Jump to content

Just got my test results back


DEL 707
 Share

Recommended Posts

Could use some help.

I used to have a small fish/shrimp setup.

1 day I notice the water is suddenly cloudy so I do a massive water change, situation didn't improve so I ended up doing more water changes over the following days. At 1 point I ended up doing a water change at 4 in the morning because I noticed how bad things looked when I got up for a glass of water. Fish were gasping and shrimp were trying to escape.
The next day I threw the towel in, saved all the fish/shrimp I could and gave them to the local fish shop. Then I scraped the tank. It's still sitting empty.
This all happened around the beginning of March.

This all coincided with me changing my RO water supplier, my usual place shut down and so I had to go elsewhere.

Wanting to get to the bottom of things I ordered a water test kit from ATI labs.
I filled up the water vials and was about to post them off to the labs when the pandemic started, I couldn't get to the post office and just plan forgot about it.

Anyway, I finally posted off the water samples and got my results back.

The ask to send tank water and RO water, but both of my vials contain just RO water. So there's 2 sets of tests, but both should be the same.
Can anyone look through these results and see if there's anything wrong with the water?

Test 1 "Tank Water"

ebjd1uY.jpg
BHAaSzf.jpg
wj8Uyju.jpg

Test 2 "RO Water"

MfwJBgM.jpg
ESSntc0.jpg
SgumMLI.jpg

 
Edited by DEL 707
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What I see out of norm for your tank water is .... that it is practically RO water.

Which leads to me asking .... what are you using to remineralise the RO water you use?

Living creatures cannot live in pure RO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Both samples I sent off were RO water.

I was using Salty Shrimp GH/KH+ to reminerlise my RO water.

Since I was using a new supplier, I wanted to check to see if there was anything wrong with the water I bought.

I'm just trying to do a little detective work to see what went wrong with my tank. I don't have any of the original tank water, it's been sitting empty for months.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, DEL 707 said:

Both samples I sent off were RO water.

I see. That makes sense then. The "Tank 1Tank water" title threw me off.

Test water 2 is certainly better. 

Whoever you bought Test water 1 from needs to change their RO filters as it is letting a lot more minerals through. But it's certainly a lot less than tapwater. 

Cloudy water can be caused by many other factors, so I wouldn't say the source problem is the RO water specifically.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Firstly, sorry to hear about you having a problem after having such a great start! It is unlikely we will get to the bottom of that problem at this stage as the tank was shut down months ago?

What sort of 'cloudy', can you remember? Greenish is usually algae and white/milky is usually bacteria bloom? I have had the white milky cloudiness a couple of times in newly set up tanks and that cleared in a day or 2 without any input from me, but I didn't have anything except snails in the tanks at that time. The PH rising and dropping as mentioned in the other post may have caused havoc with the cycle and if it was bacteria bloom, the bacteria would have drained the water of oxygen so that the fish would be gasping (at a guess)? Did you test the water parameters at that point?

Did anything die with the cloudy water?

Are you planning to have another try? Or has this experience put you off completely?

Simon

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The tank went white/milky.

The tank had 10 tetras, 3 amano shrimp, some nerite snails and an army of red cherry shrimp. They were breeding like crazy.

When things went cloudy, I did start losing some cherry shrimp. I got them out and started to do water changes. But as the days went on, I lost more and more. It was quite a gut punch when I had to throw in the towel to save what I could.

It has put me off keeping fish. A friend is coming to collect the tank off me in a few weeks when he's down my way.

I used to live in London, kept quite a few different tanks over the years, with no tap water and no problems. Even had a few marine tanks. Switched over to RO for my 5ft reef tank.

Moved out into Kent and tried a 3ft planted tank, nothing but algae problems, which put me off for a few years.
Thought I'd have another go with a smaller tank and RO water to make sure everything was perfect.
I was hoping the problem was the RO water I bought, but it seems like it's somethings I did.
I just wish I knew where I went wrong.

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you ever try again, we would be happy to walk you through the process with our opinions and experiences.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry to hear you have given up but I certainly understand as I have been there a few times myself. It is such a shame as it was going so well up to that point for months! Very upsetting after you had spent so much time and effort getting everything where it should be.

I suspect you had a bacteria bloom by the sound of it but there is no way of knowing why or if at this stage.

As JayC says above, 'should' you decide to have another go at some later date we will be pleased to help as much as we can!

Simon

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Posts

    • alkemist
      I believe the rocks are banded jasper. Previously when I first set up the tank, I was worried about the rocks. I have done previous testing with them before. I don't have hydrochloric acid but I've done the vinegar and water soak test. I had a test rock in RODI for a month with no change in GH and KH. There were no reactions to vinegar. The rock was marketed for aquatic use but it doesn't always mean it's correct. Sometimes I do question it though. I previously moved some rocks higher out of the substrate to help fix the scape and there was a dividing line in the color of the rock. The portion originally above the substrate had darkened and the part that was previously buried in the substrate stayed it's original color. The only other thing that comes to mind is that maybe I have been overmixing my re-mineralized water. I could have sworn that when I originally made the mix to 180 TDS in 1 gallon of water, it was 6 GH and 4 KH. I did some mix testing yesterday and at 160 TDS, it was 6 GH and 3/4 KH. I did a 10% water change and replaced it with straight RODI water. It brought the KH down to 5/6 but GH also down to 5. I will do another 10% water change next week and probably add in mostly RODI and a little re-mineralized to keep calcium and magnesium content in the water for the shrimp.   I think the KH rise could have been part of the issue. If I recall, I saw a shrimp laying around and twitching, like I've seen in a failed molt. The higher KH had totally skipped my mind and I went straight to thinking it was a food issue due to the ton of shrimp in the tank and light supplemental feeding. Though maybe it can be a contribution to possibly shortening their lifespan.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      The copepods are only really a problem as they compete with the shrimp for food, and look unsightly, but are actually otherwise a good thing and indicate the tank is good! As mentioned by JayC, I had success using fish, they wiped out the infestation in a couple of days. Every environment will find its 'maximum occcupancy' level based on how many it can sustain, and this can be increased with additional food but thats a difficult balancing act to get right. If the filter is clearing some of the copepods, then it will almost certainly also be clearing some of the new born shrimp (hense the decline) as they are similar sizes, rarely do you see newly born shrimp as they are soooo small. I would do as JayC recommends and change the substrate, but would also add some nano fish and plants as it is quite a big tank? Most substrates have some sort of run-in period so this may mean putting the shrimps back in the old tank for now? Shrimp don't need hiding places, unless there is something that predates on them. If you want to try the fish route then sufficient plants/cover/hideouts would be recommended to maximise the survival rates of the shrimps. If you do use soil substrate with plants you don't need additional plant fertilizer as the soil and shrimp waste will cover that.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      The KH is to high for sure and should be reduced, as JayC recommends. Best way to check the rocks is to put them (individually) into a container with pure RO water (which should be zero on all reading) and test the water after a week to see if it has stayed the same parameters. Water changes, slowly added is the only route I know of to reduce the KH! Other than that, everything you are doing etc seems to be well informed! Are you convinced there really is any real problem (other than high KH) as shrimp only live 12-18 months anyway so it could just be natural life span with the high KH also contributing?
    • jayc
      Copepods themselves don't pose much of a threat to shrimps. Apart from out competing the shrimp for food. They would be eating the same foods as adult and baby shrimps.  Copepods can be unsightly in a tank, especially in plague proportions. Unfortunately anything that will kill them will also kill shrimps. The only method that I have had success with is to catch all the shrimp and start a new tank. Do not reuse the gravel, plants or filters. Nothing from the old tank must move to the new tank. The shrimps are caught and placed in a temporary tank/hospital tank, for a few days while the new tank is set up, and then caught again to be placed in a new tank.  It's pain for sure. Oh, another method that works is to add fish! As long as the fish are shrimp friendly of course.  High Nitrates can be an issue for shrimps and shrimplets. So I would put this high on the list to remedy. High Nitrates is linked to detritus. See below.  Heavy amounts of detritus is one of the causes of Nitrates. Detritus that has sunk deep into the gravel, and stuck on filter media can be the causes of Nitrates increasing. When was the last time you gravel vac'd? Or the last time you squeezed out your filter sponges and cleaned the filter media? Of course, cleaning media should be done in the old tank water. Never clean filter media in chlorinated tap water. Lots of fast growing plants also help control Nitrates.  Do you still have the old 40 tank? I would use that as a temp holding tank and move all your shrimp across while working on the 180 tank.  Sand, even if it's black blasting sand, can get compacted and trap detritus. I would look at replacing it with substrate that has a similar shape to ADA Amazonia. That round shape has a reason. It allows more water flow between and as a result is "lighter" and easier to clean with a gravel vac. Plant substrates also have other benefits like holding more nutrients for plants, easier to plant with and has pH buffering abilities.  Yes, that is an increase in costs, but I have never thrown out old ADA substrate. I use it new in my Caridina tanks. And when the substrate has lost it's nutrients and buffering capabilities, I wash and re-use it in my Neocaridina tanks.    Hopefully this has given you some ideas.   
    • jayc
      KH creeping up can only be from fertilisers that are added, or from rocks. As beneficial bacteria break down ammonia/nitrogen, the by product is slightly acidic water. This is a very simplified explanation. But the point is aquarium water will become acidic as the bacteria breakdown nitrogen. It is this acidic water that causes some rocks to increase KH or carbonates. What rocks do you have in the tank?
×
×
  • Create New...