Jump to content
NoGi

High pH?

Recommended Posts

NoGi

Ok, so I usually never check water parameters and only recently did it as I put up some lots for auction. My pH readings came back at 8.3 which sounds high? Having said that, there are no signs of stress on my tank inhabitants. The cherries are breeding like crazy and so are the endlers. My natives are doing fine too. I'm not using any mineral powders atm but do have a bunch of those mineral balls in the tank. Water is brisbane tap water straight into the tank.

Should I stick to old school chemical based test kits?

Control substance as part of the calibration:

IMG_3779.thumb.JPG.b6bd982048bd2ce2f9dde

In tank:

IMG_3780.thumb.JPG.4aee81d42f162685ef387

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
perplex

id say you reading are correct if you calibrated it correct, ive got the same ph tester and normal drop test kit and they both read the same reading, but if i was you, check with a drop test kit to confirm

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Disciple

I also have one of these PH testers.

I found it very frustrating to you because once you put it in the PH will take ages to settle. I found that when I put it in it might be 7.4 ph but then it will slowly go down. I am not sure if the ph is the amount you first put it in or the amount it settles at cause the instructions are in another language.

I plan to invest in some better well known equipment but as Perps has mentioned if you have calibrated it should be accurate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kizshrimp

Nogi, you want to calibrate at a couple of points along the pH scale or at least closer to what the test subject reading is. If you did a pH4.0 single-point calibration it's unlikely to still be accurate up at 8.3. 

I think everyone should have liquid pH tests! Cheap EC meters work but cheap pH meters are unreliable. If you're going to use one then get a decent one, like a HM. A bottle of Bromothymol Blue is a cheap way to verify pH meter readings even if you are using a good meter. Granted bromo blue won't work at 8.5 and so perhaps not relevant to NoGi here, but relevant to most of us most of the time. 

When I used to test water for customers at a large Melbourne LFS, we always used standard liquid pH kits. You spend more time calibrating digital meters than using them and the liquid test is done in 5 seconds. People get so hung up on accurate measurements but a .05-0.1pH difference is really irrelevant for aquarium purposes. What I'm saying is that a colour chart is normally accurate enough. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
NoGi

yeah, I also did the other end as well, just didn't take a photo. 8-) Had 2 x 250ml distilled water with 2 different callibration solutions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
perplex

I also have one of these PH testers.

I found it very frustrating to you because once you put it in the PH will take ages to settle. I found that when I put it in it might be 7.4 ph but then it will slowly go down. I am not sure if the ph is the amount you first put it in or the amount it settles at cause the instructions are in another language.

I plan to invest in some better well known equipment but as Perps has mentioned if you have calibrated it should be accurate.

take the reading once it settles down, i leave mine in water while i test the other WP 5-10 mins

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Disciple

take the reading once it settles down, i leave mine in water while i test the other WP 5-10 mins

Thanks mate

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      Sorry to hear that putting your shrimps with the betta didn't go well. My first betta couldn't have shrimps either as he would go after them. My current betta is ok though, he gets very close and watches them but nothing else? It would be best to have a filter if you can get one small enough, and if it is adjustable have it on low flow because it is a small tank, the shrimps are fine in flowing slow water,! Are you planning to keep them in this tank long-term or is this tank temporary until you decide where to go next with them? It is possible that some may die from injuries/stress/shock etc, but hopefully they will be ok. Simon
    • FancyBubbles
      On Saturday I wanted 8 ghost shrimp for my betta (he's in a 12 gallon). Mostly for extra cleaner, while also expecting the my betta trying to eat them. After one night, he ate out the eyeballs of 3 shrimp while the remaining 5 seemed to be attacked but not too damaging. Currently they're in a 2.5 gallon tank, no filter, gravel as substrate, 1 moss ball, 2 plastic plants, and a small castle for hiding. For food I put one algae wafer (in tank right now) and plan to put pieces of lettuce or cucumber after a couple of days. My question is, do ghost shrimp need filter? I currently have 5 of them in the 2.5 gallon tank. If they do I'm planning on to get a certain sponge filter that's safe for shrimp and small enough to not cause too much current.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Although losing the last killie must have been upsetting, it does now give you a clean working space for getting the parameters sorted and then you can look forward to getting some replacement killie - I love killie, even more than Betta but it is a bit too involved for me so I have avoided it so far! If your guppies are anything like mine (endlers), fin and tail marks will happen a lot and clear up almost as quickly, they are far too curious/nosey and go into every gap, under moss pads, squeeze behind the filters etc and so mine I have put down to them having just gone somewhere that they have got a small tear or caught on something - behind a filter or too close to a mesh pad etc? Simon
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Thanks for the heads up! I left the tank a month without shrimps even though they 'say' you can safely use  with shrimps immediately. I'm not all that happy with it in all honesty, I would use the JBL pro scape again in future as it just isn't going as well this time and although the plants are showing a bit of growth it all looks a bit drab and brown compared to Bertie (the betta) tank which is so lush and green and gets WOW from most visitors. The JBL required 50% water changes twice a week for the first 2 weeks but that extra work was well worth it for the better end result! Simon
    • Crabclaw
      Thx blue ridge for the advice, currently my problem is with the tds and hardness of the tank. The endler guppy no longer has a problem with her tail, and sadly the rocket killie has passed away. All of the other fish look fine, and I think the reason my killies have had it tough is due to the hardness being way too much for them. As there doesn’t seem to be a disease with them, my main focus is to get the hardness down before I lose my last 2 😢. 
×