Clicky

Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Ishtarduzzie

The trials, tribulations and (hopefully) sucesses of new shrimper!

Recommended Posts

Ishtarduzzie

Hello SKF readers!

To save me starting multiple threads and also so I know here to find answers I am doing a journal/question thread.

If I put this in the wrong spot JayC/mods then feel free to move it or tell me to re-make :D

Sorry.... this WILL be long probably and I appreciate any time you take to read and answer my questions!

 

So, on Thursday (edit: tomorrow now according to an email from AU Post) I have a package coming from The Tech Den with a Aquael Shrimp Set Smart 30 and a few other goodies.

My plans so far are:

  •          Iron sand (found posts saying shrimp when ok with it).... May need more than the 2kg I initially got...?
  •          An amazing piece of Gold Vine that I found at my local pet store
  •          The light and filter (modified) from the kit with the heater only being used in winter if needed
  •          Filtered water (RO maybe? It is a 2 canister counter top carbon and sediment drinking water filter gifted by my mum a few months ago. Unsure brand etc) with JayC’s DIY remineraliser
  •              IAL and alder cones
  •         Some ceramic hidey holes
  •         API GH/KH and Master kits
  •         TSD pen - Xiaomi Professional TDS Meter from eBay

Still need:

  •            TDS pen as I forget to check the pet store and Tech Den were out – Recommendations?
  •           Plants
  •           Shrimp – Would like blue dreams and maybe glass shrimp
  •           Fish – Big IF! I am worried about eating all the baby shrimp. Spotted rasbora since they are sooo tiny if any.

So, according to the local store the light from the kit is pretty good and I have seen quite a few good things about the filter around YT and such. I was thinking of modifying it like this with a single though: https://youtu.be/I_ckQpO8GBo

My old 16L (does not fit in spot and wary of using for fish since it housed mice) has been a bit of a dummy test on water temps and for the last week has been in a safe range. None of these have been 40+ days though so I will probably need to air-con or get a cooler for coming into next summer.... or something (nowhere near planned this part since should be cooling off by time cycled).

So... to break up some questions that relate to the ‘still need’ list:

-          I was thinking plant wise Anubias nana petite, Java fern narrow (still need to source somewhere to get... not sure local store has anything other than plain) and.... a moss...

I was hoping for something less stringy than Java moss. It is just so..... wild lol
Fissiden sp. ‘Vietnam’ and Mini Pellia are calling to me but are slow growers and needs med-high light and I think Co2... filter has a Co2 option if needed.... but NO clue what a 6w, 8000K LED translates to on a nano tank... and I guess that would depend on other planting...
Also pondering about Peacock and Phoenix? But probably similar problem....

Maybe I should just wait for if I get a bigger tank.... for anything other than Java lol *sighs*

-          Sourcing blue dream shrimp! Your trade section does not seem to get many responses lol
My local has glass shrimp (Australian... soooo Paratya australiensis?) who looked blue tinged at least, cherry red and cherry yello but no source of cherry blue.
Would appreciate sources to get from Newcastle or Sydney! Gumtree makes me hesitate though I have found people with them up on there. One seems a safer bet but maybe not as easy to get to. A second one has potential and very easy for me to get to for Newcastle (no car).

-          Now... going with plants that don’t need a planted substrate.... should I still actually go with an actual buffering/planted substrate for bacterial reasons...? Should I add hidden biomedia sock or anything like that since the bacteria won’t really colonise in a thin layer of sand, unlike a planted tank.

 

Starting to get into the excited but freaking out I am doing something to mess it up bad stage.

Blue dreams are more expensive than I was wanting to be learning on... but if I get red cherries that would just mean another tank later lol

Edited by Ishtarduzzie
Update
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Madmerv

G'day @Ishtarduzzie

I will cover a few of your questions there.

First up a two stage sediment filter is not a RO unit. It will not remove the salts and chemicals that are present in your tap water so you will still have to use dechlorinators and the PH/TDS of the water will be the same. Google Reverse osmosis units and you will see why. A remineraliser may not be needed.

Not all plants need a substrate, just the root feeders, but all plants need some fertilizer. With a thin layer of iron sand there might be enough flow of water through the sand that even root feeders could get what they need if the water column is dosed. Most shrimp keepers use a buffering sub to bring down the PH of the water to something close to what the shrimp prefer not really for the plant growing ability. Your shrimp selection, tap water/RO, plant selection will dictate what sub to go with. Going with iron sand, that is inert, will mean getting the water to the desired parameters before adding and having nothing in the tank that will affect it.

That being said buying your shrimp from a local breeder with the same water as yours can negate all the hassle as a lot of the shrimp out there have the amazing ability to adapt to the local conditions and will thrive with what you already have. 

Disclaimer: This is advice and it's free. You get what you pay for and i'm taking no responsibility if you put $200 worth of CRS in tap water because the breeder said it was ok and they turn turtle. 

I hope some of that helps.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Thanks for the reply @Madmerv!

Beware rambling below in response and just random thoughts/notes as I reply over like two hours of distractions lol

On 2/18/2018 at 7:37 AM, Madmerv said:

Disclaimer: This is advice and it's free. You get what you pay for and i'm taking no responsibility if you put $200 worth of CRS in tap water because the breeder said it was ok and they turn turtle.

Hahahaha Don't worry, I will automatically assume I messed something up myself.... I have a 'gift' of it at times.

Also I am not going anywhere near CRS for a looonnnggg time. First I need to get blue cherries to survive.... AND thrive... which is daunting enough for this newbie 😥

On 2/18/2018 at 7:37 AM, Madmerv said:

First up a two stage sediment filter is not a RO unit. It will not remove the salts and chemicals that are present in your tap water so you will still have to use dechlorinators and the PH/TDS of the water will be the same.

Yeah, figured this was the case once the Master kit turned up and started to test things.

Using Seachem Prime to dechlorinate the water. Slightly more than recommended due water amount.

After letting the tank sit the TDS has gone up. I assume this is due to the sand or wood. Was 120-odd then 200-odd just before I did a water change. GH and KH also increased after time in the tank.... or my first results were wrong.... think it was user error since today's test was the same as the second 🤔

Was only water logging the gold vine so haven't officially started the cycle (starting today).

Glad I didn't because the filter got super clogged after a day or two of having the wood in there. After the first few days it has been running smooth... Obviously just cleaning out whatever I missed after a two day soak and scrub to remove the worst 🙄

As of this very present second after a huge 90%-odd water change to remove some debris and a good portion of the tannin it is at:

  • TDS 140
  • PH 7 (seems to go between 6.8 - 7-ish)
  • GH 5
  • KH 3

I quite like the tannin but needed to reduce what was in the tank as there was getting a lot of tea scum build up and it was just a smidge too much like more morning drink colour.

On 2/18/2018 at 7:37 AM, Madmerv said:

With a thin layer of iron sand there might be enough flow of water through the sand that even root feeders could get what they need if the water column is dosed.

*nods* I will talk to the fish just at the shop on Saturday when I am picking up my plants on if and how much ferts he thinks I will need for the plants.

I ordered in the java narrow and the anubis nana. For the life of me I forgot if we agreed on java or riccia moss.

So tempting looking at all the amazing plants... especially the purple ones.... and then remembering they need more care than I planned to give (also my favourite two were not true aquatics aka dragon flame and mauve stricta).

I am very glad that both the people at the local pet stores (with specialist fish people) have actually kept shrimp at home. Actually both stores even HAD cherries in but not great quality ones. Makes a conversation/asking advice so much easier when they know what I am going on about 😆

 

Anyways.... here it is so far. Plants will go in Saturday after I get them 😊

Java will be back left corner to ideally grow up behind, anubias on the wood and moss around the bottom areas. Will put the 'housing' in with the plants.

C3cLQgA.jpg

If you are still reading, thanks for making it this far!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
WhySoCRS

Nice piece of driftwood, look nice with some dwarf hair grass planted around it.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Thanks @WhySoCRS. I really loved that piece of wood. Had NOT planned on buying it that day and it was a smidge too big (hello hacksaw) but couldn't say walk away from it.

So.... an update that is not really an update

Ok... So now that the tank is actually cycling the wood has started to grow a fungus.

Despite knowing this is relatively normal for new woods it did freak me out a little when I noticed it today. Part of me is tempted to pull it out and scrub it off... but people say it will go away by itself 😕

Picked up an anubias nana and a very small amount of java moss from the store.

Turns out the narrow leaf java fern has been delayed... So back next week I guess!

Keeping an eye on the parameters and the TDS is going up noticeably each day. I can only assume the iron plant is leaching some minerals. Since plants use iron, I am hoping they will counter the leaching of the sand a little now they are added.... Though I do not expect this to be noticeable necessarily. At least nothing should have an iron deficiency 😜

Now to slowly watch the tests and monitor any changes.

Pushed up the ammonia levels a little because they were sitting at around 1ppm. They are sitting somewhere between 2 and 4ppm now. Maybe 3ppm? Sort of  a mid colour between the two.

Also I think I found a breeder off a Facebook auction group in Sydney that has some beautiful blue cherries. They will be about $10 each which is a LITTLE wince worthy (when I am so worried about some dying off), but seem within the mid range of prices. Now to save for them! 😁

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Madmerv

G'day @Ishtarduzzie

How much is your TDS going up each day? Where is it at now/before WC?

You can scrub the wood clean for the sake of looks if you want but the shrimp will take care of it when they are introduced.

3ppm of ammonia is about right to get the cycle really cranking along but drop that down a bit once you have a good reading of nitrite so you dont over populate your filter. When you put shrimp in there they only have a small bioload and the extra BB in the filter will starve and die. That might cause a swing in the tank and it is important to keep things stable when they are introduced.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

QwOGehV.jpg

Stats so far...

I was naughty and missed two days due to utter chaos in the house.

Each ammonia test at 1ppm or less I added about 8 drops more after it.

 In other news.... Yay NO2 🤗

Edited by Ishtarduzzie
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Madmerv

Your tank is looking fine. A TDS rise of 20ppm in 5 days is nothing to worry about especially when it is new and you are adding ammonia, leaching new wood, new substrate, evaporation etc.

Keep adding ammonia drops every day even when the reading is 0 so the BB have that food source. Do a WC of 20% or so once a week and the hardest thing of all. Have patience.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Thank you @Madmerv

Have a w/c planned for today anyway because of tannin starting to build up a little scum and getting a smidge too dark for my liking. I am also paranoid the plants may need some fresh water to refresh any lost minerals.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Minor update.

More water stats. We are into No3 territory! Another step closer. 

Can’t test it tonight because beating the daylight out of the bottle will wake partner.

Bk4cKMr.jpg

Still waiting on needle leaf have which is proving to be a bit problematic for my local pet shop to source it seems. Spent a good portion of time staring at their dozen shrimp trying to sex them for ‘practice’.

Found a store called Scoop Wholefoods that sells bee pollen per gram so got 2tbs worth for about $1. Got a little to test.

Algae starting to build up a little on a few surfaces. Noticeably the filter suction cups in particular. Will be good when the clean up crew arrive.

PH today also tested twice orange (close to 6.4 but it was orange) for normal test. Not sure what was wrong... will wash better and do all again tomorrow followed by water change.

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Ok... nope... it looks like it has indeed dropped to 6.4. 

Water change of 60-ish% put it at 6.6 for that evenings and the next days test. Now back to 6.4..... and 8 drops of ammonia processed in 24hrs put 8 in at 11pm last night... tested this morning and it was 0.25 and no2 present. Now both at zero.

It just seems.... way too sudden to have such a drastic change in 48hrs. I also expected it to be at least two more weeks.

So... I will keep a eye on and make sure not an anomaly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
9 hours ago, Ishtarduzzie said:

Water change of 60-ish%

Did you use dechlorinated tap water?

9 hours ago, Ishtarduzzie said:

8 drops of ammonia processed in 24hrs put 8 in at 11pm last night... tested this morning and it was 0.25 and no2 present. Now both at zero.

Looks promising. Did you seed the tank with BB?

Edited by jayc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie
4 hours ago, jayc said:

Did you use dechlorinated tap water?

Yeah dosed with Prime and sitting for about a week.

4 hours ago, jayc said:


Looks promising. Did you seed the tank with BB?

No booster used no... which is why I am a bit confused. Completely from scratch... unless some hitched with the plants when added three days in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Please someone tell me this isn’t planaria....?

I had thought ammonia straight was a way to discourage them over food..... 😓

At least there are still no shrimp in there.... so can do something about it without harming shrimpies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
12 hours ago, Ishtarduzzie said:

Please someone tell me this isn’t planaria....?

It is planaria unfortunately. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Damn.... 😭

Guess I should have got that “No Planaria” for a just-in-case that I decided against.....

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

*looks unsure* They still have no eyes and are still only 1-2mm big. That video was under a macro lense....

Are they actually rhabdocoela? They don't look 'flat' when they detach from the wall/glass either.

*is very confused but getting some Planaria Zero just in case cause cheaper* No Planaria is so expensive....

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ishtarduzzie

Well.... I had ordered some Planaria Zero but Boss Aquatics never charged or sent it (ordered it a second time because I thought I had messed up the first time but it DID work the second time).... *shrugs*

So my LFS said that specific planaria killers that are shrimp safe are a grey import and they wouldn't risk carrying (interesting). They suggested a copper dose since I have nothing in there.... That seemed to not work...... So..... Then I got frustrated and found out that the residual Prime may have been countering it? URGH!

My next step was to get more frustrated and just pull everything out, scrub the best I could, replace the substrate and 'restart' the best I could.

So far so good.... If they come back I will test with some glass shrimp... if they survive a few weeks I will get the neocaradina. If they don't I will just get some dwarf rasbora or a fighting fish and re-think.

If this fails... I will probably get a bigger tank for a different location and be MUCH more careful.

First tank dramas ftw. I am trying not to let it get me down and find other positives. Learning is good, right?! lol

jSGVeEA.jpg

On whole, it looks good though I think! It should make something, be it shrimp or fish (or damn worms) happy lol
 

Edited by Ishtarduzzie

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • Brooohm
      By Brooohm
      Hello SKF. 
      I have never owned or held shrimp before, but i have been inspired alot by ecospheres, or very basic shrimp enclosures. I would love to make a tank, which is mostly self independant (like a small ecosystem), that also means that i would love to be without filter. But im in a need of some knowledge first. Do you guys have any advice? My thoughts so far:

      A bowl or something like that as the tank.
      A lamp for heat/light
      Let my tank cycle for a couple of weeks before adding shrimp.
      Plants, am i fine taking some from my local pond? Also, do i need a source of algae first? Like a mossball.
      Substrate, again, am i fine taking some from my local pond? Also, what kind of substrate? Gravel, dirt?
      At last the shrimp, what kind? Is theyre saltwater, how does that work with the plants?
      If there is anything i havent talked about, some heads up is gladly welcomed :) 

      Thanks in advance.

       
    • Finley2
      By Finley2
      I have been using UP Aqua Shrimp Sand 1mm size for years with great success. Perfect product for me. However...
      I recently bought some from Tech Den (Australia). It was a larger size, about 2-3mm, and looked a little different.  It came in a vacuum-packed bag, instead of loose in a regular bag.  I figured it's just the larger size that I have heard about, but that it would be basically the same.  Not!  Within 90 days most of it has disintegrated to dust.  Stirring up the substrate produces dense, heavy clouds of 'smoke' - the disintegrated material. It's a disaster.
      Also the water chemistry is not quite the same. OK, but not perfect like before.
      Has anyone else experienced a change in this product, or know whether there is a fake version around?  
      Do any Australians here know where to buy the good 1mm UP Aqua Shrimp Sand, in the ordinary (non-vacuum) bag?
      Thanks.
    • jc12
      By jc12
      I have been a long time lurker on this forum and have learnt a lot from past and present members who have contributed to this forum. Thank you.
      This is my first 'real' post and I hope this would help anyone who might be considering building a rack themselves. As requested by @Disciple, hope this helps you too.
      Just a bit of background on my experience. My only previous build attempt was for a stand and sump for a 4x2x2. It was my first build dabbling with staining wood and using silicon for sump baffles, etc. As you can see from the photos below, they are pretty amateurish but I am happy for how it turned out as a first attempt. Next step is to fit some doors to it.
      The stand was built following this video by King of DIY. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jN4Y9AYuwcQ
      Anyway, this gives you an idea of the level of experience I have before I embark on my ambitious attempt to build a rack.
      Below are some photos of my 4x2x2, sump and stand build, and some of its inhabitants. Sorry they are not shrimp related and not of great quality taken using my phone.
       
      Stand and sump

       


      Filled up and planted.

       
      Display tank front view.

       
      Display tank side view.

       
      With background in place and tank inhabitants added consisting of altum flora discus, german blue rams, panda corydoras, cardinal tetras, otocinclus, red cherry shrimps, darwin algae shrimps and darwin red nose shrimps.

       
      Altum flora discus.

       
      Panda corydoras.

       
      German blue rams with their fry.

       
      I have browsed many build threads including some from here and have built on my ideas collectively from different sources. The specific post from @BlueBolts here: http://shrimpkeepersforum.com/forum/topic/1415-breeding-rack-no2/ has inspired me greatly and I would like to acknowledge that.
      I followed the DIY rack build as outlined here: http://shrimpkeepersforum.com/forum/topic/7063-diy-rack-for-under-50-in-under-2hrs/
       
      The plan, materials, and costs
      This rack will be located in the lounge room so it has to be 'display-ish' quality and light from it must not interfere with the TV or be too blinding to people sitting around the lounge room. Also, no unsightly hoses/pipes are to be seen. I managed to convince the Minister for Home Affairs that a canister filter and chiller by definition, is not categorised as hoses or pipes, and would be in no way unsightly. The LED display from the chiller would provide subtle mood lighting, and the gentle humming of the filter and soft soothe whirling of the chiller fan would be therapeutic for lounge surfers, and would also greatly enhance movie watching experience with enriched sound depth and effects.
      Hence I received approval to have a canister filter and chiller located next to the rack.
      I used 5 x 5.4m long 90x45mm MGP10 untreated structural pine bought and cut to size from Masters for $83.75. I find Masters generally sells timber cheaper than Bunnings. Since I have both of them close to where I live, I selectively buy what I need from where it is cheaper.
      The frame is held together by 10-8 x 75mm zinc plated countersunk screws. I bought a box of 250 screws from Bunnings for $27.50.
      The rack measures 1390 x 420 x 2200 mm (L x W x H). The plan is to hold 2 x 2'x15"x15" tanks on the top and middle tier each, and a 4'x15"x15" hospital/quarantine/grow out/sump tank on the bottom tier.
      Each tank would be insulated by 20mm foam around the sides, back and base as I plan to run both tropical (28-30 degrees C) and chilled (22-24 degrees C) tanks on this rack. Plumbing for air and sump would be hidden within the frame.
       
      Please disregard the mess in the background. Still sorting out stuff in the garage after the move.
      From this:

       
      To this:

    • KillieOrCory
      By KillieOrCory
      Hi all,
      As some of you know, my currently my set-up looks like this.
       
      With enormous amount of help and encouragement from my fiancee, we have now got the fishroom to this state.
      It feels awesome walking in there to play with water :o
      Amazingly for me things have not stop improving here! We are in the process of building a new house and getting a purpose build fishroom in it.
      The construction started just before Christmas last year.
       
      In this fishroom I wanted to have some of the things I wished I had or I had done in my current set-up.
      1st Priority: Insulation
      I wanted to be able to keep the room warm in winter and cool in summer with minimal power consumption. Living in Canberra we get cold winters (nights especially) and a week or two of extreme heat every summer.
      We decided to build the the whole structure; house and fishroom, with a relatively new building material suggested to us by our builder. It is a thermal facade system called 'Exsulite' it is manufactured by Dulux.
      It is a system that uses foam, foil, airgaps and various boards. It provides a lot better thermal protection than regular bricks for example.
       
      Between this system and the gyprock regular insulation batts are fitted. The whole house including the fishroom and the garage has insulation batts on the ceiling as well.
      I also decided against a door that opens to outside and windows to minimize heat loss through these.
      2nd Priority: Access to water
      I wanted to make sure I had all that I needed within the room in terms of access to water as well as getting rid of waste water. I decided to have a 42L laundry tub fitted into the room to provide all important 'cleaning' station. I no longer need to take over the laundry or worse the kitchen during certain maintenance of various fishkeeping related items.
       
      I have also got a separate tap installed next to the laundry tub to have my water reservoir line to be permanently connected to this tap. I won't need to connect and disconnect this line unnecessarily in the future.
      A center drain in the middle of the room was also a must.
       
      3rd Priority: Access to power
      As with almost everybody that is in the aquarium hobby, I always found I needed more power points than what is available around the tank/tanks. This always inevitably leads to using of powerboards, but even with using quality ones there is always potential to overload or something to go wrong.
      As much as possible I wanted to avoid using power boards and double adapters in the fishroom, though I know resistance is futile and I might resort to these at some stage.
      To ensure I have access to power where I needed I decided to get 20 quad power points installed in the room! That is 80 power points!!! I had to show photos of my current set-up to the builder and the electrician when their eyebrows were raised when I requested this. They were wondering why I need this much power? :anonymous:
      I am getting the power points put in two lines; one over the other. One line is going to be connected to a wired timer. These power points are for the lights. The second line is ordinary points for various other equipment.
       
      The electrician have put another box and 3 circuits in this room alone!
      4th Priority: Lighting and ventilation
      As already mentioned, will be lighting all my tanks relatively well by fishroom standards. I do not see the point of having a fishroom where you can't see the inhabitants of the tanks very well.
      Each row of tanks are to have LED lights fitted above them. I have recently been replacing my T8 fluoro units with these.
       
      I am finding this is saving me a lot of energy.
      As I have been known to leave smelly things in the fishroom; like a bucket of blackworms that have died, it was super important for my fiancee that the room can be easily ventilated! This was something I wanted anyway as the room has no windows and no access to outside aerating the room is not possible.
      We are getting a toilet/bathroom style exhaust fan installed in the room.
       
      Its a type of model that has flaps that close when not in operation providing no gap for heat loss.
      The room is getting two ceiling flouro lights as well, for the times I might walk into the room when the tank lights are off.
      That's about the progress so far. We are still couple of months away from completion.
    • Zebra
      By Zebra
      Hey hey hey,
      Hows things everyone?
      Ive been getting right back into shrimp in a major way now, Had a few days spare so I got around to re-sealing an old tank I had laying around and building a quick stand for it.
      This is being setup as a shrimp/ low tech planted mostly somewhere for all my anubias to live I have some rather large varieties now, just some lava rock as the main hardscape, then course white sand, lots of ferns etc.
      standard aquaone heater, and the filter I'm running is an aquaone 1050 series ii. It's quite new I got it on the cheap ages ago and it's sat there lol.
      The tank was already drilled through the bottom panel from an older project, so I decided to run a closed plumbing system which seems to have stopped the notorious dead spots you sometimes get in tanks bigger then 4ft. And it's working great with only a relatively small filter.
      Probably Going to end up being for my chameleons and or something else. Loving life right now, even though I didn't sleep and it's water change day today haha 
      peace ✌️ 






  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • ineke
      Unfortunately unless we can get at the black shrimp and cull everything else constantly we will always end up with a few blues etc. I tried for sometime to get just blacks but I think it must stem back from when the blacks were first being bred here and nearly always kept with chocolates. Even back in my 2013 colony that i got from Dean there were blacks and chocolates together. The blues didn't start turning up straightaway but even with culling I ended up with all 4 colours. i know many people have the same issue when trying to breed the blue diamonds- blue from black -they have to cull hard and constantly and truthfully I don't think any or at least only a few have a large colony of blue diamonds that breed 100% true.  You need to try and find a few blacks that don't show the deep blue - try putting them in a white container near a light source - you will see the blue/black colour more readily -if you are lucky enough to get a trio of true black without the blue base you might get started -good luck!
    • jayc
      That is less than 5%, so that should be safe. But maybe change it over every 3 days. Or every week, if you want to be safer.
    • Baccus
      Thank you for the imput Ineke. I too started with a mix of chocolate and black, nearly lost the lot thanks to an invasion of dragonfly caddis's and I ended up putting the few survivors into my 1000L pond. Months later I found chocolates in the pond and got interested in trying to get a good tank of them again. I swear my black cherry shrimp tank is determined to do my head in...….Almost every shrimp in there now is either blue (and practically all the shrimplets are blue) or a very definant blue/black. And the 4ft where I put all the dark chocolates are now producing lots of blacks. I know its an odd thing to complain about, getting too many blues, but come on I really loved the glossy all black cherry's. Oh and on a side note. In the dedicated Blue cherry tank I am getting deep blues, clear blues (diamonds?) and apparently for good measure blue rilli. And there is no way the shrimp can get between the tanks because no swapping around of plants has occurred and the tanks are a good 2-3m apart over a concrete floor.
    • nicpapa
      What parameter are you keep taiwans tibees?   What tds you get wiht salty shrimp mineral? And what gh? 1 have 3 same tanks 100liters, same setups. In one there are tibbe and taiwan,  i get them months ago, dont loose anyone. They breed but i dont have babies... I saw one baby  with  molting problem dead. In the other tanks there are crs cbs , they breed like crazy and i have lot o babies, the survation of babies is very good.   My water is 128 tds ppm , it raised to 140 because of the fans. Gh measure 5 (jbl) kh 0 ( api) ph 6.4 (api) Mineral salty shrimp gh + Substrate akadama       Also another tank, wiht hybrids, same water , same substrate, f1 taiwan x crs , taiwan x tangerine tigers babies grow fast.... Babies survive also is very good.   I think i try to lower the gh to 4 ...
    • pastu
      I would change 10 l a week with pure ro
×