Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Warwick

How to maintain low TDS with water changes

Recommended Posts

Warwick

Hi

Im fairly new to shrimp keeping and have done a lot of reading but im stuck on how to maintain a low TDS in my shrimp tank

I hope someone can help me.

Heres my problem

I want a TDS of 150 in my aquarium and over time i let it creep up to 170. So if I do a 25% wc with DI remineralised to 150 then it will only bring it down to 165. Then if i do another the next day (which i wouldnt but in theory) it would come down to 161.25

So my understanding is that unless i do a 51% water change or more i can never lower it back to 150.

I know i could just add pure DI but obviously this would change the parameters.

So how do people do it. I appreciate any help

 

Edited by Warwick
Spelling

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

TDS creeping up from 150 to 170 in short span of time, say 1 day to 3 days, is usually due to the materials you have in the tank. It can be difficult to find. How fast are you finding TDS go from 150 to 170?

A simple test you can do is use several plastic cups and add the items in your tank along with water. Measure the TDS of the water before adding it in the cup. Start measuring TDS after 1, 2, 3, 4 days to see what is raising your TDS.

Usual suspects are substrate/gravel; filter noodles (glass or ceramic); rocks; ornaments.

TDS does rise naturally and slowly. The shrimp can handle the slow rise. But changing your parameters in a rush, like daily water changes because you are chasing an ideal TDS, is more detrimental to the shrimp than the TDS itself. So try to find the cause of the TDS rising and avoid daily water changes. On hot summers, water can evaporate faster, causing TDS to rise due to the concentration of dissolved solids in the tank which now has less water. So top up evaporated water with pure RO to bring TDS back inline to what it should be.

TDS also rises as waste is produced from the shrimp and left over food. So gravel vac occasionally can help and removing uneaten food is also a good idea. Feed less maybe.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Warwick

It takes about 2 weeks to go from 150 to 170 but that doesnt matter in reference to my question.

Lets say it hypothetically it takes a month or even 2 to get to 170.

Lets also say hypothetically in that time i had 0 evaporation (i do have a lid so it is fairly minimal anyway)

How can i bring it back to 150 without doing more than 50% water change if the water im using is remineralised to 150 so that the parameters stay the same?

In regards to pure water top offs i would have to do a 10% change to bring it from 170 to 153 which would change my gh from 5 to 4.5 and my kh from 2 to 1.8

So how can it be done?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
beanbag

As you initially calculated, it can't be done unless you know exactly what is the chemical that is causing the TDS rise and remove it selectively.  For example, if you have 20 extra ppm of sodium chloride, then sorry, you can't remove it except for dilution.  But if the extra is something like nitrates, there are resins or plants that can remove it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Warwick

Ok but if TDS will inevitability rise, and from what i see most people do weekly 25% water changes, that means everyone will get to the point where they must either do more than 50% change or change their parameters.

I thought maybe i do the 10% pure change and then slowly build my gh and kh back up. Which of course means the same thing in reverse - i will never get my gh and kh back to 5 and 2!

What do you guys do?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
beanbag

You have to accept that your tank TDS will always be higher than the TDS of your input water.  Using the power of math, you can calculate if your tank rises x ppm per week, and you do y% water change every week, the equilibrium ppm will be z.

I mix up my input water to have barely lower GH than what I actually want, in order to make up for evaporation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
1 hour ago, Warwick said:

if TDS will inevitability rise, and from what i see most people do weekly 25% water changes, that means everyone will get to the point where they must either do more than 50% change or change their parameters.

Yep, you have found the "TDS inevitably rises" problem. A tank is a closed eco system. Waste inevitably collects and raises waste (organic or inorganic) that 10-20% water changes will never get rid of. Evaporation, food, substrate, rocks, plants, etc all contribute to the change in TDS. As the tank ages, you will never be able to get it back to ideal TDS level, because those minerals are used up, either by the beneficial bacteria, shrimps or plants, or dissolved solids are added from some other source.

A complete water (99%) water change is required to reset your water parameters. This is a good idea to perform a drastic water change half yearly. This reset the levels of Calcium, Magnesium, and removes any build up of unwanted minerals. 

I do this every 6 months +/-.  I have found this to be the ideal length of time before minerals in a closed ecosystem like a tank get completely depleted leading to moulting issues with shrimps. This big water change is when I gravel vac the substrate as well as squeeze out filter media. 

 

BTW: 150 - 170 TDS rise in 2 weeks is normal. Time for a water change.

 

Edited by jayc
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sdlTBfanUK

JayC seems to have this covered but just thought I would join in.

I did my weekly maintenance yesterday (only do 8% each week) and took out 2 litres at TDS of 163 and as I like to aim for 160 I added new water of 128, this took the tank down to 161. So I always make the new water lower tds to compensate for any slight increase - increase in my case is due to evaporation mainly.

As regards the altering of the GH and KH, if you are using the kits with drops they only register in whole units which means your never getting an exact reading anyway to a decimal point. I use double the water in the test tube for GH so each drop added is then half a GH. All I am trying to say here is that your readings may not change for GH/KH or they might. ie if KH is really 2 and then goes down to 1.8, that will most likely only record as KH1? Hope this makes sense, but basically over all you aren't talking about much of a change so I would just concentrate on the TDS as that is a more accurate test anyway and easier to alter slowly and measurably!

Simon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Posts

    • jayc
      Ahhh ... the age old question of how to trigger your shrimp to breed. We will have to assume you have at least 1 male. What are you feeding them? Feed frozen bloodworms twice a week. The additional protein will give them more energy. Add more Indian Almond Leaves (aka Cattapa leaves) to the tank to promote more tannins and biofilm. Try raising temps to 23C or 74F. A 10% water change might help the females moult.
    • jayc
      No it won't have all the minerals needed for plants. SS GH/KH+ is made up of Calcium carbonate, Magnesium.   Anubias is a slow growing plant, so it does not need much fertilisers. Mosses will grow with out any added ferts. Hairgrass and whatever you have in the back corner will survive without added ferts. Give it CO2 while your tanks is empty of shrimps.    Aim for 4-6 GH.  
    • Newday
      Hello, again.  I really appreciate everyone's wisdom on this topic.  Since I last posted, I lost my 29 gallon tropical freshwater aquarium to a sudden leak. 😞  Thankfully, I was able to save and rehome all the fish.  But, that means my 7 gallon shrimp tank received an upgrade wrt live plants and gravel.  I was hoping that would inspire some mating behavior, but I actually witnessed a female discharging what must be unfertilized eggs just this evening.  The male shrimp (I thought I had two, but now I'm questioning the other's sex after some weeks) is not doing his job and I can't figure out why.  I had to siphon out 50% of the water to move it from it's prior location beneath the 29 gallon.  I have not performed another water change in the nearly 3 weeks since the leak happened.  I check the parameters in the 7 gallon once a week and ammonia, nitrate, and nitrite are 0ppm.  Temp remains at a steady 72 degrees.  The shrimp are as active as ever but that male is unexcited by a tank full of females.  No clue what to do next.😑
    • DEL 707
      I'm thinking of ordering that "Salty Shrimp - Shrimp Mineral GH/KH+". My only concern is, does it also have all the needed minerals for my plants? Edit - If I was to use my tap water, what kind of GH should I be aiming for?
    • sdlTBfanUK
      WOW, that's hard water all right! Amazing how different it is to mine as probably only about 25 miles between us???? You were right to use RO water so at least you have a good starting point from here in! The PH may be the biggest issue as remineralising with a shrimp specific GH/KH+ will sort everything else with RO water. Cherry shrimps are pretty tough and adaptable so will tolerate PH below 7 but the nearer you can get to 7 the better, and a long time acclimating the shrimps using a dripper (there is a tube with regulator sold by ProShrimp for about £10 I think if you don't already have something) will be needed! The soil will take longer to loose its PH buffering ability with the RO though! There are a number of ways you can go from here: 1) RO water plus a GH/KH+ and try to get the PH up somehow although you will be fighting the Soil until that exhausts its buffering ability. 2) You could mix RO and (dechlorinated) tap water at 3:1 and then use a GH+. I do a 50/50 'similar' (half tap water, half brita filtered water) on my oldest tank. can't even remember why but I believe in 'don't try and fix it if it isn't broken' so have just carried on ever since. The mixed water would start at PH 6.2, TDS 70(ish), GH just over 4, KH just under 4 and then you can mineralise it (GH+ only) for the rest. This will exhaust the soil buffering quicker than 1 above and you will save a bit on RO water, use less (about half as much) mineraliser etc. You may think this is a bit too fussy a route though, and the soil will still buffer anyway, just not for as long as all RO water, and when it stops buffering you will have a PH closer to the ideal for the shrimps. Probably where you are now I would just get the snails for now until you have stopped adjusting the water or at least decided where next, probably not much longer before you get shrimps. I would also try turning off the CO2 and just see if it is really needed, if it looks like it is you can easily turn it back on then, but shrimps will do better without it and it MAY not be needed, same for fertilisers??? At least you are doing all this before getting the shrimps, very smart as most of us have learnt the hard/wrong way................ Simon
×
×
  • Create New...