Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
daveron

No3 rising very quickly

Recommended Posts

daveron

Hi

I have an issue with my old tank, which is around 3 years right now and the issue is NO3.

Currently I am forced to do 25-30% water changes twice a week, and this is just enough to keep the NO3 below 10 (which is still way to high!). I have no idea what is causing the NO3 to raise so quickly as there is just around 50 shrimp and nothing more.

The tank is 30L (8 gal), inert substrate, heavily planted, I add no fertilizers.

Plants are duckweed, anubias, cryptocoryne, and eleocharis parvula carpet.

Two HOB filters - one is sponge, the other one is small sponge + peat + JBL nitratex + seachem matrix (I added two weeks ago, as this thing is supposed to bring down nitrates, but so far no results).

For water changes I use salty shrimp GH +, Azoo Triple Black Water, Azoo Mineral Plus(every second week) and Azoo Ph Down, to adjust the pH of the water that goes into the tank with what's already there.

As for bacteria I add seachem pristine, and seachem stability once a week around 2ml of each.

Feeding is once per 2-3 days, small amounts that gets eaten in a few hours.

So I had that issue already around 5 months back and what I did is bought the JBL bionitratex and added duckweed, and it did solved the problem but to get a good result I had to use two bags of the JBL product for a single tank (the product comes with 4 bags total). Now this thing is quiet expensive imo for the time it lasts, so I would like to ask for any other options to keep the NO3 in check, as the plants are clearly not able to handle that.

From my observations - there is a substantial amount of muck in the substrate, but since the tank is heavily planted I cannot vacuum it.

If needed I can provide some pictures of the tank.

Your help greatly appreciated !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

When was the last time you cleaned the filter media?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
daveron

I did so as soon as the problem came back. Did not help !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

Then, the muck in the substrate must be the problem.

Try vacuuming just the top if you can't go deep down due to the plants.

Alternatively, Seachem Purigen  will help. In Aus, we have a cheaper alternative called Macropore. But you might not get that where you are.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
daveron

The thing is that most of the acidity in the tank comes from humic acids, which purigen will absorb (as Seachem confirmed).

I will try to clean the substrate as much as possible.

Just a small update - I tried vacuuming as you suggested and it looks like it is effective, despite the plant carpet as I managed to suck out a lot debris without disturbing the plants and the substrate. I will continue with frequent water changes, but now vacuuming each time I do that, and hopefully the NO3 will stop rising so quickly after a few weeks.

Thanks for the help !

Edited by daveron
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
9 hours ago, daveron said:

looks like it is effective

Good to hear.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pastu

The bacteria you add weekly are not necessary and ríase nitrates

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
29 minutes ago, pastu said:

The bacteria you add weekly are not necessary and ríase nitrates

Interesting theory Pastu.

Where have you read/seen this? Because most experiences I have read are that they reduce nitrates, at least temporarily.

Genuinely interested to know if these bacterial additive in a bottle actually raise nitrates instead of reducing it. Please let me know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pastu

Is not a theory. Stop adding them and continúe testing, you will likely see That nitrates stop raising

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cesar
3 hours ago, pastu said:

Is not a theory. Stop adding them and continúe testing, you will likely see That nitrates stop raising

 

@pastu do you have a link, pdf, research paper? or is this more of your personal experience?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pastu

I dont have links and i have  never used bottled bacteria , nor do i think i ever will. But do a search in Google about bottled bacteria and you will find Several reports  of them raising nitrogen compounds.  Either  their dead  bodies rise nitrogen or they have ammonia added to supply them with food. 

Once the beneficial bacteria population is established in a cycled acuarium, adding  bottled ones can do no good in my humble opiniom 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

@pastu, thank you. Certainly interesting.

I'll keep an eye out for these reports, but good to know. 

I don't use bottled bacteria either, as I have many established tanks that I can use to seed new tanks. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
pastu

I really enjoy cycling a tank from zero. Find fascínating the invisible process seemingly Out of the blue , where ammonia  rises, leaching from the substrate ( always use Ada amazonia or help shrimp substratos) then ammonia turns into nitrite and those two dissapear and you are left with nitrate, al i had to do  was wait, i also use seachem matrix or pondguru,s ultimate and that ends Taking Care of nitrate too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • revolutionhope
      By revolutionhope
      Hey SKF,
      I've recently started adding 2ppm of nitrates to my weekly/fortnightly waterchanges as my tank constantly had zero nitrates and my plants were looking hungry. The product I use is cal aqua labs green.
      I'd like to know what people's experiences or opinions are on whether small amounts of fertiliser can be added to shrimp tanks WITHOUT dripping it in slowly (as in a typical waterchange which is what I'm currently doing)
      In other words; if I directly dose the 1 or 2 ppm worth of nitrates to my aquarium without slowly dripping it into the tank would it have any negative impact on the health and/or breeding of crystal or tiger shrimps?
      love n peace
      will
    • larrymull
      By larrymull
      Hi Guys,
      My nitrates continue to read above 20, sometimes 40 and I have no idea how to keep them down. All other parameters are fine ph 6.2, 0 ammonia, 0 nitrites, 2kh, 4gh, 195 TDS (it has crept up a bit too much for my liking).
      Anyway some simple things for you to know is that my tank has a layer of frogbit, I do not overfeed (feed every 2nd or 3rd day), weekly 10% water changes using RO water, I also have boss mineral balls, IAL leaf, Benibachi zero, golden vine with xmas moss, 1 aqua clear hob filter and a biospon 56l dual sponge. 
      I do not want to go down the path of using peat moss, I just want to be able to control the nitrates naturally. 
      I would appreciate any thoughts - my plan of attack this weekend is to do at least a 25% water change (this takes forever to do when you are dripping the RO water back in to the tank) and was going to clean the sponge in the HOB filter.


  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Posts

    • jayc
      ✌️   Absolutely only use bleach as the last resort, with nothing in the tank. (6parts water to 1part bleach for future reference). Even white vinegar is safer and probably just as effective for removal of planaria and worms. After you clear the old tank of gravel, give the glass a quick wipe with a vinegar soaked kitchen paper towel. Rinse and let dry in the sun. Use vinegar if that wasn't clear.   Set up the new tank as desired. If your other tanks are free of pests, you can use the filter media to seed this new tank. Wash the filter media in the water of the new tank. Yes, it will be dirty for a while, but you will have seeded it with millions of beneficial bacteria and probably cycle the new tank in a week.   PRL, real PRL, are pretty rare in Aus.  They will demand a high price for them, so check the legitimacy of the PRL. Find out the PRL history. Nice looking CRS is not the same as PRL.     
    • DEL 707
      Thanks. Think I'm going to order from Pro Shrimp, get 5 cheeries and 3 amano, just to play it safe.
    • Crabclaw
      Dang I thought u might say that... for some reason the guy at my rlfs (relatively local fish store) recommended them instead of honey gouramis as a bit of a feature fish. Are there any other ‘feature fish’ style fish that wouldn’t munch on my shrimp, or should I just stick with my endler trio? I’ll check out the food stuff, thx.
    • incomplet
      Hi Simon,  Thanks for the warm welcome! I've been using the GenChem No Planaria; honestly it worked so well the first time and most of the snail population/worms all disappeared and i tried to remove most of the larger rotting worms but didn't have a single casualty, they were Neocaridinas and i guess they were much hardier. But i did notice the packet wasn't sealed properly when I went back to use it a few months later. I haven't seen the SLAqua Z1 available in Australia before.  I used to own a marine aquarium previously with fish only; then i changed after a few years to a planted aquarium with CO2 and then to a smaller set up with shrimp. Currently have three tanks (2 foot with RC Shrimp, 1 foot cube with BB and another 1 foot cube with CBS); I've never had to really restart a tank but would rather consult SKF then have a crack at it myself. I wasn't use if using bleach to rid of all the hitch hikers was the right method. And i have no idea what ratio of bleach to water I should be using for a 27L cube. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!  Yeah i think RO water at stage 6 would be a bit over kill; especially with the time it takes to make the water. Thanks for that. I've got about 40-50 with about 10 as breeding adults and the rest as juveniles still; I'm not a picky person when it comes to culling; I'm enjoying the hobby not as breeder to sell to others. I'd figure it would be good fun to pass the time, water changes and watching the little fellas shrimp around picking and prodding at things. Also i have no idea about the F1, cross breeding, taibees, taitibees, etc. just more interested in seeing the differing colors.  I set up the CBS and BB tanks at the same time which also sit next to each other; the CBS population has exploded to about 100+ shrimp where the BB is a bit slower. Is that quite common; are BB more fragile? I thought about trying to have a got at PRL. Any advice? Cheers, Dan Hey jayc, Thanks for that; phew lucky i bought a spare way nack. Yeha i have lots of denitrate left over. Also hello fellow Sydney-Sider! Dan
    • jayc
      There are so many varieties of food you can be feeding them. Have a read of this Food & Nutrition section for more ideas. Leaves, flowers, vege scraps. Frozen bloodworms. Bee Pollen.  
×
×
  • Create New...