Jump to content
beanbag

Red and yellow shrimp lost color

Recommended Posts

beanbag

Hello folks,

Over the course of a few weeks, the red and yellow cherry shrimp (one each) in my tank have lost color and become more clear compared to when I first got them.  Physically, they seem fine, though, and walk around and graze.

In the case of the yellow shrimp, it used to have a solid opaque yellow stripe along its back, but that has disappeared, revealing its digestive system.

In the case of the cherry shrimp, I was told by the aquarium that it was a "painted fire red", but really it started off as a nearly opaque maroon color with a pink stripe down the back.  I noticed a few days later that its color would fluctuate, sometimes becoming more or less clear.  But after this last molt, it is even more clear, with internal organs visible and looking like a maroon low grade cherry.  It still changes from more to less clear.  (I think when it is active, it becomes more clear).

This red shrimp came from the store aquarium with TDS 450 (!) GH 6-8, KH<4, and from a tank with fluval Stratum, so probably slightly acidic.  On the other hand, my tank has pool filter sand (lighter color), TDS 200 GH7 kH5 ph 7.2-7.6.  My shrimp are fed biofilm, cholla log, bacter AE, jayc's agar recipe, and only rarely Hikari Shrimp Cuisine.

I added two pics: one from the first day I got it, and one from two weeks later.  At its palest, it's even more clear than the pic shows.

pfr_after.jpg

pfr_before.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

It's almost always water quality as the primary cause, then food.

Improve on water quality will help restore their colour.

Try reducing pH to 7.0 and KH.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
beanbag

Over the last few days I added a capping layer of buffer substrate (Seachem aquasolum) and started using Salty Shrimp GH (only) in my water changes.  The parameters are now:

pH 6.8-6.9 (ph swings with lights on and off are smaller now)

TDS 160

kH 3

The color of the red shrimp still fluctuates a bit, but on average looks about half-way between my before and after pictures.  The yellow shrimp is still kind of clear looking.  I guess I will wait a week or two more since that was the time period over which they lost their color.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zoidburg

Can't help but wonder if it's a combination of light colored substrate and being color fed?

 

KH should be zero with a buffering substrate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
beanbag
20 minutes ago, Zoidburg said:

KH should be zero with a buffering substrate.

The Seachem Aquasolum doesn't seem to deplete KH.  So I wonder if I should have some KH around anyway?  Right now my KH value is somewhere around 1.5.  (after many partial water changes since the last post)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zoidburg

I'm honestly not familiar with Aquasolum but it does say that it softens water (potential issue with shrimp!) and lowers pH.

 

Kind of curious to know if GH and KH remain stable once you've got it set at where you want them in the tank?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
beanbag

Well first of all I have a small 1.x gallon tank, and only a capping layer of Aquasolum. 

I looked at my old notes, and it seems a fresh batch of aquasolum wants to have a pH of 6.4, and will take GH down one notch, and KH down either a tiny bit or none at all.  My tank originally had a problem where the GH slowly rises, and the aquasolum is not enough to counteract that.

But other than that, GH KH and pH are fairly stable.

Regarding the Aquasolum, I mean it has a picture of a shrimp on the bag, so...

My tank right now is pH 6.6 (lights off) to 6.8 (lights on), GH 5-7, kH 1-2, TDS 180-200.  I do partial water changes with a mix of Salty Shrimp GH/KH and GH only.

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zoidburg

That's what I thought would happen. It's a soil that should, in theory, absorb GH and KH until it's reached it's limit, then GH and KH remain stable after that. Controsoil does the same - supposedly, although I've never tested it.

Rising GH would tell me it's either due to rocks/coral in the tank or evaporation, and can counter-act it by doing top offs with pure RO water or doing water changes with slightly lower GH.

 

I've learned years ago that just because something is marketed towards a specific animal doesn't mean that it's actually good for them... you could look at human products and see just how much crap is sold for us that's not healthy for us! I'm not saying that Aquasolum is bad at all (not familiar, don't know enough people who have used it), just that not everything on the market is good. I've come across many people who have used the Fluval Shrimp and Plant Stratum and struggled to keep shrimp on it. Others have great success. Most people who use it don't actually know how to use it to it's fullest potential.

 

I've been MIA for a few months so kind of just 'catching up'. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • Zoidburg
      I recently made the switch from sand and SS GH/KH to SL-Aqua substrate and GH only minerals (from same company - liquid form). When I switched everything over, I didn't even acclimate the shrimp. Knock on wood, I haven't seen a loss yet! It's only been a few days. Everything in the tank is the same except for the substrate and water. Also cleaned the sides and front of tank while I had it taken down.   It's a 10g tank, so I remineralized two 5g buckets of water, one of which I slightly over-remineralized. Figured it would work it out as I had tossed in some water that wasn't remineralized to the right parameters just to keep the plants in there wet. One bucket had been sitting around for a while with just RO water and the other only a few days before adding minerals. After everything has settled, it all worked out to about 7.5/8 GH which is about what I was aiming for.   I can't say I'll continue getting the liquid remineralizer right now, but we'll see with how this one does. Powders will always be more bang for your buck with how much water you can remineralize with it, but the liquids are supposed to contain more nutrients in them that are beneficial for shrimp.    Tank has Caridina (YKK and ???) and Neocaridina (Bloody Mary) in it.
    • Zoidburg
      Coming from a pet bird keeping hobby, I can easily back up what jayc said about imports.... not only can you not import animals, you can't export them either. The *ONLY* exception may come between New Zealand and Australia. Some animals can be moved between those two countries. Otherwise though, import and exportation for both countries is banned. I live in the USA.
    • ShrimpNewb
      Thanks, Simon.  I am a shrimpnewb after all.  My tank has pretty much zero evaporation - it's weird, but it seems to have something to do with not running a heater and the water temperature being the same as the room.  I'm just planning to switch over to the shrimp focused mineralizer with water changes over time.  I'll update the TDS differences I assume will be there.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      This has got rather long and involved, interesting though! Just wanted to remind you that topping up tanks from evaporation will still need pure RO water (not mineralised) though so you will need to keep some Pure RO water aside for that. Simon
    • ShrimpNewb
      Oh, yes.  Live and learn.  This is, as my wife keeps telling me, a science project.
×