Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Kaizen088

Chery Shrimp with Bristlenose eggs

Recommended Posts

Kaizen088

So this topic has come up on another great (aquaruim) forum that I am a member of, thought I'd see if anyone here has some more info on the subject.

I have recently got back into fish and breeding after a bit of an absence for a few years.

Back in the day I bred bristlenose catfish with many pairs/trios breeding all the time and I was always getting some eggs kicked out of some caves.

I'd put them in an egg tumbler and most survived, occasionally some eggs would get a hairy fungus grow on them(usually the unfertilised eggs) which if not removed from the clutch would send the other eggs next it fungusy as well.

So now there is shrimp available where they weren't available back then.

Some reputable people on the other forum said to throw a couple of shrimp in the egg tumbler with the eggs to keep them clean.

I got my first batch of eggs almost 2 weeks ago and the male had kicked about 12 eggs out of the cave. I put them in an egg tumbler with 2 medium sized Cherries. I watched them constantly each day as I was a little paranoid that the shrimp may eat the eggs. I noticed that there was one white, unfertilised egg within the clutch (I used to remove them with an airline to prevent problems). The shrimp went straight to work on the unfertilised egg and for the duration that the eggs were in there, that was the only egg they ate. I could see them feeding off/cleaning the healthy eggs but didnt lose any.

Both also shed while in the egg tumbler (not sure if that's relevant)

My question is has anyone here used shrimp for care of eggs in an egg tumbler and have they eaten healthy eggs as well as unfertilised ones. Any other info around this topic is also much appreciated.

Cheers

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Matmatmat

I've not used a tumbler , but have used cherry shrimp to keep flowerhorn and goldfish eggs clean. Never noticed any healthy eggs get eaten..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
wayne6442

Mate neve done it, But a very interesting point you have there,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
smicko

hi mate. every egg I have ever tumbled has had cherries in with them. as you mentioned they eat any unfertilized eggs and keep the others clean which I found handy when I was breeding Africans and Americans.

cheers Mick

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
honcho

me too ive been diong it for ages.. only way to keep eggs clean of any fungus..or dead eggs.. they will definantely not eat good eggs..

i have found larger females to be best for this job as they seem to do better cleaning of eggs.. maybe due to eating more to produce there own eggs..

males tend to be lazy and my eggs usually get fungused up easy and die..

well thats my experience with it ...

hope that helps

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kaizen088

Thanks for the feedback guys.

@honcho, does it matter if the females are berried or not?

I'm very skilled at sexing berried shrimp(lol), if they're not berried do I just look for a saddle or what?

Still new at keeping shrimp.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
staphjermz

Wow that is interesting.i have bristlenoses as well but daddy looked after the eggs til they hatched

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mickeyG

I've used red cherries with all my yellows,bn and l number eggs without any problems.

A couple of times I have thought they had attacked a good egg but when I've looked closer the eggs have always been non fertile.

I had to get my head around the fact cherries knew before me what eggs were the keepers..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kaizen088
I've used red cherries with all my yellows' date='bn and l number eggs without any problems.

A couple of times I have thought they had attacked a good egg but when I've looked closer the eggs have always been non fertile.

I had to get my head around the fact cherries knew before me what eggs were the keepers..[/quote']

Yeah I think its a bit like maggots, they only eat dead flesh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
honcho

lol @ maggots.. yeah doesnt matter if they are berried or not.. just look for a couple good size ones and chuck them in..also saddle is usually a little diamond shaped yellow colouring just where the head and the body connect on top..

females also have a much bigger belly that is more rounded..

..also i just remembered that this is how i first got into shrimp.. because i needed some to tumble bristlenose eggs.id totally forgot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
mickeyG

Same honcho, lost three batches of bn eggs before my mate told me to try it and gave me 20rcs

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
fishmosy

I always use RCS in my tumblers, certainly saves the hassle of trying to remove fungused eggs yourself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
t3v0r0

Wow that's interesting. I've got red cherrys in my tank and my bristlenose is about to have eggs.

I'll give this idea a go

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
zohn
Wow that's interesting. I've got red cherrys in my tank and my bristlenose is about to have eggs.

I'll give this idea a go

What's the status? RCS with bristlenose eggs worked for me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
t3v0r0

So my BNs had eggs over the weekend, and it so happens that my male kicked half the clutch out. (About 20 eggs) I've put these and 1 cherry red shrimp in the tumbler.

I'll post an update in the next day or two to see if any of the fertilized looking eggs get eaten.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
t3v0r0

Update:

All the bristlenose eggs hatched successfully. Thankfully none was unfertilised.

The cherry red shrimp didn't touch any of the eggs during the whole hatching process

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kaizen088

Good to hear...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Posts

    • DEL 707
      Again, thanks for all the help. I ordered the Shrimp GH+KH minerals and they arrived today and did a 20l water change. I plan to do 20l on Saturday and 20l on Tuesday when I'm off, so that'll be over 100% water change. If my tank stats come back o.k, I might finally look into getting some shrimp next week.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      It is definitely more of a balancing act when trying to keep everything happy in a tank with Shrimps and plants, but don't be put off I think you will be fine. When putting the shrimps in the tank you should take hours of dripping to acclimate them and you may lose a few with the low Ph but I am sure it will work out in the end as cherry shrimps are fairly tough. If you use all RO water and GH/KH+ then the PH will always be lower even after the buffering of the soil stops, but this is the easiest route to go! If you go the mixed water 1:3 with GH+ the same applies but the PH will be slightly higher and will be cheaper (less GH+ and RO water needed), so overall this is the way I would go, and it isn't all that complicated once you get it up and running! As with JayC I doubt you really will need any ferts but if you must then use a lot less than the packaging recommends!  The best thing to do is just decide which route you prefer to go from the start as it gets so much more difficult to change it later? I don't have any issue with keeping shrimps/fish/plants happy and I don't use CO2 or any fertilizers so it is definitely possible and not that difficult if I can do it? I think that a lot of the plant fertilizers etc are really intended for plant aquascapes without any inhabitants but with fish and/or shrimps there will be natural fertilizer and the soil should have enough to start everything off? If you still aren't too sure I would just try running the tank without the CO2 or ferts (with the exception of as JayC recommends above) for a few weeks and just see how the plants get on, as you can start using either/both again at any point if they don't look like they are ok, but I expect it will work out fine. This will also give you time to mull it over at leisure? Simon
    • jayc
      You only need Flourish Potassium, as needed, in an aquarium. Potassium will be the limiting factor to growth in most aquariums. But with shrimp in the tank, I would dose it at 1/4 strength once every 2 weeks or more. Seachem Flourish for micro nutrients at half recommended dose every other 2 weeks in between the Potassium.   But !!  I don't believe you will need too much ferts in your tank. The type of plants and the amount of plants do not warrant much ferts at all. The waste from the fish and shrimps will be enough ferts, and if they are getting enough light a day, the plants will be fine without any additional ferts, except maybe a little potassium once every few weeks.
    • DEL 707
      O.k rethink. If I use that Salty Shrimp GH/KH stuff. Can you recommend any good fertilisers I could use for the plants? I'm not dosing anything at the moment.
    • DEL 707
      Not going to lie, this is giving me a headache. Just want a nice planted tank with fish and shrimp. 🤨 At the moment it looks like it have to either pick 1 or the other. Would this be a solution. Use Seachems Equilibrium and KH products to bring my GH and KH up to 4, then use that Shrimp King Mineral Fluid Double, to bring the GH up to 6. That would make sure that there are at least some minerals for the shrimp.
×
×
  • Create New...