Jump to content

Dean's (Ec) vs BlueBolts (TDS)


BlueBolts
 Share

Recommended Posts

Very helpful thread, just bought myself a TDS pen and worked out its conversion is 0.5, Getting readings on some new tanks that are cycling of 150PPM which i think is good. (plan on keeping crs/cbs)

Thanks again mate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

Can someone provide some example maths using these "conversion factors" sorry?

Because I'm trying to get my head around how it works as I use Bluelab's way and the way typically adopted in Aquaponics.

From EC to ppm500 (American) EC of 0.4*500= 200

From EC to ppm700 (Aus standard) EC @ 0.4*700= 280

So working backwards if I knew my TDS on an Australian meter I'd divide by divide by 700, or an american meter I'd divide by 500 both bringing me back to the 0.4 EC I know to be true...

So I cant help but wonder as I have trouble following the OP what maths everyone else is using? and whether perhaps as people are using different meters with different equations we should actually adopt the international standard of EC ratings like as being seen in the Hydro/Aquaponics industries? Might help make water parameter discussions a little easier as we'd know we're all on the same unit of measurement. Just my 2c

-edit-

This is driving me mad, Because as an example of converting days to hours the conversion factor is "24". 2days*24 = 48 (Hours)

But if you were to try to get from say an american TDS of 200 (that's 200 @500ppm) then multiplying by 0.5 would get you to 100, when the EC rating is actually 0.4 and would be attained with a conversion factor of 0.002 (200* 0.002 = 0.4)

I feel like I'm missing something obvious here :/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think it's possible dude, you'd have to get all the manufacturers of TDS pens to work off a standard conversion factor. The only one that is standard measuring device is an EC pen as they all use the same measuring unit without conversion. The thing with TDS pens is it all depends on what chemical they are calibrated with, whether it's NaCl or KCl, they both have a different conversion factor from EC. :encouragement:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry but Bluelab truncheons don't even need calibration, which is what I use. Joys of a device that displays CF, EC, ppm500, ppm700 and needs no calibration to use...

I'm just trying to figure out this headache that others have to go through, which it sounds like anyone with a TDS pen should be doing. Otherwise when you all display your ppm ratings of your water parameters without knowing how it's being calculated then it's not that useful. It would be like having multiple ph scales in use but not being able to directly compare them.

If all probes read at EC, then convert to ppm displays then it makes complete sense to me for everyone to calculate their EC ratings as it's a scale we would all be able to compare against. Because otherwise if what you say is true and that it's not possible then everyone should throw away their tds pens and start using EC as it's again sounding like the only unit with some sense to it.

as an example if I was to start measuring shrimp in inches at least it's known to my buyer what inches can convert into. But buying shrimp with water parameters of a T[email protected] means little if we cant convert it to either EC (accepted unwavering standard) or to each others TDS ratings.

-edit-

oh and squiggles I edited my first post not knowing you had responded sorry, but please check the maths for me in my previous post.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you are over complicating it, the simple way for this to be solved is for the buyer to test the water their new shrimp come in with their own TDS pen & also slow acclimation is a definite necessity. I completely agree that we should probably use EC as a standard parameter but EC pens are not as freely available & definitely not as cheap as a TDS pen. Also, not everyone can afford a $100-$200 piece of equipment when a cheap $15 TDS pen will do the job. As with everything, what works for you may not work for someone else, I have crystal shrimp living in TDS values ranging from 150ppm to around 300ppm. I would not try the higher values with Taiwan Bees or Tigers but if people are buying $200-$500 shrimp then they will probably be able to afford a more adequate pen. No TDS pen or EC pen should ever need calibration but calibration is mainly used to initially set these instruments.

I can understand your confusion trying to work this out, having a single parameter that would make it a bit easier but I fear you will be trying to change what already works for a great majority of shrimp keepers around the world. :encouragement:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 8 months later...

Well, very interesting and usefull topic.

At the early times of my hobby, I have serious issues with PPM metering and targeting. Changing my pens to EC meters helped me very much to be succesful breeding taiwan bees.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Iv been on here for about a year and a half and im only reading this for the first time lol very informative once again Marcus well done

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      Sorry to hear that! I hope you are getting enough baby shrimps to keep the colony going at a reasonable size?  
    • beanbag
      the short antenna ones eventually die
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Are you getting and unusual shrimp deaths, or is it just the shorter antenna?
    • beanbag
      I don't know if bacteria is the cause.  It seems to be an uncommonly diagnosed problem because most shrimp articles only talk about bacteria infection as "a few shrimp die every day / week"  What can I say, a standard dose of minocycline and erythromycin didn't work to stop it, so not sure if oxytetracycline will work.
    • jayc
      Ah yes. That was the injectable form of oxytetracycline. Each mL of the injectable form contains: 100 mg oxytetracycline HCl, 5.75% w/v magnesium chloride , 6 H2O, 17% v/v water for injection, 1.3% w/v sodium formaldehyde Sulfoxylate as a preservative and q.s. with propylene glycol. Basically, it has additional compositions in it. 1000mg might have been the dose recommended for the injectable oxytetracycline, but if you have the powder form then follow the dosing rates as recommended on your bottle. Hope that clears it up a bit.     As for doxycycline and it's use to treat short antenna ... I cannot comment on whether it will be more effective than oxytetracycline or not. But if you do use it, only try one at a time. Is bacteria even been proven to be the cause of "short antenna disease"?
×
×
  • Create New...