Clicky

Jump to content
beanbag

A shrimp molted, got eggs, and died

Recommended Posts

beanbag

Hello folks,

I've had this orange neo shrimp in my tank for about 4 months now, and it was generally doing ok. These last 2-3 weeks, it seemed less active, but still ate, so whatever. Last night, it seemed to be actively exploring the tank but not eating. This morning it molted, and I saw it laying on it's side, barely moving. But with some prodding, it would get up and walk around. I then noticed that it was carrying eggs, which is weird because the only other neo (blue) in the tank is also supposed to be female. (At least that's what the guy at the store said. That shrimp doesn't have a saddle, but does seem to have the egg-protecting "side shirts" of mature female shrimp.)

Anyway, this shrimp was near death, usually being motionless, occasionally staggering around and falling on it's back, and then not getting up for a while. I put it in semi-quarantine (i.e. inside a net in the main tank with some plants and a chunk of food nearby) so that the other shrimp won't annoy it and steal its food. But it died after about a day.

When I tried to search on this topic, it seems lots of people have berried shrimp die, but not usually right after molting and getting eggs. I also can't see how this is molting related, as this shrimp, and all others have done it several times in this tank.

As for my tank, yes there is something sub-optimal about it, as my shrimp aren't as active as the ones I see at the fish store. (They aren't active 100% of the time.) The orange neo was relatively active the last 2 months or so, and quickly gained in size over the other shrimp. But then it started slowing down a bit 3 weeks ago, and I think it was getting over-due for a molt. 3-4 days before the molt, it had eaten a lot, so I wasn't worried about lack of nutrition or anything.

BTW, is it possible for a shrimp to be berried with unfertilized eggs?  I am not sure if the only other neo in the tank is male or female.

Tank parameters: Ammonia 0, nitrite 0, nitrate 0 (yes, it has been 0 ever since I've had floating plants)
pH mid 6's
gH 6-7, kH 0-1 due to buffered substrate
temp 71F
other inhabitants: two amano shirmp and one blue neo shrimp, who have also been around for 4 months and are doing fine.

I attached a pic of the orange berried shrimp, and also the potential mate.  Does the blue shrimp look like a female?

IMG_20190119_173028-2.jpg

IMG_20190120_140637~3.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sdlTBfanUK
43 minutes ago, beanbag said:

Hello folks,

I've had this orange neo shrimp in my tank for about 4 months now, and it was generally doing ok. These last 2-3 weeks, it seemed less active, but still ate, so whatever. Last night, it seemed to be actively exploring the tank but not eating. This morning it molted, and I saw it laying on it's side, barely moving. But with some prodding, it would get up and walk around. I then noticed that it was carrying eggs, which is weird because the only other neo (blue) in the tank is also supposed to be female. (At least that's what the guy at the store said. That shrimp doesn't have a saddle, but does seem to have the egg-protecting "side shirts" of mature female shrimp.)

Anyway, this shrimp was near death, usually being motionless, occasionally staggering around and falling on it's back, and then not getting up for a while. I put it in semi-quarantine (i.e. inside a net in the main tank with some plants and a chunk of food nearby) so that the other shrimp won't annoy it and steal its food. But it died after about a day.

When I tried to search on this topic, it seems lots of people have berried shrimp die, but not usually right after molting and getting eggs. I also can't see how this is molting related, as this shrimp, and all others have done it several times in this tank.

As for my tank, yes there is something sub-optimal about it, as my shrimp aren't as active as the ones I see at the fish store. (They aren't active 100% of the time.) The orange neo was relatively active the last 2 months or so, and quickly gained in size over the other shrimp. But then it started slowing down a bit 3 weeks ago, and I think it was getting over-due for a molt. 3-4 days before the molt, it had eaten a lot, so I wasn't worried about lack of nutrition or anything.

BTW, is it possible for a shrimp to be berried with unfertilized eggs?  I am not sure if the only other neo in the tank is male or female.

Tank parameters: Ammonia 0, nitrite 0, nitrate 0 (yes, it has been 0 ever since I've had floating plants)
pH mid 6's
gH 6-7, kH 0-1 due to buffered substrate
temp 71F
other inhabitants: two amano shirmp and one blue neo shrimp, who have also been around for 4 months and are doing fine.

I attached a pic of the orange berried shrimp, and also the potential mate.  Does the blue shrimp look like a female?

IMG_20190119_173028-2.jpg

IMG_20190120_140637~3.jpg

Sorry to hear about your problem.

You may be able to save the eggs, JoJo has recently done this (she had the same happen) and I think I attached a yoytube video I saw on setting this up if you have the stuff and want to give it a go, worth it if you only have a few shrimps? I can send another link to the video if you want?

The blue one looks like a female to me! Have you lost any shrimps from this tank in the last 3 weeks, maybe (if you have) that was the father?

The water parameters look more caridina than neocaridinia, but I don't know whether that may have caused the death?

Sorry, but I can't really be of any more help......

Simon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
beanbag

No, there haven't been any other neos in the tank for a while now.

I guess that means the eggs are unfertilized and there is no point trying to hatch them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jojowhisky

Hello beanbag!
I apologize that i did not see your thread earlier.
Ok from what i read, there is no such thing as unfertilized eggs. Meaning when the females are berried all of those are gonna be live hatches.
If they are not fertilized, the eggs will not be moved down to her tummy at the bottom as you have seen on your berried mama and they will show the saddle.(sexually matured but not pregnant)

I am so sorry i did not see your thread earlier as i would have encouraged you to give a go at hatching those eggs yourself?
It is possible to do that, kind of gross at first but it is possible.
I know it is a silly question but do you still have those eggs?

For mamas, there are many reasons why they die.
I read a first time mama may "drop" her eggs after molting. In this case, you can also save the eggs.
For me, personally my shrimps used to die because of shifts in water parameters and also during water changes i dont really know what im doing. (I was all over the place)
I have learnt from the kind people here that taught me, getting a book and changing the exact same water amount every time and gradually lowering or altering the individual values very slowly helps.
Than note the date, amount changed, parameters before and after water changes in the book. This helps me take note of what needs to be changed and how to.
@sdlTBfanUK simon always reminds me to drip all new water into the tank very slowly. Quick changes to the water kills them pretty fast.

Please dont feel too sad as well,@zoidburg did mention once that sometimes the shrimps are already advanced in years when you got them? Sometimes its one of those things?

Your parameters i may not be the best to advice you on what is right?
But all i can say is keep it stable most importantly?

I have a 16litre main tank with crystals and blood marys(neos) my gh is 6 and kh is 0, quite similar to yours? And my ph is 6.3 also with an active substrate. Im still using distilled water remineralized. Will switch to rodi when im back from my trip.
If you still have the eggs for any reason, this is what i attempted, by any means it does not look pretty but it works:

https://skfaquatics.com/forum/topic/14201-new-tank-setup-for-yellow-shrimps/
Sorry if its a lengthy thread i think i was very longwinded , scroll down to see what to do with the eggs ok?

This is the video simon shared with me, good as well:



I hope everything works out good for you ok?
Regards,
Jo

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
beanbag

Thanks for the suggestions.  But so far, 4 out of 4 people on the internet said that my only other blue neo shrimp is a female.  So I guess that means that if a female carries eggs in her saddle for too long (in this case, maybe 3 months), she will eventually "release" them and then die, or something like that.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jojowhisky
Thanks for the suggestions.  But so far, 4 out of 4 people on the internet said that my only other blue neo shrimp is a female.  So I guess that means that if a female carries eggs in her saddle for too long (in this case, maybe 3 months), she will eventually "release" them and then die, or something like that.
Oh really? Never did hear somethig like that. Guess its good to learn new things.
Hope everything is looking up for you.

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • richiep
      hi to all a friend of mine as had a load of shrimp die and didnt know why he sent me photoes and said these red spots appear and a few days later they are dead, all water perameters have been checkek and are fine.before they die they lie on their side an just move theis swimmers also the red patches go clear like an ulsar ive looked at these shrimp and believe it is rust spot but would like a second oppinion third or fourth, i thank you in advance Richie
    • beanbag
      No, because you would never be able to clean it out.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I don't think most people measure GH or KH in parts per million, I think your results would be KH 0-1 and GH 3-4. You don't need to remember the colour the drops should change too, as, as you say the colour in the test tube should match the original drops colour to get your reading. You may need to get some GH/KH+ for cherry/neocaridina shrimp, as your results are nearer caridina shrimp parameters. Cherry shrimp though are a lot tougher than bee shrimps so they may even survive in the parameters you have but not do as well? Anyway, if you are still cycling you can come back to that nearer the time that is done. The best shrimps to get are juveniles as you know you will have them longer (you can't tell how old an adult is) and they are better suited to adapting to new water parameters etc. You may find the below video interesting and useful as it covers virtually all you need to know at the start:- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8pO6iJPbmdk Simon
    • jayc
      HI Welcome to SKFA. Are your shrimps eating the crab cuisine at all? I don't blame them if they are not eating it. There are much better alternatives out there. Crabs will eat any junk, but shrimps are a lot pickier in their choice of food. Have a read of the numerous choices in the "Food & Nutrition" subforum. And remember, you don't have to limit yourself (and the shrimps) to processed foods. Look at leaves, flowers, vegetable off cuts or even frozen bloodworms.
    • jayc
      Why oh why do you disagree with me? 😄
×