Jump to content

GH - Ca:MG Ratio


BlueBolts
 Share

Recommended Posts

Sorry if I wasn't clear. This was a fresh batch of water made up in a 150l barrel. There was no suluwesi minirels in it. just fresh ro water (0ppm) and 14 scoops of the new tub of saltyshrimp gh/kh+ I just purchased. I found it strange that saltyshrimp gh/kh+ didn't have a good cal:mg ratio for shrimp (1.8:1)

Also I normaly aim for a gh of 8 with my cherries, have been breeding them for almost 3 years like this with no moulting issues. Crs/tbs I like lower around 5-6 tho

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 months later...

Great read! (Again!)

 

Was measuring my water and seems Squiggles observation of 5ppm of calcium to 1 degree of GH is where im at, as i have GH6 calcium 30ppm my TDS is about 140ppm.

 

Was wanting to measure the magnesium with a sera test kit I bought. Looks like it is in fact intended for marine. Will it still give an accurate reading using only 2ml of water to test on? It a 5 part test.. quite complex compared to most test kits.

 

Im wanting to make sure the water is right and just to know where im at so i can tinker and tweak a little if need be so any help greatly appreciated.

 

TIA :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hey shrimpstan i cant give you any advice but I'd love to know your findings as I wanted to test magnesium in my tanks too. so good luck and hope to hear some positive report from u :-)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 9 months later...

can i premix the ca:mg powders? say i buy 10kg of calcium sulphate and 2.5kg magnesium sulphate, can i dump them in to a bucket and mix them up good to have my 4:1 ratio? or is it better to keep and dose separately?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, shrimpaholich said:

can i premix the ca:mg powders? say i buy 10kg of calcium sulphate and 2.5kg magnesium sulphate, can i dump them in to a bucket and mix them up good to have my 4:1 ratio? or is it better to keep and dose separately?

Yes, you can premix the powders. But mix it really, really well.

10kg is a massive amount. Are you going commercial? Why do you need so much?

At those amounts you would need a cement mixer.

The mix needs to be kept very dry, and moisture will cause it to absorb water and turn the powder into a messy clump. Another disadvantage of making such a huge batch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well i bought them amounts lol. im going to package it up and maybe see if i can get a lfs to carry it and get rid of it with shrimps they sell. they most likely wont, but i can atleast have it and start an inventory of my own for when i start breeding shrimp. or maybe even sell on ebay. i dont like doing anything on a "small" scale. doing things in bulk saves $$$

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

New to keeping CRS, and I have been on a steep learning curve.

Tank originally set up using treated tap water, to cycle, then all water changes using RO aged with peat, (pH of supply 7.2 - 7.4), or rainwater (pH 6.9). Top offs using pure RO. I am using mineral balls, IAL, Alder cones. The substrate is ADA Amazonia.

I tested my tank, and got the following:

Ca = 40ppm

gH = 80ppm (or 4.47 dGH)

Using the formula, I get a negative value for Mg, so the ratio is: -8.4:1

I am expecting delivery of Salty Shrimp Bee Shrimp Mineral GH+ today, and I'll start using it to reconstitute the peat treated RO I use for water changes. What else should I be doing to bring the ration back into line?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi @nerowolfe,

SaltyShrimp has a Ca:Mg ratio of 3.79: 1. This is exactly in the sweet spot. By mixing the SaltyShrimp to the desired GH that you prefer to match your setup, it is a very safe option to just keep doing your water changes with the salty shrimp and the deficiency will equal out over time if it is not a heavily planted tank.

There are very successful breeders that do not worry about this ratio at all: @ineke I hope you do t mind me using you as an example?

If you have many plants in the tank, they use more Mg than shrimp as there is a Magnesium molecule central to every chlorophyll molecule in the plant cells. I suspect this is not your problem, instead, the mineral balls might be releasing too much Calcium. For your GH of 4.47, your Calcium is a bit too high. I suspect that plants might not be your problem. I would recommend taking out a few mineral balls as if you want your tank to stay stable at a GH of 4.47 that you currently have, your Ca should be 22.5ppm ( you measured 40ppm)  and Mg 5.79 approx giving a ratio of 3.88:1.

In your situation it is not advisable to correct this imbalance by adding MgSO4 ( remember that shrimp don't like change), also known as Epsom salts ( Magnesium Sulphate). The reason why this is not the correct course of action in this case as your Calcium is quite high already, thus by just adding Epsom salts, your GH will go up quite a bit and you will possibly end up losing a few shrimp with the GH change.

So, by mixing Salty Shrimp to your GH of 4.47 for your water changes and by removing a few mineral balls, your ratio will correct itself safely and naturally.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

@KeenShrimp has hit it on the head spot on.

 

 

@nerowolfe, what have you been using to remineralise the RO and R/W (rainwater) so far if you didn't have salty shrimp?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks @KeenShrimp I'll do that, and bring the ratio in line slowly. Oh, the tank is quite well planted, Anubias, Crypts, Java fern and Water wisteria. (no CO2 - low tech), so that may be having an effect on the magnesium levels, which I'll be monitoring closely from now on.

@jayc I used a little Continuum GH+, which does have calcium & magnesium, but I must admit i didn't use it all the time in the peat aged RO water, until now I was only testing gH and was focused on that and the pH, which I am slowly bringing down into the high 6s, using peat in the filter and the peat aged RO. Now I am aware of the importance of the Ca:Mg balance/ratio, I'll start getting it back into the right ratio.

The good news is that my new CRS have settled in nicely, active and feeding, and exploring the tank.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another question .. what test kit are people using to test for Ca? I ask because the freshwater one that came with my Nutrafin (Hagen) master kit, only has an accuracy of 20ppm increments. So a colour change after 2 drops of reagent can be anything from 21ppm to 40ppm! Kits for saltwater are calibrated for much higher ppm range, as suits seawater, and are quite specific as being for seawater only.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi nero you can usually double or triple etc your water volume and then divide the result to obtain a more accurate result with this style of testkit. Alternatively get the api which is what most of us use. (Including bluebolts the author of this thread)

Love n peace

Will

Sent from my SM-N920I using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I looked at the API, but again it has an accuracy of 20ppm, nothing in between.

I am thinking to test Mg instead. There is a good freshwater Mg test kit from JBL Germany, and it measures from 0 - 10mg/L (ppm), and >10. It then seems to me that you could then calculate a more accurate Ca level.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share


  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      There isn't much to report on this at the moment, I am 50/50 as to whether this is going to work or not long term. I have seen 2 dead shrimp since adding the new ones and counted about half of the new shrimp bought, that I saw yesterday! This is going to be a long term experiment I guess, the best I hope will happen at this point is that the remaining shrimp survive and reproduce and that new borns born in the tank should be more suited to the environment/water etc. There is an element of the acclimating didn't go as well/to plan as it should with my knowledge/experience, but I did the best I could, so that is what it is! Simon
    • Franks
      How is now the condition of pH?
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Summary from the old thread; I managed to destroy my wonderful Taiwan bee tank with a faulty heater that cooked them. I then set up the tank afresh May 2019 using shrimpking substrate, new plants and wood etc. The tank looked very drab from the start and several batches of new taiwan bee were added and died out instantly. Covid came along so I decided I would give up with the taiwan bee shrimp and get some fish instead about a year later (1 kilie and 12 mosquito rasbora). September 2020 I tried another batch of tawian bee but they fared no better and the tank was still very drab looking (and still is to this very day). I very much doubt it is the substrate but won't be using that again but have aquired a large bag of the old type of substrate I used before, but I really don't know what caused the problem, maybe there was some sort of bacterial infection or I accidently poisoned the shrimp, or there was something on the new plants/wood??? The parameters were always perfect and I have to just accept I will never know? At some later date I dumped some wild type red cherry culls into the tank as food for the killie but he didn't seem to eat them (they were clear/brown so maybe he didn't see them) and they seemed to settle into the tank and bred! Fast forward to a month ago and I decided that now the postal service is better than it had been early in the pandemic, I should maybe try some more taiwan bee as the cherry shrimp had been in there for a year or so and doing well, so I assume whatever the problem was had gone, although the tank is still not as healthy looking as the other tanks using the other substrate! I ordered 15 black shrimps 2 weeks ago and put those in the tank and they seemed to be surviving so earlier this week I order 20 red/blue shrimp and put those in the ttank yesterday. This morning I counted 18 shrimps (about half) so it looks as though it maybe going to work now, the tank is so densely planted that I would never expect to see ALL the live shrimp anyway! The killie fish died a few days ago so he isn't a threat anymore and I doubt the rasboras are either. I am now in the process of fishing out the wild type cherry shrimp as/when I see them! Here is the link to the full thread about the above but I decided to start a fresh thread from here on, https://skfaquatics.com/forum/forums/topic/14523-here-we-go-again/ I will keep this thread updated and get some photos at some stage, though the new shrimp are a bit small at the moment.  Simon
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I think I should start a new thread on this now as this is getting a bit long and it seems to be working now, and to keep it tidier and easy to find/follow! I will attach a link below once done! Simon https://skfaquatics.com/forum/forums/topic/15621-here-we-go-again-again/  
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Hopefully it will settle quite quickly now and it was just everything sorting itself out, and at least you caught it before it caused problems with the fish and shrimps. As you also say, it will take a bit of time for the neneficial bacteria to spread in the new sunstrate as well! The  packaging of the substrate should tell you if there is any routine you should carry out when first using it because of mineral build-up or ammonia, so if the packaging didn't say anything I think it is safe to assume it was not the substrate (Fluval stratum is volcanic soil), and other people may have just assumed it was the substrate without considering anything else if they had a similar episode to yours? Simon 
×
×
  • Create New...