Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
ineke

Under gravel filters

Recommended Posts

ineke

Hi another question . Are under gravel filters alright with shrimp? If so what is the deepest the substrate can be? I wanted to use quite deep river sand in some places. I will be using a sponge filter as well for the babies.

cheers

ineke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Squiggle

In my experience with gravel filters, they aren't as effective with sand as you can't get the flow through the sand as well as gravel, they also work a lot better if you put a powerhead/pump on top of the uplift tube. Also, from my understanding, under gravel filters are good for shrimp cause the bacteria they feed on grows in the gravel so the whole base of the tank is a big dinner plate :encouragement:

I have a UG with a powerhead in my LumiQ & the shrimp are doing great, I'm using Fluval Stratum, which is porous so it buffes the tank & has a greater surface area for more effective filtration & larger bacterial culture(more food)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
northboy

Sand is to small to allow water flow past it efficiently, us a 3mm gravel and it works OK up about 2cm deep, but you have to use a gravel cleaner to keep the gravel from compacting and when it compacts there is no flow there for no filtering, this also leads to anaerobic bacteria build up, that is bad.

In all I like UG filters if they are maintained, how ever some plants don't like the UGs much, 6 of one half a dozen of another. Your gravel is your filter media.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke
In my experience with gravel filters' date=' they aren't as effective with sand as you can't get the flow through the sand as well as gravel, they also work a lot better if you put a powerhead/pump on top of the uplift tube. Also, from my understanding, under gravel filters are good for shrimp cause the bacteria they feed on grows in the gravel so the whole base of the tank is a big dinner plate :encouragement:

I have a UG with a powerhead in my LumiQ & the shrimp are doing great, I'm using Fluval Stratum, which is porous so it buffes the tank & has a greater surface area for more effective filtration & larger bacterial culture(more food)[/quote']

Thanks Squiggle I've always used them with my fish and been very happy with them so if its good for the shrimp I'll use that in the new setup

cheers

Ineke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke
Sand is to small to allow water flow past it efficiently' date=' us a 3mm gravel and it works OK up about 2cm deep, but you have to use a gravel cleaner to keep the gravel from compacting and when it compacts there is no flow there for no filtering, this also leads to anaerobic bacteria build up, that is bad.

In all I like UG filters if they are maintained, how ever some plants don't like the UGs much, 6 of one half a dozen of another. Your gravel is your filter media.

Bob[/quote']

Thanks Bob,

I like the UG filters with fish and as the tank I am setting up has one thought I would try it with the shrimp. I want to have a couple of deep sand areas for contouring and wonder what the deepest I can go . 2 cm over most of the tank will be good but I'll try acouple of hills and just make sure I clean them thoroughly The filter base covers the whole of the tank so if I angle the higher areas so there are not huge areas of deep gravel would that work?

Cheers

Ineke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke

meant to put river gravel not sand

I just read back through my original question and I have the coarser river gravel not sand. Sorry for the wrong wording. So looks like it will be all good just worried about the depth.

Cheers

Ineke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • Steensj2004
      I am. I’ve looked at a few vendors. I ha w a buddy ordering from Aqua Huna in a few weeks, but I honestly don’t know if them import or tank breed. I know Flip tank breeds, he’s from my home state. I don’t know, but I have time to decide. I’m in no hurry.  Does the vendor you’re talking about sell only reds, or does he have other colors?
    • Blue Ridge
      I will consider it. I have an agreement with my wife that $100 a month each is our hobby allowance, and am behind on that by the tune of 6 months already at the moment. Patreon's and forum subscriptions count towards that so it may be a bit unless I sell some stuff (which is likely). I've owned a message board and been a moderator on several and understand server costs and the work that goes into these endeavors and particularly the difficulty of breaking even now that so many folks just use Reddit, FB, Instagram and so forth. It's a tough balance to give member perks to paid subscribers and not leave the nonpaying majority feeling like they can't enjoy the full forum. I admin'ed a corn snake forum where the owner decided to not allow nonpaying people have the ability to edit posts, and it resulted in a ton of members not sticking around -and the downfall of it being a popular place to post. I think to this day the most popular thread on that site is titled, "Show us you pets," and the site owner would not let me fix the typo. (insert roll eyes emoji) All of this to say that I understand restricting some privileges for non-paying folks, as well as the potential for free members not sticking around that it can have. For the time being, I will mark forums messages as spam to keep my phone from alerting me all day and hopefully kick a few bucks a month your way later on. I love international forums regarding our hobbies and the different approaches that seem to be regional and think these can enrich us all! Cheers, and thanks for the explanation. 
    • jayc
      I believe those settings are only enabled for paid subscribers.  Consider supporting the forum,  your knowledge and experience will be most welcome here.    Just checking that you are clicking the "Notification Settings" as per the image below right?
    • Blue Ridge
      I was wanting to change my settings so that I do not get an email alert every time there's a reply or reaction to a post. Is this something that is disabled for new members?
    • Blue Ridge
      You're in the US, no? There's a guy on another forum who breeds nice CRS and sells them for $1 each +actual shipping. Home bred, hardy and beautiful shrimp with lots of positive feedback. Not sure of rules regarding crossposting, so will hold off for now, but if rules allow I'll post a link. Or PM me when you are ready. He's had this colony for years, so no need to rush. I only mention this because most vendors sell imports for between $5-10 each.
×