Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
shelbyw93

Blue velvets dieing after molt

Recommended Posts

shelbyw93

I have kept tropical fish tanks for years and have never had much of a problem

Recently my LFS got a batch of blue velvet shrimp in and I fell completely in love. The lfs told me they were pretty hardy and just had to be by themselves in order to successfully breed. I had a cycled 6 gallon that was sitting empty (with the exception of some nerites) that was months previously a betta tank. I brought home 5 of the bluest ones they had and everyone did great for about a week. I had my first shrimp molt but discovered it dead the next day. This pattern continued every few days until a month after their purchase when my last remaining blue velvet molted and died after about 24 hours. I was stumped as I kept them the same way I had been successfully keeping my fish without issue. The tank temp was 82 which I of course realized only after the loss of my last shrimp. As far as I know my other water parameters are within range for the shrimp. I contributed the deaths to the high temperature and removed the heater (making the water temp a consistent 75) and awaited the next shipment of blues to my LFS.

I purchased 6 more blue velvets about a week ago. Last night I found a molt and this morning I woke up to a blue dead on its side. All of the other shrimp acting completely normal. I'm stumped. I'm working on finding a copper test to see if my local water could be causing the deaths. Is there anything else you guys can think of? I'll post my tank parameters and pics of my setup below. Any suggestions would be great. Also if I find copper in the tap water what kind of water would you suggest I use (spring, RO, etc) If it doesn't end up being copper what's the next thing I should look for? Thank you in advance!!

34cb07dfa336c6efc90b09a0854c57ed.jpg

3c7859116ced50433bcbe466595f06da.jpg

378f26acd5543d51da120982b60e3126.jpg

a878613a3eb69a6892d89ce2d65fd5c1.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc

Hi @shelbyw93,

Sorry to hear the news. 

The pH is a bit high at 7.8. It would be interesting to know the GH&KH readings too. 

Moulting issues are always related to water parameters. Can you get TDS readings?

Do you have a TDS pen? 

Read this... 

 

First thing to do is remove that cuttlefish bone.  It will no doubt be increasing TDS and possibly GH and KH

Then, do a 20% water change to reduce the hardness & pH. If you use tap water and the tap water is pH 7.8, then you need to look at using RO water to reduce pH, TDS, GH.

Have you tested your tap water parameters like pH and TDS so you know what you are working with?

If you can't use RO water, rain water can be an option if you don't live in a polluted city.

 

Edited by jayc

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
shelbyw93

Thank you for your reply. I was under the impression they could be kept in a wide range of parameters as long as it was clean (low nitrogen wastes). I've obviously disproven this for myself. I can do RO water I have friends who keep marine tanks. Do you have to worry about the tank having too low mineral content for the shrimp or would I be doing a portion RO AND tap water in the tank to rectify that? Also I'll be moving back from college soon and the water there is well water that goes through a softener. They also have a drinking water filter. I suppose if water parameters were correct out of any of those sources it would be just as good as using RO mixed with tap? If you don't mind me asking because I've received conflicting information what pH, GH, KH, TDS, and hardness should I be aiming for? Thank you!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
jayc
40 minutes ago, shelbyw93 said:

I was under the impression they could be kept in a wide range of parameters as long as it was clean (low nitrogen wastes). I've obviously disproven this for myself.

Yeah, as you have found, shrimp can be difficult to keep outside of their preferred parameters.

 

42 minutes ago, shelbyw93 said:

Do you have to worry about the tank having too low mineral content for the shrimp or would I be doing a portion RO AND tap water in the tank to rectify that?

Yes you do. That's where a TDS meter will come in handy.

RO with a bit of tap water now for water changes to reduce your hardness, pH and TDS (I will assume TDS is high, given you have moulting issues).

But once you reach the ideal parameters, remineralising RO water is a must.

45 minutes ago, shelbyw93 said:

Also I'll be moving back from college soon and the water there is well water that goes through a softener. They also have a drinking water filter. I suppose if water parameters were correct out of any of those sources it would be just as good as using RO mixed with tap?

Not necessarily. I recommend testing any/all water sources that goes into your tank. Never assume it is ok.

Drinking water filters are usually slightly alkaline. That means it has a pH of 7 or higher.

48 minutes ago, shelbyw93 said:

what pH, GH, KH, TDS, and hardness should I be aiming for?

For a Neocaridina which is what a Blue Velvet is, aim for

pH = 6.8 - 7.2

GH = 8-9

KH = 2-4

TDS = 180 - 190.

 

I've listed a smaller target. Sure Neos can live in parameters slightly outside those ... but then again, "Aim small, miss small". 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Must Read SKF Articles

  • Join Our Community!

    Register today, ask questions and share your shrimp and fish tank experiences with us!

  • Posts

    • sdlTBfanUK
      I may have missed something but aren't the parameters JayC quoted for Bee shrimp, but these are cherry shrimp??? Hopefully with only 2 shrimps they will survive the cycle as 2 won't make a lot of ammonia! You should try and cool the tank a bit as JayC states, you are pretty close to the limit. With Cherry shrimp you can use dechlorinated tap water, I do. The IDEAL parameters for cherry shrimp are, PH 6.5 - 7.5 TDS 150 - 250 GH 6 - 8 KH 2 - 4 Don't get too fixated if one isn't exactly in this range (ie your PH should be fine, same as mine) or where you want it, as cherry shrimp are fairly adaptable, but if you get measurements we can check those for you and let you know whether any action is required? Mine live with nitrates of 25-50 for instance, and have done for years - I am not saying they should, just that they can live outside perfect parameters. Again, if you are using tap water it is unlikely ALL the parameters are good but the thing to do is not try and get EVERY one right, especially with tap water, and if you do want to change something do it VERY slowly! Tap water is also unreliable, every time I test mine it is different? The only way around this is to use RO water and shrimp mineraliser, but I have kept mine in tap water for 5+ years ith never a problem so unless the tap water is way off I would carry on with the tap water. If you let us know the parameters we can check if it is likely to work longer term? Welcome to shrimp keeping and this forum! Simon 
    • jayc
      And Crabby covered all your additional questions here.  Great tag team!👍
    • Crabby
      No you shouldn’t, this is what is naturally good for the tank, not a chemical. Yes, mix beforehand then add. Do this weekly if possible. And if you can, purchase the api GH/KH test kit, and/or a tds pen.    Sorry I didn’t see that you had posted the same message on two different posts, jayc covered mostly the same stuff as I did. Except better of course 😉
    • Crabby
      Hey Brando, How long has the tank been set up? You said you have had shrimp for 2 days, dosed fluval cycle 3 days before that... Sometimes people can get away with using those products for fish, but it’s not good for shrimp. They don’t produce much ammonia, but they like an ‘aged’ tank. This means it has lots of tiny little creatures, absolutely microscopic, that the shrimp can eat. Along with those an aged tank will have lots of ‘biofilm’ which is what it sounds like - a biological film, and shrimp love to eat it! A shrimp’s diet consist primarily of these micro fauna, biofilm and algaes. And a 5 day old tank will barely have any of those. Since you have already got shrimp in it though, I’ll give you advice for what to do now. If the shrimp have no fishy friends they will frolick around, swimming and diving as you have noticed. This is good, it means they feel safe.  Your parameters are okay for Bloody Mary shrimp, not perfect but alright. Can you test tds or KH and Gh? Your ammonia and nitrate are a bit high, should always be 0. This is another thing that would be different if you had waited properly. In terms of ph you may want to reduce that. Temp is fine, maybe a little high, aim for mid 70s if using a heater. Can we see a photo of the tank? Thanks for joining the forum Brando, looking forward to seeing your tank improve and mature.    post note: sorry if I came off as a little abrasive, that wasn’t intended. Just trying to be clear.
    • Brando
      Hi group, i am a new shrimp keeper and have had 2 Bloody Mary shrimp for 2 days now.    I used Fluval Cycle(bio booster) for the first 3 days because that’s what is set to do on the bottle. This was used before I got the shrimp. my Temperature is 82, ph is 7.6, ammonia is 0-.25ppm , nitrite 0, nitrate 10-20ppm.  Are these levels fine? I am new to hobby!    my shrimp randomly swim up to the top and along the glass then dive down to rest/eat. Is this a bad sign they are stressed?   please leave any tips or input!  
×
×
  • Create New...