Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Sprae

EC and TDS

Recommended Posts

Sprae

Just got me 2 EC meters. I'm wondering if there's any optimal range for EC for CRS.

Current here's my tank parameters

GH = 6

pH = 6.2

TDS = 166

EC = 338us Meter A / 366us Meter B

Meter A is a combo meter and Meter B is a more sensitive EC only meter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

EC vs TDS confuses me......appreciate the diff in them (i.e. TDS & EC....salts/minerals...etc), but most meter's does a conversation...so if a formula exist between them, why is there a separate EC and TDS meter ? I think the Europeans use EC, and others use TDS ? ...just thinking out loud ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
doctr-dan

Hey sprae what Tds and EC meters did you get?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dean

the best EC range that i have found for all crystal and Tai shrimp is around 200.

i have tried higher and lower in many tanks but always get best results for breeding and color when the EC range is around 200.

also the SaltyShrimp bee shrimp mineral GH+ recommends the same reading of 200.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sprae
Hey sprae what Tds and EC meters did you get?

I got these ones;

Hanna 98129 - combo meter

http://www.hannainst.com/usa/prods2.cfm?id=030&ProdCode=HI%2098129

Hanna 98303 - Low range EC meter

http://hannainst.com/usa/prods2.cfm?id=003003&ProdCode=HI%2098303

BB, What's the EC in your most stable CRS tanks? I'm totally new to the EC too but I think mineral additives like SaltyShrimps talk about EC 200 +/- 50 µS. I think my tank maybe a bit high at 366µS.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sprae
the best EC range that i have found for all crystal and Tai shrimp is around 200.

i have tried higher and lower in many tanks but always get best results for breeding and color when the EC range is around 200.

also the SaltyShrimp bee shrimp mineral GH+ recommends the same reading of 200.

Thanks for that Dean. How can I lower EC slowly? Lower EC top ups or do small water change?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Dean

im really no help on nano tanks mate, they are to hard for me :)

i would say at a guess add less mineral with top ups and a small water change every other month would also get it down i guess.

sorry mate that's the best advice i can give on a nano tank....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sprae
im really no help on nano tanks mate' date=' they are to hard for me :)

i would say at a guess add less mineral with top ups and a small water change every other month would also get it down i guess.

sorry mate that's the best advice i can give on a nano tank....[/quote']

All good mate :)

I'm totally challenged with this nano. Maybe Bluebolts AKA "Nano King" can help? ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

Especially with Nano's, stability is EVERYTHING...whether it's TDS 150ppm or 200ppm or PH 5.5 or 6, the instability or sudden shock of different WP, affects the health of the shrimp more.

As a rule of (MY) thumb....I restrict water changes to 10% every 1/2 weeks. I use the Salty Shrimp mix, and adjust the TDS to 50% of the tanks ppm...i.e. 180ppm @ tank, RO/Salty Mix @ 90 ppm....as TDS generally increases naturally in a tank, so doing a 50% mix, seems to work well, to keeping my TDS under 200ppm. Have had no issues to date, and works 100% for me. Prior to Salty Mix, I had issues with water changes, and only did top ups !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sprae
Especially with Nano's' date=' stability is EVERYTHING...whether it's TDS 150ppm or 200ppm or PH 5.5 or 6, the instability or sudden shock of different WP, affects the health of the shrimp more.

As a rule of (MY) thumb....I restrict water changes to 10% every 1/2 weeks. I use the Salty Shrimp mix, and adjust the TDS to 50% of the tanks ppm...i.e. 180ppm @ tank, RO/Salty Mix @ 90 ppm....as TDS generally increases naturally in a tank, so doing a 50% mix, seems to work well, to keeping my TDS under 200ppm. Have had no issues to date, and works 100% for me. Prior to Salty Mix, I had issues with water changes, and only did top ups ![/quote']

Thank BB! Might do that when I clean my canister filter next week, with a 10% WC. I'll try and do the 50% change with EC instead of TDS though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Brado

sorry to hijack your thread sprae, does any1 know how i can raise my ec from 150 to 200ppm and lower my tds from 220 to 150ish....... it seems that if i lower my tds by using less minerals, im struggling to build ec, if that makes sense

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Trav80

Hi Brado,

I don't think it's possible to increase one and decrease the other. Your TDS is calculated from your EC. If you increase one you increase the other, so if you decrease one you decrease the other.

From the little reading I have done it seems that most Digital TDS testers use one of two formulas to calculate the TDS. The first which is generally used for aquaculture is EC x 0.5 = TDS and the second which is generally used for hydroponics is EC x 0.7 = TDS.

The cheaper TDS testers that you get from eBay etc are set to one of the two but you don't know which one as they very rarely state this in the details. Testing EC is more accurate as it is a direct measurement, you only have to worry about the accuracy of your Digital tester. The lower the range and the lower the +/-% the better.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
BlueBolts

Most TDS/Ec pens are calculated via Ec, then converted to TDS. The US uses a 0.5 conversion, and the Europeans uses a 0.7 conversion.

My TDS meter is US calibrated (0.5), so with my TDS @ 220ppm, the EC conversion is 220/0.5 = 440µS

If our target is the european conversion (as salty shrimp's recommendation @ 200µS), then my Ec is really is (220ppm/0.7) = 314µS.

But really TDS & EC is the same, just looking at it from a different perspective.….although I appreciate the electrical (EC) and solids (TDS) calculation, but still there is a mathematical conversation ratio between TDS & Ec.

So I think if we're talking about EC/TDS, we need to clarify if someone is using just a EC pen, or if they are using a TDS pen, then we need to ascertain what the pen's conversion ratio is, i.e. 0.5 or 0.7.

In my research and understanding....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Trav80

Cheers Marcus,

I had done a little reading on TDS vs EC but what you said made it a lot easier to understand. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sprae

Marcus, Does than mean I've been looking at my EC totally wrong? I've been trying to match my EC to the saltyshrimp recommendation of 200µS, where my US meter is telling it's 330µS. So in EU conversions it would be 237µS? If so, my parameters are closer to optimal than I've thought.

@Trav80 —I think regardless of conversions types, lowering one will lower the other.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Trav80

Sprae, that's what I was getting at. They are linked, you lower one and the other will drop, raise one and the other will rise. Marcus put it much better tho :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • Steensj2004
      Turned into a ghost town in here, lol.   PH is down to 5.9-6.0 for some reason. All I’ve changed is the Rock was removed and a few small almond leaves added. I know those can bring the PH down a hair. Any idea what might be causing the issue? I was planning on keeping Some Jade Neos, I don’t know that they would like 5.9-6.0 very well. Thoughts?   I’m struggling here and I don’t know wtf to do. I’d love is someone could help me out here.
    • Steensj2004
      Update for anyone interested.Rock was removed, Ph and TDS is down, over the last few days it’s crept down to around 190TDs after small water changes. Something that want happening with even larger changes before. PH seems to be down around 6.5. I hope it stays at that level, all inhabitants look to be doing well.
    • Cesar
      IME, the healthiest and highest quality has always buying directly from hobbyist, usually a small setup in their garage or fish room. Next was specialty store/importer, last is the local TFS, both often having stock that has been imported, transported and kept in less than ideal conditions... Buying directly from hobbyist has always produced the best results for me...
    • Steensj2004
      Did boil a few times, the water wasn’t completely clear when I stopped cleaning it. So they should be getting some tannins. I was able to remove all but one rock, I have one more piece to put in in its plAce today.   Right on. I’m originally from Ohio, and I’ve been scoping out Flip’s videos and website for a few weeks now. Looks like I’ll be ordering from either Flip or AquaHuna after I get this tank works out completely.   TDS is already down slightly after removing the rock and doing a small water change. I also took the opportunity to remove some plants I wasn’t a fan of and replace them. Indian Almond Leaves came in today too, but my BacterAE is delayed. Thanks Amazon.🙄🙄
    • Goshio22
      Its about 1 cm its definitely of breeding age.. i would be happy if its male, but my eyes is untrained when it comes to fully colored males.
×