Jump to content
Baccus

Does anyone Know

Recommended Posts

Baccus

Twice now I have seen snails for sale on apparently Australian facebook shrimp auction page that are selling Assassin snails now a zebra nerite that I am sure is only sold overseas. I have heard from other Australians that they have managed to buy Assassin snails off gumtree. My quandary is this are these snails supposed to be in Australia? Surely with all the other fish species banned the powers that be wouldn't suddenly allow in at least one of the snail species, the nerites I can understand being let in since they are so tricky to breed in fresh water.

Edited by Baccus

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

They were probably smug_gled into the country just like how Sulas might have been, which in theory would not have been allowed into the country.

Eggs in a bit of wAter is not easy to detect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Grubs

All smuggled in illegally - like most of the shrimp and half the aquarium plants that are in this country.  Snails in particular are a no-no to import because they are often the intermediate host for parasites that infect people. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ageofaquariums

Should also be noted some of these parasites are quite intimidating.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ineke

there was an article/thread showing an assassin snail killing a shrimp on facebook so potentially lethal to more than just other snails. It's a worry if they ever get into our waterways!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Baccus

Because of the risks involved with illegal imports both for our own (and our tanks) health and the environment I am really surprised to start seeing these "known not allowed" species being openly sold in social media sites.

I know one person who did purchase an assassin snail who later had it die in their tank, and I know they are supposed to be slow producing but there is still a huge potential for them ending up being either deliberately or accidently released.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
NoGi

It always surprises me how people want privacy and hide behind aliases on forums yet on Facebook they don't seem to have an issue publishing these illegal imports

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Baccus

Its even funnier when these same people that wanted "privacy" and a way of obscuring their identity get all bent out of shape when suddenly the powers that be track them down (possibly by posing as a buyer) and ruin their little illegal endeavours.

Actually it poses a grey area in who has consumer law on their side when the seller of an illegal item eg snail, marimo moss ball fails to deliver on the promised item. True the buyer should have been aware that the item might not be allowable in the country but lets face it plenty of people never really look into if something is supposed to be here. Instead they see it for sale on Facebook, Gumtree etc and assume it must be legit to own.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
zn30
2 hours ago, Baccus said:

Its even funnier when these same people that wanted "privacy" and a way of obscuring their identity get all bent out of shape when suddenly the powers that be track them down (possibly by posing as a buyer) and ruin their little illegal endeavours.

Actually it poses a grey area in who has consumer law on their side when the seller of an illegal item eg snail, marimo moss ball fails to deliver on the promised item. True the buyer should have been aware that the item might not be allowable in the country but lets face it plenty of people never really look into if something is supposed to be here. Instead they see it for sale on Facebook, Gumtree etc and assume it must be legit to own.

That's what so good about this forum the moderators and member keep this in check, job well done moderators ?? should be acknowledged more.

Does this forum have an article on illegal trading and or items @NoGi  ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
NoGi

Best to continue SKF sales discussions here:

We are currently looking at the future of the sales forum and which direction to take it. This all feeds into that discussion.

Marimo is banned as it is protected in their homeland: 

Exotics are still a grey area as a black and white ban would include cherries, CRS, etc.... everything but natives.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Kaylenna
1 hour ago, NoGi said:

Marimo is banned as it is protected in their homeland: 

Is there recent info on them?

I **THINK** it's listed as ok to import now when I tried to look it up... but I may have been looking at the wrong thing.  I do know you're not supposed to go to their lakes and fish them out, but considering the volume that is likely already out of the native lakes and being propagated in other settings and countries, it's rather like banning farmed fruit trees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
NoGi
4 minutes ago, Kaylenna said:

Is there recent info on them?

I haven't seen any but happy for someone to try and track down

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Baccus

I think the only definitive way of finding out if Marimo moss balls are allowed into the country is to talk directly to AQIS, some how I doubt it is allowed since not only is it now protected in its native lakes in Japan(?) because of the concerns with its slow growth in the wild, but also I believe there was some concern with being able to properly quarantine the moss balls and being sure that no hitch hikers come in with it without using harsh chemicals to kill potential hitch hikers that could/ would also kill the moss ball.

I do know there have been many fake marimo moss balls being sold online, being made out of some sort of fake grass or florists fake moss even fibreglass. I have usually seen marimo moss balls being sold on ebay and gumtree, for me the dead give away that the balls are most likely fake is the asking price. If the marimo moss ball had gone through the quarantine requirements I cant see it being flogged off for as little as $10.

After a bit of quick searching online it appears that the powers that be in Tasmania are pretty sure that Marimo moss balls are in the state

http://www.ifs.tas.gov.au/news/marimo-or-moss-balls-are-declared-unwanted-quarantine-pest-in-tasmania

 

But in the same search I came across this Australian seller

http://www.exoaquaristic.com.au/products/big-marimo-moss-ball-4-5-cm?variant=26785399747

I am guessing still a grey area then on the legalities.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

    Join Our Community!

  • Posts

    • kms
      I still have a bee that I forgot to mention, it has eggs for a whiles, they should hatch soon.
    • Shrimp the world
      Hope you get some numbers back, in the tank .. you will be cross breeding lines tho but breeding is good tho 
    • kms
      This is an update, just I only have 3 babies left, and I have just purchased 3 more shrimp, 2 wine Red and one red bolt/golden. The two light reds are the babies, the dark red are the wine Red.
    • sdlTBfanUK
      I will be using 4-5L of the betta dirty water next friday and the sponges will be 1 from the betta tank and 1 from the fish tank. The tank is 47cm wide, 25cm front to back, 29cm tall closed (72cm with the top flipped up). There is a nicely fitting clear plastic cover between the light and the water but that is very tricky to remove UNLESS you flip the light upwards so you need the clearance above and the same goes for feeding as it is quite a tight fitting top it would be easier to remove the top cover, but you may be able to lift the plastic cover (fiddly but light weight to drop food in?). With that top removed access is good from the open top. Of course, flipping the light up means there is no light when doing maintenance, unless you drop the light back into place which I do but I do have unusually skinny arms and unless you have really fat arms this should work. I like black backgrounds so just used a refuse sack which I taped on and that works well because you can also wrap it around the back section of the sides - this may make more sense when the tank is in front of you. I wouldn't even consider moving it when water is in it for maintenance, bad idea in general and I am not sure it would take too much of that sort of stress.................... The dripper sits nicely on the top and the water pipe can be squished between the top and edge of the tank which holds it securely so won't spring out when your not looking. Overall it is a great tank and ideal for shrimps (or Betta) as it isn't too tall, which is wasted space for shrimps lets be honest (or Betta), you want more base area than height. It is easy to set up, well there isn't really any? If you decide which way you want the top to flip before you set it up as the front is the same as the back (though actually I don't know which is which) so you just turn it round the other way. 3L of substrate gives about 3cm depth which looks about right. Although it is officially a 25L tank, mine holds 20L of water (assuming my measuring jug is accurate and once all the stuff is inside and allowing 1.5 cm from the surface for safety and air etc. The only 2 'possible' draw backs are you NEED clearance of 72cm from base to flip the top up, which you are going to have to do regularly in reality. The second is the horrible box section that is built inside to house the filter and heater, it wastes way too much room and looks hideous, but that can be removed as I have done using this video (it's in german but you can see what you need to do and I actually used a sharp bread knife as I don't have any of the blades she uses https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=odw-rgejNgg. The filter that comes with it is shrimp safe and adjustable for flow rate and angle. I think I have covered as much as I can think of but let me know if you want any other clarification on anything? Simon
    • sdlTBfanUK
      Thanks for that. I put the substrate in the tank and I think that is exactly the depth. I need to add more water as only 6L in there at the moment but it does look too much soil to my eyes at the moment but that's probably just because I only had half that before and I just need to get used to it like that. I will half fill the tank (hopefully get that done today) ready to start putting the plants and decorations back in and then decide, but it is a great help to know that that is the depth others use and works ok! Thanks again shrimp the world. Simon 
×