Jump to content

my alternate approach to tank setup for my shrimp


Paul Minett

Recommended Posts

Holistic Shrimp Keeping

After trying for 6 months to get a stable and healthy tank and failing dismally, I was using shrimp soil and following all the recommendations to keep shrimp everything was testing perfect but the shrimp were dying steadily.  I then changed approach in the 6 months fighting with the tank and doing many hours of research I developed the approach I have been using now for the last 6 months with great success, it involves following a few basic principles that are a little different to the normal shrimp keepers mantra of shrimp soil, Ro (reverse osmosis) water and re mineralise with salty shrimp minerals and you won't have a problem well I was basically following this and had a lot of problems.

 

What I feel is more important and my experiment has proven you don't need to spend a lot of money on expensive soils minerals and ro units to keep any shrimp, to prove my experiment I chose to use expensive high end shrimp that supposedly require very specific water conditions and you absolutely must use all of the above mentioned things or they will die. They have not only survived but are breeding happily.

 

What I know to be of high importance the tank water parameters you choose must remain very stable, you must provide a complete ecosystem for your shrimp if anything is lacking the system crashes, you must provide healthy food preferably fresh or commercial food that doesn’t go sour.

 

Shrimp are not as delicate as people make out they are mostly resilient and robust if you can put them in a bag and post them across the country with the posties using the parcel as a football and they arrive happy and healthy it puts that myth to rest but having said that any ammonia or sudden changes in the tank will kill them very quickly which is why they have the delicate reputation.

 

The recommended parameters for the Taiwan Bee shrimp and the Crystal shrimp are as follows Ph 5.5-6.2, gh 6, kh 0, tds 150 ammonia and nitrite 0, minimal nitrate. My tank parameters are ph 6.8, gh 7-8, kh 3-4, tds 130 rest as required yes they are similar but to a shrimp keeper they are way outside what is recommended according to the rule book at 6.8 ph and kh 3 my shrimp should have died within a week or 2 and the babies shouldn’t have survived as they should be kept at a ph below 6. The reason they recommend the levels they do is because they are hostile to all microbial life in the tank essentially creating a sterile environment that they then add in only the things that are beneficial to shrimp growth and health the problem this poses for us in Australia is we don’t have ready access to these products so we can’t make a balanced environment and the shrimp die.

 

I have setup my tank with normal aquarium gravel and pool filter sand no shrimp specific substrate as I found it gives a false sense of stability if it’s there you rely on it to make the water stable not make it stable yourself. I use rain water from a tank I then re-mineralise using readily available aquarium minerals to a level I have chosen. The tank is heavily planted with mosses and plants to provide biofilm for them to graze on and cover when needed.

 

The rainwater starts at ph 5.6 gh 1 kh 0 tds 10 I then in a 20 litre bucket add about ¼ teaspoon of reef builder ½ teaspoon of equilibrium which gives a ph of 6.8, gh 5-6 these are the important parameters as this is the levels in the tank by matching them the water that comes out is the same as the water that is going back in this provides the essential stability that you need to keep your shrimp happy. I also add azoo mineral plus and bio plus as described as well as flourish excel and stability to provide essential bacteria for a healthy biosphere these are added each week with the water change. I have been using this approach now for 6 months with great success the reason it works when everyone will tell you it should fail is it provides the essential things for healthy shrimp:

  1. Stable water conditions with a ph below 7 this ensures any ammonia produced will be in the form of ammonium which is harmless to shrimp it also reduces the effects of nitrites
  2. A diverse bacterial colony that shrimp require for a healthy existence.
  3. A robust and healthy ecosystem that provide food and shelter for the shrimp
  4. Diverse foods for nutrition and health

I feed my shrimp every second day from the following list:

Shelled peas, dried shitake mushroom, organic rolled oats, chia seeds, and commercial shrimp foods like snowflake, max growth etc 

Edited by NoGi
Fixed up formatting
  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • HOF Member

I have been watching Paul for a few months now and have to say the quality of his shrimp and the number of babies has been outstanding . I think more people are starting to keep their TB's outside the "normal" parameters with some success. I also think it should be noted that the key to successful shrimp keeping is stability regardless of the parameters they are kept in . The biggest problem I can see with shrimp being kept at different parameters is when it comes to selling them on the purchaser needs to be aware of the different water parameters . Having said that at least here most people do advertise what water parameters the shrimp are kept in.

Thanks for sharing Paul. A six month trial seems to be quite a good time limit given that shrimp usually only live 2 years on average.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really interesting to see a different approach.

 

Again, as Ineke said, have been seeing Paul's shrimp for the last six months and he is doing something right.

 

Comes down to stability and balanced systems.

 

Even if shrimp came from different parameters, if they are acclimatised slowly they should adjust, as long as the system they are entering is stable too!

 

Thanks for this Paul!!  :thumbsu:

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

guys thanks for having a read, I  have moved some misch off too a couple of friends as well as one of my green project tb to tanks with lower ph etc with no issues and yes they were acclimatised slowly just in case, but I have also moved my tank ph around at times testing things with no ill effects to the shrimp have ranged it from 6.2 -7.4, when it comes time to sell a few buyers will be made aware of the parameters etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great write up Paul, very interesting read & after six months of keeping your TB in your WP, its obviously working. Not only are your TB living, their breeding.

 

Well done & thanks for sharing  :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

great read expesially for a newcomer to shrimp like me i used to keep tropheus and they where a pain but as soon as my 6ft was stable i had no bloat no deaths

and this is a perfect example of stability whitin a mini ecosystem.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was interested in how you remineralizer your water and had to google reef builder. So you use equilibrium to raise the gh and reefbuilder to raise kh. The reefbuilder site says it raises kh without raising ph, so how did your ph go from 5.6 to 6.8?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well this makes me feel better about not using shrimp soil :)

 

and all my parameters are the same :)

 

nice work, was a good read

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      We just had another 3-4 hot (for UK) days where the tank seems to have gone up to 26 and I think no shrimp died this time, though last time it got a bit higher the smaller shrimp died off so I guess they are more sensitive to the heat. I took the cover off the tank so that any heat can rise. I have just tested the parameters and they seem to be great, Ph 6.5, Gh 5-6, Kh 0-1, TDS 134 so aim to stop using unmineralised RO water from here onwards. If the remaing shrimp seem ok for another 2 weeks (as they have for the past 2 weeks) then I will likely get one more delivery of about 20 shrimps, 10 red wine, 5 panda and 5 blue bolts???? The shrimp that have survived so far are the blue bolts, all the pandas died off but they were the first added when the parameters were further off, and about half the blue bolts also died but they were very small  ones mainly and as mentioned, I think the heat did them in. So, it is looking quite hopeful at this point but I will make that final decision at the end of the month. If it is still going well and there are no more deaths I will order some more shrimps and look into getting some sort of fan cooling setup for future hot periods!  How is it all going your end beanbag? I think my Betta won't last very much longer, he is just sitting at the bottom and won't eat, lt can't be the water getting too hot as the shrimps are fine and the water likely only topped out at 28 degrees max. as with the other shrimp tank, as they are next to each other? There isn't anything visibly wrong with him other than not eating or swimming around as he used too. 
    • beanbag
      have a fan blow across the top of the tank, or get one of those U-shaped air conditioners that allow you to keep the window mostly closed
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I just watched the video again. With that tank I would take 1 of the sponges and put it in the left compartment (where he put the heater in the vid) and the heater can go in the middle section with the other sponge, so that would work well and be very simple and no extra costs or modification involved. The water level in the back drops either because the pump is set too fast (if it is adjustable) or mostlly just because the sponge directly behind the inlet slots is getting blocked. Somtimes just pressing the sponge insitu at the top will blow some of the gunk back into the tank, but you will probably need to take the sponge out weekly to clean it, though I imagine you would probably do weekly water change/maintenance anyway. The tank in the video is also quite good because the back is covered so that will help with reducing evaporation from the back working part, mine was open/uncovered at the back so evaporation was more of a problem. I freaked out when I saw the level drop in the back the first time, especially as I had a glass type heater in the back! If you only very rarely need a heater then you could just put that in the main part of the tank on those rare occasions to be safer? As you say, you have time to see if you even need a heater but I suspect you won't as indoors will be warmer than the outside temperature overnite, and I have seen vids on youtuube where some Australians keep Neocaridina shrimp outside all year with no heaters in huge tanks or even ponds, and I doubt there is anywhere in the world where the temperatures don't fluctuate between night and day so all creatures must be ok with that (within limits of coarse).  My problem last week was the same only opposite, overnite it dropped to about 13 degrees outside but inside overnite it rose to 28 because the sun had heated the roof etc all day, so I did lose a few shrimps then (but they are Caridina so not as adaptable or tough as cherry shrimp), only babys though strangely? Of coarse, it's your winter now, whereas it is our summer. Do you have A/C in the house for the summer, even Neocaridina won't survive much over 30? I only have a portable room one which requires a tube out of the window hense I couldn't leave it running overnight as it is a ground floor room!
    • DemonCat
      Thanks for the response and interest! I'm planning on ignoring everything about the filter media provided and will do my own thing. But yes, a simple idea to save shrimp is put the filter right next to the intake bit.. I hadn't thought about that and was already thinking about adding mesh... your idea is much better and straightforward.  In regards to heater, where we are in Australia it gets 40 degrees in summer, but we had -7 last week at night.. this morning was a much warmer -3! The heating in the office is a bit whack too... it seems to be boiling hot or freezing cold, so the heater is something i'll just play 'wait and see' with. I don't propose to stock for a while anyway so will have substantial time to monitor the temperature and see if/how/when a heater is needed.  I saw a short youtube video on the water level at the back.. I'm glad I watched it / you told me because if I went in without knowing I'd be freaking out the first time I noticed it. 
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I had a very similar tank to the petworx one and they are very clean to look at and easy to maintain, but obviously you are losing some volume/floor area for the shrimps to inhabit. You will probably need to work something out so the shrimp don't get through to the back area, especially babies (sponge behind the slots etc) - you may be able to just move part of the sponge to that compartment looking at this video:  I would only get a 25w heater, I learned my lesson when my 50w stuck on and cooked the shrimps in my 35L tank. 25w should be adequate as you have a much warmer climate, in fact do you really even need a heater? One drawback with this type of setup is that the level of water in the back can drop drastically when the sponge starts to get clogged, though this is mainly only a problem with the heater which may break in insuficient water, or the pump in really severe circumstances. You will need to clean the sponges at least weekly.  The level drop in the back can look quite alarming when you first see it happening.  The other makes may also have the same issues? I would have thought nearer $250 as it already has a light and pump, and if you don't need a heater? I tried the 'let the idea fade away', but it keeps returning???
×
×
  • Create New...