm setup new tank

I will update again later

Will try to improvised KISS and more stable tank

Edited by salvanost

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OzShrimp

No molting issue from failed molting,

Just sometime when i turn on the light, i scare some shrimp while the shrimp still molting process

Ussually result the shrimp won't eat at all, dying after 1 week

 

The moulting of a shrimp is actually quiet quick like seconds, so if they are moulting slowly to the point you are disturbing them then there is definitely a strong chance that there is an issue with their moulting process

 

Edited by OzShrimp
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
salvanost

i just watched them jumping and leaving the shell like the video

 

when that happen, the shrimp won't eating anything, starve to death :(

 

but still not problem like failed molting (the shrimp runs out energy while molting, death with half finished molt position)

Edited by salvanost

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

but still not problem like failed molting (the shrimp runs out energy while molting, death with half finished molt position)

 

Hmm, sounds like a moulting problem to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OzShrimp

Ditto i am in agreeance

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

+2, definitely sounds like a moulting problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
salvanost

don't worry, the tds around 120-140

so it's fine for a while ( i think)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sprae

TDS is purely an indicator. If 90% of that 140ppm is calcium, you'd still have moulting issues.

 

Moulting death comes from two extremes, new shell too soft or old shell too hard. You might want to check your calcium levels with something like this - http://www.apifishcare.com/product.php?id=585#.VFqblPmUcoo

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
salvanost

already use glasgarten baby shrimp food for 2 weeks, no death shrimp at all

except when i use borneo wild shield, fortunately no victims from mosura tonic pro when i use it a little for twice a week

i'm using both tonic pro and borneo wild because the beta glucan

 

i'm really happy with glasgarten baby shrimp food

already give mosura bioplus to my friend, will give the bw shield too later

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

Seems like you found the cause.

Don't use Shield.

 

If you want to add Beta Glucan, just feed your shrimp some Oats.

Oats is packed with Beta-Glucan.

 

Another good food for baby shrimps is Bee pollen.

I find it very economical on the wallet for a 250g bottle as well.

Edited by jayc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2OFUS

Where do you buy your bee pollen jay ?

I have looked EVERYWHERE !!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      You are indeed correct in that I didn't see a cycle as such, I only had nitrates of 25 to start (cooked prawn) and that dropped but also as you say the PH was very low, below 6 so a proper cycle may not have happened - well spotted, I had forgotten about that. I set the tank up in June so if it isn't cycled by now though I guess it never will be? Incidentally I have only got the Ph up to 6 (recently) by putting a bit of the old rock back temporarily, and possibly that caused the tank to cycle or something??? I have thus far got 4L of RO water and hope to get more done so I can do a approx 50% water change at the weekend. You make a lot of valid points and thanks for giving me more to go on, maybe the plants aren't as green in this tank because of the different parameters and the substrate isn't as bad as it appears? The other tanks have Ph 7.5 so quite different! I like your point one and that seems to be how most people think in the modern world, but I am 100% sure it is my fault one way or other, I am old school! I am however physically restricted so it isn't anything I can do anything about! Got friends coming on sunday so if I get the water ready they can lug the buckets of water around................. I will get some rubber gloves anyway as that means I can rule that out, and give me peace of mind for the future that I won't accidentally contaminate the water by mistake? I have been using a lot of cleaning products (scrubbing floors) around xmas which makes me think I may have contaminated the tank without realising??? Simon
    • beanbag
      Just to update that I went back to my normal, very low dose of fertilizer, but the Ludwigia are still dying, from the bottom up.  The tips are green and growing, but the bottom parts are rotting away.  So far, I can only think of two possible reasons: 1) I have been feeding my shrimp less, so maybe they aren't making enough ammonia and nitrates for the plants 2) About 2 months ago, I changed the lighting so that it was a complete blackout at night and only 7 hours of medium light a day.  This did a great job of getting rid of algae that was growing on the plants, but maybe now I need more light again?
    • beanbag
      My first choice is still to blame the substrate.  The reason is that it becomes "not your fault". But secondly, I might blame the biological ecosystem.  I don't think you ever "proved" that you have a cycled tank, in the standard sense that it can remove 1ppm of ammonia per day.  And in my own experience, if you have a low pH (like under 6), it could take forever to cycle a tank.  (I wasted about 1-2 months on this)  It's possible that you have a case where you don't have much nitrifying bacteria, but rather the plants are the one consuming the ammonia.  And maybe that is ok, I dunno. Thirdly, I am not a big fan of using dead meat or fish food to cycle a tank, because not only does it create ammonia, but it also creates water pollution.  Again, the standard thing to do is a 95% water change before adding animals to get all the nitrates and pollution products out. In any case, if I were in your position, I would do the standard "it can't hurt" things of: 25% water change per week with remineralized water A low dose of Prime anyway, in case there is a very small amount of ammonia Add some nitrifying bacteria in a bottle, or keep adding some bacteria from other tanks (as long as they have a similar pH) Maybe add some probiotic bacteria like Dr Tim's Eco balance.  I have no idea if this will actually help, but it probably won't hurt.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I won't be using the gloves for long in the tank, quick front glass clean and then the sponges so they won't be in the tank long, but I will rinse them a couple of times and dry them off before I first use them! I don't have any spare JBL soil to do that experiment, but I have used that in the other tanks and all has gone soooo much better, though there is more prep required with it but that is a small price to pay for the rewards. Shrimpking is by dennerle so I don't for a second think that can be the actual problem killing the shrimps! But the other tanks with JBL are so lush I would definitely use that in future!  Simon 
    • sdlTBfanUK
      We are having similar issues, though I have only seen 1 dead shrimp but they are disappearing! I am only giving it one more go as we are half way through winter here so at least if I go carefully and manage to keep them alive they will at least start breeding as yours are. That was when mine exploded with shrimps in the previous case and losing a few adults then doesn't matter quite so much? I tend to believe the babies are tougher because they have always lived in that environment anyway and not been as stressed as purchased shrimps. You are not alone in getting frustrated with this type of problem, at least if you can pinpoint what went wrong you can correct it? I have done pretty much exactly what I did last time so am really baffled and clutching at straws now! Simon
×
×
  • Create New...