Jump to content

Hydra & Planaria shrimp safe removal.


Dean
 Share

Recommended Posts

The SL Aqua is a herbal extract so isn't actually a chemical and it had NO negative impact (they say maybe snails would die but mine didn't) so ultra simple, quick and effective. Mine was a new tank so there were only snails living in the tank at that time. The hydra I had were so tiny (tank was only a few weeks old so they were probably young) you needed a magnifying glass to see them and it would be quite difficult to remove them without disturbing the aquascaping as they were attached to wood (that is probably where they came from)! 

I have seen the traps on ebay but I don't know whether they are effective or not, but they don't look nice in the tank and how do you know if/when you have caught them all?

I think the SL Aqua Z1 would definitely be the way to go if you have hydra/planaria and you can get hold of it, it is a natural product and couldn't be easier, 1 dose and you should be done, though they say you may need to do another, but I didn't, though I doubt there were that many in my tank anyway!

Hope everything is going well with your shrimp tanks kms? I haven't seen many of my new shrimps (3 so far today, early yet though) but it is a heavily planted tank and they are adolescent size shrimps. I have put some fresh spinach and a pea in there today, hopefully that should draw them out? I checked the parameters etc yesterday and they were all spot on.

Simon

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Traps don't work on hydra. Even with planaria, it is slow and it doesn't catch them all.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...

I still recommend the SL Aqua Z1 if you have this problem (AND CAN GET IT) but read on:

I got this for the betta tank, used  it once and I haven't had a problem since so that was perfect, tick, done!

I must have transferred something from the betta tank to the shrimp tank whilst there was hydra in the betta tank so then had to treat the shrimp tank and it looked to have cleared it of hydra. I have since had to retreat twice as the hydra have started to reappear after a couple of months, but they vanish within minutes of adding the powder and as that is the extent of the treatment it is so easy I will carry on using it if they reappear in the future as it hasn't any negative affects that I have seen, even the snails survived without a problem (assassins)!

Simon

Edited by sdlTBfanUK
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...

Does hydra has a green color? I tried to take photos of my tank of this creature since yours photos look like they are white while mine is green, I’m not sure if they are hydra in my tank! ? 

  • Confused 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hydra are white from my memory of when I had them, but they don't look anything even similar to your photo. They are more like a thick hair with split ends at the very top, they don't look similar to anything else so it is easy to spot and identify them!

I think JayC has it right with limpits, I also thought it might have been them earlier but believed they were only saltwater, but did a bit of reading since, and there are freshwater ones. The one in the photo must be very young as I couldn't actually see a shell. They are harmless enough, some people even think they are benfecial (like snails), so if you don't want them I would just remove them manually as and when you see them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I tried my best to take photos of it and this is what I got for like 30 mins of trials. The photo didn’t show the color but it is green, not white like you said. I found some reading said that the green color is due to symbiotic with another of its kind forgot the name of that. So it is hydra, isn’t it? And yes it’s very hard to spot them since they are relatively small at this moment. I took photos with my iphone 13 pro max and trust me I’m suck at taking photos on phones! ? 

by the way, I tried the link to buy the product but the link is broken, is there any way I can get it from the US? 
thank you!! 

7144B67B-7C15-4E87-9C87-0FCD1CF30886.jpeg

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, CrookiestoPro9991 said:

So it is hydra, isn’t it?

Yes. this is a hydra.

 

15 hours ago, CrookiestoPro9991 said:

by the way, I tried the link to buy the product but the link is broken

Yeah, this is an old thread. The website is probably out of business.

Google "SL Aqua Z1 Planarian & Hydra Cleaner", or "planaria zero" or "no planaria" and just look for the most convenient site to purchase from.

Edited by jayc
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That is definitely hydra!

If you have planaria as well you will want a product that kills both so the SL Aqua may not be what you want. There are various treatments available on ebay, as mentioned by JayC above.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share


  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • krogoo22
      I would add that boiling discourages natural decomposition and would likely break down the antifungals present in the bark, letting the fungus actually grow.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I shall probably just call him bertie as I did the previous 2 I had.
    • jayc
      What nice friends you have! Have you named the new betta yet? 
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I had friends round at the weekend, moving furniture around so now I can see the fish tanks from where I normally sit. The only tank that has been running since I moved has had bloody mary shrimps in it and they are fine. It was my betta tank before, and after moving my friends went out and got me a new betta;- As you can see he is ultra healthy looking (pic is of him in the fish store tank) and he has been very active from the moment he arrived and started a bubble nest within an hour of going into the tank. He is about half the size of a fully grown one! He is a bit bland to look at as just white but I went for him as the tank is quite (understatement) dark and so he is easily visible, even from a distance. Hopefully he won't devour the shrimps (the odd baby shrimp I don't mind) but I will have to see on that issue! All the water parameters seem fine aside frm KH which is 6 as this area has harder water than where I was before, but I will gradually get that down using the filtered water (RO) with GH+ shrimp remineraliser from this point, that has no KH and I will just do it gradually over a loooong period as neither he nor the shrimps seem unhappy as it currently is anyway! Apparently the store he came from also sell blue bolt (and some other taiwan bee type) shrimps etc so I will start thinking about setting that tank up (it is situ next to the betta tank) at some point in the near future, though that will be months away even when I do decide to start, as the substrate needs running-in, and the tank will need to cycle etc. 
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I see the 2 shrimplets, very exciting and the shrimp in the photo look very healthy! The KH is fine at 3 and slowly dropping because of the substrate, but still in the acceptable range. Not sure about your tank size, other than 'nano' but if you have fish in that same tank (I think I see one in the photo blrred and at the back) I would do 25% weekly water changes (mainly because of the fish) and that will help counter the substrate as well, until the substrate is 'exhausted' of its buffering ability. Use the same kh4 new water as currently and always add the new water slowly, a drip method is best. Obviously you will need to be extra careful when removing the old water that you don't remove any of the new shrimplets........ Try not to change too much though as you may do more harm than good and it looks like everything is actually already going well, visible mating behavour and shrimplets doing well. Hope you manage to get rid of the planaria and that usually involves sizeable water changes in the process so complete that first and from then do the 25% regular water change routine. As the population grows you will need to increase the amount of food but be cautious not to overfeed. The bacter AE should help with biofilm growth etc but it isn't actually a food for the shrimps, though you may see them eating some if it isn't dissolved fully. The scuds are harmless and I would (and did in the past) remove them manually when you see them.
×
×
  • Create New...