Jump to content

Cull from a red rili line


Kelly
 Share

Recommended Posts

Ok I bought a cull from a guy that breeds red rili. I didn’t want to buy top quality shrimp yet because I’m new to shrimp hobby and bound to and have (bought a internal filter tank my 1st mistake) make mistakes. I have been researching the subject but as you all know there’s a lot of information out there. Now I think the females I have has  recessive rili gene in them  but they are all red bodies and don’t show rili markings at all. I am guessing they fire reds....but unsure. The males I think are low grade rili. Red head and red tail somewhat clear middle. What’s my chances of getting a good rili out of this batch? Do they get their looks more from their mothers or dads? If they have shrimplets I plan to cull them by putting unwanted ones down stairs in community tank. When I feel ready to buy a good batch of rili should I just put all  these ones down stairs and  focus on the good quality shrimp or do it the hard way  and breed all and see what I end up with? 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, Kelly said:

Now I think the females I have has  recessive rili gene in them  but they are all red bodies and don’t show rili markings at all. I am guessing they fire reds....but unsure.

It's difficult to tell. You should ask the person you bought them from what he thinks it is.

I wouldn't call them Fire Reds, as that will confuse the situation. Rillis do not revert to Fire Reds.  And an almost red Rillis does not make it a Fire Red.

If the guys says these are Rillis, than what you have are just Rillis, albeit low quality Rillis.

 

1 hour ago, Kelly said:

When I feel ready to buy a good batch of rili should I just put all  these ones down stairs and  focus on the good quality shrimp or do it the hard way  and breed all and see what I end up with? 

Yes, separate them. Breeding these current low quality Rillis with a better quality Rillis will just produce poorer quality overall. 

Say you buy new A grade shrimp and breed them with C grade shrimp. You end up with shrimp between B and C grade, never A grade.

Offspring will get traits from both parents. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I mean, the shrimp you have there is already a beautiful shrimp. If you want to turn that line into a rili line, using the low grade rili males, it'll take a few generations to get some nice ones popping out, and at that stage you'll probably want to bring in someone else's rili line anyway to increase genetic variation. It's up to you whether you want to go for the more interesting alternative of breeding your own line, or just buying one. Just know you're not likely to get anything special from the first batch.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The shrimp in the picture looks more like my bloody mary than a fire red.That is a female with eggs inside........ lovely solid colour!

I wouldn't get too bogged down with what to do in the future at this stage, wait and see how it goes with the current batch, removing any poor quality as you plan. There is no real way of knowing what shrimp carries what genes when you start out as you are?

Simon

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know they aren’t cherry...they too red and I don’t think they are Bloody Mary their flesh aren’t red and I believe Bloody Mary has  red shell and flesh. They do have red legs though...

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know I have a  berried  shrimp... one came that way but I just noticed another molted..... so maybe more on the way....I still want to move them to 8 gallon eventually...but I’m unsure when the little shrimplets be born.....

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Kelly said:

I know they aren’t cherry

Why would you say that? It's certainly not a Rilli. Looks more like a Red Cherry to me.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Definitely looks like a high grade cherry to me. And as with Simon, I'm leaning towards Bloody Mary. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I meant low graded cherry. They too red in colour. They probably have  low grade cherry in their background and I’m sure if I don’t cull it will eventually show that. The breeder is working with red rili line. This is a cull from that line. 

I will put them in the 8 gallon by this weekend I think. I want to make sure everything ok 1st.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • jayc
      Great idea! Please document your journey here. I have no experience with marine shrimps, so cannot help you. But what you have listed above seems like a sound plan to get started.   
    • sdlTBfanUK
      That sounds like a fun project and look forward to hearing how it goes!  Hopefully someone will have some useful advice/tips etc? 
    • Crabby
      I have an idea. And considering I’m terrible at being concise, I’m sure it’s gonna take me a while to explain it.   Essentially, I want to do a nano marine rockpool tank, with just crustaceans and molluscs (and perhaps a seastar or two). And I really don’t know how plausible it is, but I’m pretty intent on finding out. I don’t know if anyone here has any experience with marine shrimp, but I figured I may as well see if any of the Aussies here are familiar with the shrimp I want to keep. So this species of shrimp is actually the species that got me into the hobby! I found them on a camping trip, and they were just so active and engaging, and I just fell in love. Then I went home, did a bunch of research, and got an aquarium. They’re part of the reason why I’m so interested in shrimp. Now I’m on holidays again (in a different place in Vic) and they’re everywhere in the tide pools. Millions. The species is ‘palaemon serenus’, the red-handed shrimp, and they grow to about 6cm for big females (which I discovered last night) and I think 3-4 for males. Just from observation. They live primarily in colonies of 10-30 under rocks during the day, venturing out when they feel safe, and going everywhere once it gets dark. They’re omnivorous, eating pretty much everything they can get their little claws on (including my fingers and toes). They look rather like freshwater macrobrachium, to be honest. I’ve had a look and it’s legal to collect from this location. There aren’t limits on anything I want to collect. So, I’m thinking I’d do a 20 litre tank for the meantime (until I can get some awesome 30ish litre low-boy tank). I’ve got one at home that could be set up as soon as I’m back. If I take home a big rock and sand, then I should have beneficial bacteria sorted, as well as a food source. The rock would have plants and a bit of algae and all the other good stuff you find on the rocks they like. Other than using salt for water changes, I’d run the tank like a freshwater tank - sponge filter for filtration, freshwater light, no heater, fortnightly or monthly water changes. I’d love to add a couple little fish if I can catch them, but I have no idea how to identify whether they’ll grow or not. Same deal with the majority of crabs (although I have ID’d a few species that would work). And unfortunately no nudibranch either… although I found the CUTEST little one last night. They’re apparently super specialist in terms of diet, and I don’t have the time to observe one for hours to see what it eats, ID it, work out how to cultivate it, and all that. So, that’s the plan. I would love any advice, recommendations, or criticisms you have. I understand there’s a good chance this could be too ambitious, and the well-being of the animals is number 1 priority, so if it sounds like it’s a bad idea then I’ll just scrap it. But I’m pretty keen on finding out a way to make this work.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I have had fungus each time I set up a new tank, but it has always just disappered on its own after a month or two, and has been varied in appearance each time!
    • Dirk De Bakker
      Had a go searching / feeling throught the substrate for the tabs but no luck.  They might have dissolved or become soggy so I can't  feel them.  I have a bucket sample of substrate brewing at the moment for a 24 hour test and its already steadily rising the TDS.   Looks like a just wait and see...... Thanks for all the help as ususal it is appreciated.  Dirk       
×
×
  • Create New...