Jump to content

Attack of the worms

jojowhisky

By jojowhisky,
in New Members Forum

 Share

Recommended Posts

jojowhisky Shrimp Keeper

jojowhisky

Posted
Posted

Hello all,

Is anyone able to id this worm?

Im not sure if it is the dreaded planaria or harmless rhabdocoela??

Just dosed my shrimp tank with planaria meds 2 days ago but these are still alive?!

I have shrimplets in my tank so im pretty panicky about these worms.

 

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

 

 

These are the pictures, tried my hardest to get a clear shot. Sorry for the bad photo skills.9452e438393155eb6077f0f55852d7e1.jpge961c2d065a5e4d35d1b5ae76a6d8590.jpg198c5169c8b39a6f2f231333e9bdfefc.jpg3bdcf69ad17c3eca317d7b1f0524981c.jpg704c35ef24790d50246363074e199288.jpg

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jayc Shrimp Guru

jayc

Posted
Posted (edited)

I'm going to borrow a picture from the interwebs for this question.

Planaria have an arrow shaped head. Rhabdocoela on the other hand has a rounded head.

image.jpeg.c3435df0b5dd0f19e6e2903be95e9b6c.jpeg

 

What planaria meds did you use?

It should have worked for Rhabdocoela as well.

If you can, use Planaria Zero from Benibachi. They use Betel nut extract, which is a natural remedy for flatworms.

And is much safer than Panacur C or Fenbendazole.

 

If you are worried for the shrimplets, use half dose. Do a 50% water change 2 days later (don't skip this).Gravel vac if you can. Then repeat dose and water change 2 days later to get those hiding under the substrate. If you can, stir the gravel/substrate during the treatment.

Make sure there is plenty of surface agitation for oxygen exchange throughout the treatment period.

Edited by jayc
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Zoidburg Shrimp Breeder

Zoidburg

Posted
Posted

Definitely rhabdocoela flatworms. They don't get any bigger. Planaria do grow larger, though. Hit or miss if products that kill planaria will also kill these guys.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jojowhisky Shrimp Keeper

jojowhisky

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I'm going to borrow a picture from the interwebs for this question.
Planaria have an arrow shaped head. Rhabdocoela on the other hand has a rounded head.
image.jpeg.c3435df0b5dd0f19e6e2903be95e9b6c.jpeg
 
What planaria meds did you use?
It should have worked for Rhabdocoela as well.
If you can, use Planaria Zero from Benibachi. They use Betel nut extract, which is a natural remedy for flatworms.
And is much safer than Panacur C or Fenbendazole.
 
If you are worried for the shrimplets, use half dose. Do a 50% water change 2 days later (don't skip this).Gravel vac if you can. Then repeat dose and water change 2 days later to get those hiding under the substrate. If you can, stir the gravel/substrate during the treatment.
Make sure there is plenty of surface agitation for oxygen exchange throughout the treatment period.
Hey jayc,
I used planaria off!
Its a drug from thailand, smells like betal nut extract (rather earthy kind of smell), couldnt get benibachi as it was sold out everywhere. Have ordered it from japan. Item will reach prob next week.
The other product available here is borneo wild's exterminate but the package recommends you remove all shrimp in it i think, cant do that now without leaving out some coz the tank has fry all over the place.
From what i read, rhabdocoela does not die from planaria treatments? I dont know if i should be happy abt this coz it could mean they are not planaria and im jus a paranoid mess.

I did increase the surface agitation (spray bar tilted higher) and airstone. Got it real good into the substrate (coz im paranoid). Took a reading last night and the ammonia level was >0.05ppm, im also not seeing dead bodies.

Im happy to leave them alone if its rhabdocoela but if they are planaria they got to go!!!!!b4159808f60327690c811aec02549189.jpg

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jojowhisky Shrimp Keeper

jojowhisky

Posted
  • Author
Posted
Definitely rhabdocoela flatworms. They don't get any bigger. Planaria do grow larger, though. Hit or miss if products that kill planaria will also kill these guys.
You think so?! So they are not planaria?
This is great news, have been so worried abt the situation. I have as well read that planaria treatments will not kill rhabdocoela.
Because after i dosed the treatment, i did not see any casualties. Also my ammonia readings are so low. And they are crawling around, real real small flatworms.
Cant seem to see a triangular head with 2 eye dots, they look round to me.
Its a joke, when you are paranoid, your eyes tell you its a triangular head but ur head tells you its a round head (bonkers)

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Zoidburg Shrimp Breeder

Zoidburg

Posted
Posted

No Planaria, Planaria Zero and now Planaria Off? LOL So many names!

Yes, it's rhabdocoela flatworms. You can tell because a) they are small and b) they don't have a triangle shaped head. Someone actually took a good photo of planaria in substrate near some shrimp. They can get larger than this. (not my photo!)

planaria-white-worm-aquarium.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jojowhisky Shrimp Keeper

jojowhisky

Posted
  • Author
Posted
No Planaria, Planaria Zero and now Planaria Off? LOL So many names!
Yes, it's rhabdocoela flatworms. You can tell because a) they are small and b) they don't have a triangle shaped head. Someone actually took a good photo of planaria in substrate near some shrimp. They can get larger than this. (not my photo!)
planaria-white-worm-aquarium.jpg
And really expensive all these planaria treatments!! Such good money strategy!
Anyways, that picture the planarian is already too big for my comfort if you are saying they can get bigger, i know i would really freak out if those were in my tank. Creepy!!!!!!


Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jayc Shrimp Guru

jayc

Posted
Posted

I see you bought that at Polyart!

You must be Singaporean. Polyart is one of my fav shops to visit when I'm in Singapore.

I have not heard of planaria off! so can't comment how good it is.

At least it is not planaria.

 

Minimise the food that falls in the cracks of the substrate. That might help. But it can be difficult when you have to feed baby shrimps. 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
jojowhisky Shrimp Keeper

jojowhisky

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I see you bought that at Polyart!
You must be Singaporean. Polyart is one of my fav shops to visit when I'm in Singapore.
I have not heard of planaria off! so can't comment how good it is.
At least it is not planaria.
 
Minimise the food that falls in the cracks of the substrate. That might help. But it can be difficult when you have to feed baby shrimps. 
 
Yep singaporean!
This product i could say it is a good product, though we have established that i have rhabdocoela instead, this product DID NOT KILL the berried and baby shrimps.
So this is indeed shrimp safe. ( just like the uncle at the lfs assured).
Just gotta increase surface agitation, do not overdose and also THIS IS NOT SAFE FOR FISH. Shopkeeper told me somebody killed their discus because he dosed this in his discus tank:(
You would wanna mix this well in some of your tank water prior to pouring the mixed solution into the tank as this does not dissolve instantly in the tank.
Just so glad i dont have them killer wormies in my tank, nasty little buggers they are[emoji1785]

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Must Read SKF Articles

    Shrimp Disease and Treatment
    Tibee, Taitbee, Pinto, Mischling, F1, F2

  • Tropical Fish Forum
    Discus Breeding Guide
    Discus Disease and Treatment Guide

  • Posts

    • krogoo22
      keeping cinnamon sticks and oak leaves in tank - how long?

      By krogoo22 · Posted

      I would add that boiling discourages natural decomposition and would likely break down the antifungals present in the bark, letting the fungus actually grow.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Betta Water Parameters

      By sdlTBfanUK · Posted

      I shall probably just call him bertie as I did the previous 2 I had.
    • jayc
      Betta Water Parameters

      By jayc · Posted

      What nice friends you have! Have you named the new betta yet? 
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Betta Water Parameters

      By sdlTBfanUK · Posted

      I had friends round at the weekend, moving furniture around so now I can see the fish tanks from where I normally sit. The only tank that has been running since I moved has had bloody mary shrimps in it and they are fine. It was my betta tank before, and after moving my friends went out and got me a new betta;- As you can see he is ultra healthy looking (pic is of him in the fish store tank) and he has been very active from the moment he arrived and started a bubble nest within an hour of going into the tank. He is about half the size of a fully grown one! He is a bit bland to look at as just white but I went for him as the tank is quite (understatement) dark and so he is easily visible, even from a distance. Hopefully he won't devour the shrimps (the odd baby shrimp I don't mind) but I will have to see on that issue! All the water parameters seem fine aside frm KH which is 6 as this area has harder water than where I was before, but I will gradually get that down using the filtered water (RO) with GH+ shrimp remineraliser from this point, that has no KH and I will just do it gradually over a loooong period as neither he nor the shrimps seem unhappy as it currently is anyway! Apparently the store he came from also sell blue bolt (and some other taiwan bee type) shrimps etc so I will start thinking about setting that tank up (it is situ next to the betta tank) at some point in the near future, though that will be months away even when I do decide to start, as the substrate needs running-in, and the tank will need to cycle etc. 
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Identify illness

      By sdlTBfanUK · Posted

      I see the 2 shrimplets, very exciting and the shrimp in the photo look very healthy! The KH is fine at 3 and slowly dropping because of the substrate, but still in the acceptable range. Not sure about your tank size, other than 'nano' but if you have fish in that same tank (I think I see one in the photo blrred and at the back) I would do 25% weekly water changes (mainly because of the fish) and that will help counter the substrate as well, until the substrate is 'exhausted' of its buffering ability. Use the same kh4 new water as currently and always add the new water slowly, a drip method is best. Obviously you will need to be extra careful when removing the old water that you don't remove any of the new shrimplets........ Try not to change too much though as you may do more harm than good and it looks like everything is actually already going well, visible mating behavour and shrimplets doing well. Hope you manage to get rid of the planaria and that usually involves sizeable water changes in the process so complete that first and from then do the 25% regular water change routine. As the population grows you will need to increase the amount of food but be cautious not to overfeed. The bacter AE should help with biofilm growth etc but it isn't actually a food for the shrimps, though you may see them eating some if it isn't dissolved fully. The scuds are harmless and I would (and did in the past) remove them manually when you see them.
×
×
  • Create New...