Jump to content
sdlTBfanUK

RCS / TIGER Query???

Recommended Posts

sdlTBfanUK

I have Nano fish and red cherry shrimps tank for many a year, just doing routine stuff and not really even looking inside. I decided I would try and take a photo and that is below. There are quite a few wild (brown) ones now due to my neglect! Bizarrely there aren't any browns in the picture, but believe me there are many and I assume that is due to reverting back to wild types and over time I expect the brown to red ratios will probably increase for browns and decrease reds unless I start doing some fishing out of the browns, but of coarse they are much harder to spot than the reds. Anyway, I'm waffling!

My question is, can red cherrys ( have only ever bought those for this tank) produce the tiger looking shrimps in the photo???? I assume they came from a variety of red cherry as there has NEVER been anything but RED cherrys in the tank (that I put in there anyway)? Never in my life have I bought tigers as I'm not keen on them... I only even noticed them as they were in the front of the picture, and hence blown up in size? I thought Tigers were Caradina not neocaradina???

DSC00239.thumb.JPG.b73326ce3df736ccf74b19d912e19dd2.JPGYours baffled.......

Simon

DSC00238.JPG

Edited by sdlTBfanUK

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kms
20 hours ago, sdlTBfanUK said:

I have Nano fish and red cherry shrimps tank for many a year, just doing routine stuff and not really even looking inside. I decided I would try and take a photo and that is below. There are quite a few wild (brown) ones now due to my neglect! Bizarrely there aren't any browns in the picture, but believe me there are many and I assume that is due to reverting back to wild types and over time I expect the brown to red ratios will probably increase for browns and decrease reds unless I start doing some fishing out of the browns, but of coarse they are much harder to spot than the reds. Anyway, I'm waffling!

My question is, can red cherrys ( have only ever bought those for this tank) produce the tiger looking shrimps in the photo???? I assume they came from a variety of red cherry as there has NEVER been anything but RED cherrys in the tank (that I put in there anyway)? Never in my life have I bought tigers as I'm not keen on them... I only even noticed them as they were in the front of the picture, and hence blown up in size? I thought Tigers were Caradina not neocaradina???

DSC00239.thumb.JPG.b73326ce3df736ccf74b19d912e19dd2.JPGYours baffled.......

Simon

DSC00238.JPG

From my experiences, It can happen. I'm also new to shrimps, but I got red shrimps (light , dark, see-through variation), clear

see-through and a unknown type from a blue shrimp, probably got pregnant before it was introduced to the tank.

this is a my unknown shrimps, it also has a copper color band along the back, It came from a blue shrimp.

20jpxdh.jpg

 

Edited by kms
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sdlTBfanUK

Thats very interesting and thanks for letting me know. Your one looks very similar to mine (yours has more colour) as well. I gave a friend a load of my reds years ago and saw him today and he says he has some like that as well, so they must have come from the reds!

When we both looked earlier we also saw some medium matt brown with light brown stripe down the back which I assume must also be wild type. I will try and get a photo of one of them at some point.

Simon

Edited by sdlTBfanUK
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Zoidburg

Yes, it's possible for Neos to be kind of stripy like tigers.

Also, new info may be coming to light that tigers and Neos can breed... and yes, tigers are Caridina.

 

A tank of reds doesn't typically revert to wild type, even with neglect... chances are, you had a rouge shrimp in the tank *OR* one was carrying genes for another type?

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
sdlTBfanUK
7 hours ago, Zoidburg said:

Yes, it's possible for Neos to be kind of stripy like tigers.

Also, new info may be coming to light that tigers and Neos can breed... and yes, tigers are Caridina.

 

A tank of reds doesn't typically revert to wild type, even with neglect... chances are, you had a rouge shrimp in the tank *OR* one was carrying genes for another type?

You are most likely right. I have only ever put red cherries in the tank from one source so assume one had different genes and now they are cross breeding. I got the shrimp off ebay many years ago, so you never really know what you may be getting, but they were all red to start with. I have little interest in that tank anyway, as I have the Taiwan Bee tank now, so can't be bothered to try and fish out all the brown ones as it is pretty densely planted!

Simon

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • kms
      I will post photos tmr of my current setup, is not a pretty sight, just moves house, and as said, I recently gave 99% of my shrimps away, but it's ok, just looks something like a exotic jungle.😜
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I think we are more of a 'must have a heater' country than 'must have a chiller'. Last year we had a few risky days where it got to 30 outside, but the tank water didn't get above 26 or 27, so it was close to where I thought I might see some dead bodies. It sounds as though you have gone all out with your setup and I have always thought the madagascar lace plant is very attractive, and maybe you need Co2 with that sort of exotic plant setup, but generally I think shrimp are supposed to do better without it, but if it is all working stick with it. I would love to see some photos, as I am sure others would as well. Simon
    • jayc
      No rush with the chiller,  as we are going into winter.  So shop around for the best price.  With such a small tank,  get the smallest cheapest chiller you can find in the brands range. Hailea chillers are probably the best compromise between price and quality. So you can start looking there. I think the HC100a is the smallest in this range. The cheap eBay phase change chillers will work on your small tank but quality will reflect with the price. Teco chillers are in the high range and will be a bit more expensive but they are good quality.  I have a couple myself. And they have been running every summer for many years now. 
    • kms
      The chiller is only useful if you live in a country that is hot, I think places like the UK should be alright without it. About the Co2, i'm not sure if it will affect neo's or the cardina, but my tank seems ok, I set the Co2 at its lowest because of a small tank, at least the plants are doing well, especially the floating one's  mini water lettuce, duckweed, RRF and frogbits which is beneficial to shrimps, I also have Fissidens fontanus, and madagascar lace plants. Forgot to mention, I also have a UV light.   If you want to see some photo, just let me know.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Glad we can be of some help and I agree you are doing the best thing by thinking it out thoroughly before you get started. It is very frustrating when you spend a lot of money on a small setup to then have to go and do the same again for another setup because it isn't big enough, way more economical and cost effective to get it right first time, though as you say you are starting with some of the stuff! I'm also sure that when I closed down the small one and moved the shrimps to the new tank that I probably lost half of the shrimplets as they were too small/young to be moved in reality but I really didn't want to have to run 2 tanks for a few months whilst I waited for them to grow - I had way too many anyway. I can't be much help regarding the 'chiller' as we don't have hot enough weather here, in fact even the humans don't get that over here (except in expensive cars)? A lot may depend where you are placing the setup as well, mine is in a dark corner that doesn't get any direct sun. If it isn't likely to get too hot there for a while you can of course come back to that as a separate issue as it won't mean disrupting anything in the tank anyway should you decide to get one later!  You are probably best steering away from the CO2 as it is one less thing to set up and, as you, I have read a lot of reports saying it isn't good with caridina shrimp setups, though I have no actual experience with it, but why risk it. Hope you will keep us informed/updated. Simon
×