Jump to content
chongkt

seachem replenish

Recommended Posts

chongkt

good day . my only shrimp tank's tds is rather low. +- 80 ppm. friend suggested this product.  question : is this safe  to use for shrimps ? bcos it contains salt. can someone please help.  ... perhaps another safe substitute/ equivalent. 

regards. 

Edited by chongkt
spelling errors

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zoidburg

No, not Replenish. Euilibrium would be a better product to use.

Do you have access to any other shrimp remineralizers?

And what shrimp are you keeping?

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chongkt

yes I can access to other remineralizer. 

I had about 80+  mixed neo in my tank. fire red,  blue diamond,  sunkist orange, yellow  golden  back, rcs and yamato plus few snails. I'm looking for liquid type remineralizer. 

regds. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
1 hour ago, chongkt said:

I had about 80+  mixed neo in my tank. fire red,  blue diamond,  sunkist orange, yellow  golden  back, rcs and yamato plus few snails. I'm looking for liquid type remineralizer. 

If TDS is low, other water parameters might also be affected like pH. So best to check those parameters as well based on what neo caridina needs are. 

Equilibrium is better, as Zoidburg said. Salty Shrimp GH/KH is also good for more shrimp specific product. Another one is Mosura mineral plus Ultra (liquid), and Borneo Wild has a similar product for GH/KH+. But they are really all the same. Replenish is more for Marine tanks.

The problem with these liquid remineralisers is that they are expensive for what they are. Because someone has premixed it for you, and added cost is applied.

One bottle of equilibrium will last you a lot longer. And if you want, you can get a 500ml bottle and add some RO or demineralised water and a few tablespoons of equilibrium. It should take 4-5 tablespoons. Apply to water change (a few drops) and test with a TDS meter to get your desired TDS level.

 

I make my own remineraliser from Calcium Sulphate and Magnesium Sulphate. I still have 1kg of it in powder form from the last time I bought & mixed it. Much more economical. 

Edited by jayc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chongkt

Jayce,

many thanks for the advice.  I'll go for Equilibrium. btw. the replenish is out of stock here. (I've been using this for the last 3 years).

fyi. my tank parameters as below:-

ph 6-7.

gh 6-8.

kh 3-4 .

nitrates- 5.

ammonia, nitrite  -  0.

regards n thank you. 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chongkt

dear Jayc,

for how long can I keep the premixed Equilibrium solution  ?

regards 

 

Edited by chongkt
xx

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zoidburg

SL-Aqua, Vin Shrimp, MK-Breed and a few others out there do sell liquid remineralizers, however they are usually in GH or KH form, not GH and KH. It's either buy GH and KH or buy GH and figure out a way to raise KH.


I have noticed that if you let Equilibrium sit for a while that it tends to settle in the bottom of the container and turns yellow. I've used it for fish tanks, not shrimp tanks though. It also does not provide KH.


Replenish is "okay" for fish tanks, but not planted tanks. Still wouldn't recommend it for shrimp.

 

I haven't used jayc's method for a remineralizer so any questions about that best directed to him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chongkt

zoidbutg, can I know what is the reason replenish is no good for planted tank n shrimps. it just bring up the never on tds not gh or kh. and is premixed ready to use. anyway I'll try Jay's method when I get my Equilibrium today or tomorrow. it make sense.  will update the result. thank you for your time for replying. 

regds. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
16 hours ago, chongkt said:

dear Jayc,

for how long can I keep the premixed Equilibrium solution  ?

regards 

 

Forever! 

It's just salts. Keep the bottle out of the sunlight. 

Shake the bottle before use. There might be some parts that cannot be dissolved fully and settles in the bottom, but that is not a problem and causes no harm. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chongkt

good day Jay,

this is the main reason for not using Equilibrium.  your method of putting them in the bottom 1st and use it later.  and use dissolved ones later . I believed it can solve the precipitated issue. 

 

to SKF forum member.  please join this topic/conversation. is open for all members. 

thanks. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zoidburg

It's Seachem's recommendation actually not to use with planted tanks and I just feel Equilibrium is better if we are going to choose between the two for shrimp.

From https://www.seachem.com/replenish.php

Quote

Should I use Replenish™ in my live-planted aquarium for restoring mineral content and increasing GH?

A: We recommend using Replenish™ in a community tank without live plants, as it contains sodium and chloride, which can be harmful to plants. To restore or increase GH in a planted aquarium, use Equilibrium™

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chongkt

zoidburg  

 

many thanks for the info.  I'll go for Equilibrium. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
chongkt

sorry.  didn't buy  Equilibrium.  friend gave one seachem replenish for free.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • jayc
      Oops did I mix them around?
    • DKC
      Ok then. Will add more plants to try and reduce nitrates.  Thanks Simon and JayC for the pointers and hints. I think the Dino Spit is the Glutaraldehyde and the Dino Pee has the macro and micronutrients. I will leave off the Glutaraldehyde and reduce the dose of the Pee to one third. I am pretty careful with the dosing.  Good news is that there are at least two RCS females still in the tank and looking well. Maybe they went and hid and moulded after the big water change? The surviving  DAE are all looking well.  Anyway will take all your advice on board and do smaller water changes and work out a dripper system.
    • ShrimpNewb
    • beanbag
      jayc's comments on letting remineralized water sit around got me thinking.  I've had pre-mixed up batches of water sitting around for a month or more with no obvious growth.  I asked the Salty Shrimp people about this, but unfortunately they replied back to me in German, and google translate doesn't seem to work too well.  So if anybody knows German, here is their reply: " prinzipiell ist es kein Problem dein mit Bee Shrimp GH+ aufgesalzenes
      Osmosewasser zu lagern, jedoch werden dabei einige Spurenelemente
      verloren gehen. Dies hat sich bei unds allerdings noch nicht als negativ
      herausgestellt, da wir selbst meist eine Menge von ca. 1000l aufgesalzen
      parat haben. "    
    • beanbag
      Even though this isn't the acute cause of your problem, the nitrates are too high.
×