Jump to content

Cannister filter or sump which one is better?


plecofan09

Recommended Posts

Hi guys,

Im in the process of building a 3 tier tanks to try to keep higher grade shrimps and maybe try keeping KK.

My question is

1- is it better to use a cannister per tank

2- is a sump better ?

i would perfer a sump as it is easier to maintain, but scare about if there is something wrong with one tank it would affect the other tanks.

what do you guys think?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My breeding tank is setup with a cannister filter & a sump.......works perfectly...All outflows goes into the sump, and in your case you can have say 2 canisters, one running the LHS of the tank, and the other the RHS...i.e. the cannister sucks water from the sump, and the outflow goes into the tanks...Ensure you have a tap to each tank, just in case you need to isolate it....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My breeding tank is setup with a cannister filter & a sump.......works perfectly...All outflows goes into the sump' date=' and in your case you can have say 2 canisters, one running the LHS of the tank, and the other the RHS...i.e. the cannister sucks water from the sump, and the outflow goes into the tanks...Ensure you have a tap to each tank, just in case you need to isolate it....[/quote']

BB,

i was planning to put a sump on the rhs and i have a teco chiller with uv on the other side , water flows in the sump then sump pump goes to chiller then a make up a manifold with valve for each tank so i can control flow on each tank.

Eshrimp, looking at the cannister option if i got 3 eheim 2217 =60 watts vs 2500lph sump pump =35 watts so really the sump pump works out to be cheaper running cost.

either way i only have room for either a sump or 3 cannisters on my rack as i want it all hidden.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi plecofan

Just remember that you have to upscale your pump if its pushing to a higher level 2500lph might not be enough flow and also your higher tanks will be warmer. I have a rack with a sump but over half of it runs on individual cannisters its down to what will work best for you. Give us some more info on what you intend to do. And your right, on a system if one tank gets sick it spreads through the lot. Hope this helps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you set up the sump correctly it will do a much better job than any amount of canisters and is cheaper to run and also adds to the volume of water in the system which in turn creates more stability.

if you run a UV filter on the system you wont have the problem of bacteria crashing the entire system.

and if you are able to maintain water parameters in a small tank than the larger system will be no problem at all..

i run sumps with UV only on all my racks and everything is great :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tropo , yeah thinking of Getting a bigger sump pump maybe 4000lph with a 3mtr height pressure.

Dean, yeah hopefully I can get it right, I have beening discussing with a mate and hopefully have it all sus out.

I will put a build post soon just need to take more pics .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you set up the sump correctly it will do a much better job than any amount of canisters and is cheaper to run and also adds to the volume of water in the system which in turn creates more stability.

if you run a UV filter on the system you wont have the problem of bacteria crashing the entire system.

and if you are able to maintain water parameters in a small tank than the larger system will be no problem at all..

i run sumps with UV only on all my racks and everything is great :)

i agree with bro Dean... if the sump is set up correctly it can do a great job (and definitely much cheaper then canisters... because I am doing a swap now from sump to canister... *stress*).. Large water volume can be very stable, just control yourself from adding stuff..

Bro Dean, can I check with you on your sump set up.. have you experience a point of 'maximum' bioloading where the shrimps just breed but shrimplets dont survive.. juveniles starts dying.. but the rest are still ok... just for my info because for mine, although they can breed very well and do very well but once i hit a certain quantity for the whole set up.. those issues will happen... and my reason for pinpointing to that is because when i start to net some of the shrimps (approximately 100~150pcs) out... everything went back to normal... shrimps are on a roll again... I have yet to get this issue from my canister running tanks and their bioload already hit more then the whole rack in 1 tank..

i also noticed that sump set up will just make water find the easiest way to move through the media, so what i did previously was to pack the media until there is 'no easiest' way to move for the water other then pass through the media for maximum bacteria growth area...

Sorry, i dont know if i am right or wrong in my theory.. but its just what i have experience... hehe

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i agree with bro Dean... if the sump is set up correctly it can do a great job (and definitely much cheaper then canisters... because I am doing a swap now from sump to canister... *stress*).. Large water volume can be very stable' date=' just control yourself from adding stuff..

Bro Dean, can I check with you on your sump set up.. have you experience a point of 'maximum' bioloading where the shrimps just breed but shrimplets dont survive.. juveniles starts dying.. but the rest are still ok... just for my info because for mine, although they can breed very well and do very well but once i hit a certain quantity for the whole set up.. those issues will happen... and my reason for pinpointing to that is because when i start to net some of the shrimps

(approximately 100~150pcs) out... everything went back to normal... shrimps are on a roll again... I have yet to get this issue from my canister running tanks

and their bioload already hit more then the whole rack in 1 tank..

i also noticed that sump set up will just make water find the easiest way to move through the media, so what i did previously was to pack the media until there is 'no easiest' way to move for the water other then pass through the media for maximum bacteria growth area...

Sorry, i dont know if i am right or wrong in my theory.. but its just what i have experience... hehe[/quote']

Thanks Alvin for your info..

Thats good to read so your sump setup can only handle a certain amount of shrimp, where as the cannister setup can handle way more shrimps. Is that right?

do you have the same media in both set ups?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i agree with bro Dean... if the sump is set up correctly it can do a great job (and definitely much cheaper then canisters... because I am doing a swap now from sump to canister... *stress*).. Large water volume can be very stable' date=' just control yourself from adding stuff..

Bro Dean, can I check with you on your sump set up.. have you experience a point of 'maximum' bioloading where the shrimps just breed but shrimplets dont survive.. juveniles starts dying.. but the rest are still ok... just for my info because for mine, although they can breed very well and do very well but once i hit a certain quantity for the whole set up.. those issues will happen... and my reason for pinpointing to that is because when i start to net some of the shrimps (approximately 100~150pcs) out... everything went back to normal... shrimps are on a roll again... I have yet to get this issue from my canister running tanks and their bioload already hit more then the whole rack in 1 tank..

i also noticed that sump set up will just make water find the easiest way to move through the media, so what i did previously was to pack the media until there is 'no easiest' way to move for the water other then pass through the media for maximum bacteria growth area...

Sorry, i dont know if i am right or wrong in my theory.. but its just what i have experience... hehe[/quote']

Are you sure you're not underfeeding your shrimp?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Alvin for your info..Thats good to read so your sump setup can only handle a certain amount of shrimp' date=' where as the cannister setup can handle way more shrimps. Is that right?do you have the same media in both set ups?[/quote']I have better medias in the sump set up then the canisters ones..I felt that it might be the way the water force through the media makes it different..Well, I am feeding them minimum of once a day to maximum of twice.. Powder food for enhance growth, coloration... Haha...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

i agree with bro Dean... if the sump is set up correctly it can do a great job (and definitely much cheaper then canisters... because I am doing a swap now from sump to canister... *stress*).. Large water volume can be very stable' date=' just control yourself from adding stuff..

Bro Dean, can I check with you on your sump set up.. have you experience a point of 'maximum' bioloading where the shrimps just breed but shrimplets dont survive.. juveniles starts dying.. but the rest are still ok... just for my info because for mine, although they can breed very well and do very well but once i hit a certain quantity for the whole set up.. those issues will happen... and my reason for pinpointing to that is because when i start to net some of the shrimps (approximately 100~150pcs) out... everything went back to normal... shrimps are on a roll again... I have yet to get this issue from my canister running tanks and their bioload already hit more then the whole rack in 1 tank..

i also noticed that sump set up will just make water find the easiest way to move through the media, so what i did previously was to pack the media until there is 'no easiest' way to move for the water other then pass through the media for maximum bacteria growth area...

Sorry, i dont know if i am right or wrong in my theory.. but its just what i have experience... hehe[/quote']

Hi Alvin, I have not found this problem in any of my setups running sumps. My sumps are almost 3meters long and have many stages of filtration and media, the most important thing I have learnt with running a sump is that you need to feed the sump to keep them running at full capacity. The amount of shrimp living in a tank will only hit a maximum capacity when there is not enough biofilm for the babies to feed on, regardless of feeding they still need natural biofilm and correct mineral content for high survival rates.

I only run sumps now on all my tanks as I have found that with the corect setup they are much more efficient, long as you feed them to keep the bio mass high.

Hope that helps a little ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Alvin' date=' I have not found this problem in any of my setups running sumps. My sumps are almost 3meters long and have many stages of filtration and media, the most important thing I have learnt with running a sump is that you need to feed the sump to keep them running at full capacity. The amount of shrimp living in a tank will only hit a maximum capacity when there is not enough biofilm for the babies to feed on, regardless of feeding they still need natural biofilm and correct mineral content for high survival rates.

I only run sumps now on all my tanks as I have found that with the corect setup they are much more efficient, long as you feed them to keep the bio mass high.

Hope that helps a little ;)[/quote']

Yes, i fully agree that you have to constantly be maximizing the sump's biomedia to grow and mature. For biofilm, and food for babies, i believe i have enough because i do feed powder food specifically for babies which adults will eat also.. biofilm dont grow fast enough to feed the shrimps i guess.. haha..

maybe my experience with sump set up is not good and strong enough... :( But based on comparing the 2 set ups which I am having, i can see the difference between the 2.. which is why i am more incline towards canisters if want stability easier.. i still love my sump set up still.. hahaha...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

just to add my 2 cents in, my sump has been nothing but fantastic for me. but so has my cannisters! i would have to say that both run well but if you are going to do a 3 rack system, sump is way more efficient and cheaper to run. plus more space for bio media!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      Thats a great photo, beautiful blue bolt, I hope it survived the molt without dropping the eggs! I think I can just about see some black dots (eyes) on the central egg but can't be 100% sure. I used to (and plan to again) do weekly water change of 10-15% but if you do too large or quick (not drip in new water) that would likely trigger a molt. What KH are they in, my new setup is sitting at (and refusing to budge) KH 3 and PH 7.5 so I may have to settle for neocaridina shrimp this time as opposed to the caridina I want, though not looking/deciding just yet, give the tank a bit more of a run in! Tap water here starts at kH 14, tds 320, when filtered goes to KH 0 and PH 6 but when put in the tank keeps going to KH3 and PH 7.5 despite 3 x 50% water changes???? You may be at 'maximum capacity' with only 20L tank especially if the tank is a cube type rather than shallow type?
    • beanbag
      Right now this tank only has blue bolts and golden bee (red bolts?).  The eggs start off all brown, but at the end, I notice that some are kind of a clear pink-ish color.  So I don't know if that is the egg color of dud or golden bee.  Picture of shrimp only about half hour before molting. The water is always RO + remineralizer, so it should be ok. The tank seems to still be on a "good streak" ever since I started the regimen of weekly water change, monthly gravel vac and plant trim.  The point being to keep the amount of waste low and removing moss / floating plants so that the nitrates go towards growing algae.  At one point, I had three berried females, but only netted about half dozen babies by the end, due to this early molting problem.  There might be about 30-40 shrimp total in 5 gallons, but still very few full-sized adults.
    • ngoomie
      Alright, I've done a bit more research on gentian violet's cancer-causing potential but I haven't yet done research on malachite green's to compare. But from reading the California propositon 65 document about GV (North Americans incl. some Canadians will recognize this as the law that causes some products they buy to be labelled with "known to the state of California to cause cancer", including the exact product I bought) it seems that the risk of cancer is related to internal use, either injection or ingestion. Speaking of ingestion, I think GV bans mainly relate to its use in treating fish/shrimp/etc. which are intended for human consumption, because of the above. And in countries where GV isn't banned for this purpose, it does seem to get used on various species of shrimp without causing any issue for the shrimp themselves (at least enough so for shrimp farming purposes). See the following: In February, the FDA Began Rejecting Imported Shrimp for Gentian Violet and Chloramphenicol (2022 article by Southern Shrimp Alliance) FDA Starts New Calendar Year by Refusing Antibiotic-Contaminated Shrimp from Three BAP-Certified Indian Processors and Adding a BAP-Certified Vietnamese Processor to Import Alert (2024 article by Southern Shrimp Alliance) Southern Shrimp Alliance and some other organizations have tons of other articles in this vein, but I'd be here for a while and would end up writing an absolutely massive post if I were to link every instance I found of articles mentioning shrimp shipments with gentian violet and/or leucogentian violet registering as contaminants. That being said, I know shrimp farmed for consumption and dwarf shrimp are often somewhat distantly related (in fact, the one time a shrimp's species name is listed that I can see, it's the prawn sp. Macrobrachium rosenbergii, who at best occupies the same infraorder as Neocaridina davidi but nothing nearer), but this at least gives a slightly better way of guessing whether it will be safe for aquarium dwarf shrimp or not than my bladder snail anecdote from the OP.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I would hazard a guess that perhaps those eggs were unfertilized and thereby unviable? Did the eggs change colour, usually yellow to grey as the yolks used up, or any eyes in the eggs. Is your water ok, using RO remineralised and the parameters in range, as I have heard others say that if the water isn't good it can 'force' a molt? How is it going overall, do you have a good size colony in the tank, you may have reached 'maximum occupancy' as a tank can only support so many occupants.
    • beanbag
      Hello folks,  The current problem I am having is that my Taiwan bee shrimp are molting before all their eggs have hatched.  Often the shrimp keep the eggs for 40+ days.  During that time, they lose about half or so, either due to dropping or duds or whatever.  Shortly before molting they look to have about a dozen left, and then they molt with about half a dozen eggs still on the shell.  Then the other shirmp will come and eat the shell.  These last few times, I have been getting around 0-3 surviving babies per batch.  I figure I can make the eggs hatch faster by raising the water temperature more (currently around 68F, which is already a few degrees higher than I used to keep it) or make the shrimp grow slower by feeding them less (protein).  Currently I feed Shrimp King complete every other day, and also a small dab of Shrimp Fit alternating days.  Maybe I can start alternating with more vegetable food like mulberry?  or just decrease the amount of food?
×
×
  • Create New...